4 ms·
I'll point out the obvious - PsyStar was making duplicates of Apple's software and reselling it. There is a difference between restrictions such as "You may no
by ghshephard 17y ago
I'll point out the obvious - PsyStar was making duplicates of Apple's software and reselling it.
There is a difference between restrictions such as "You may not make copies of this software and sell it for $$$", "You may not make modifications of this software and resell it" and some fundamentally illegal restrictions. I, and most people in the community, believe that the author of software should be able to restrict whether others have to attribute them as the author, can sell duplicates of it, whether others can redistribute duplicates of it, and whether others can modify and redistribute duplicates of it. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creative_Commons http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creative_Commons.
These are separate issues from the First-Sale doctrine that you are referring to. PsyStar wasn't selling PCs with retail box purchased from Apple in the same Bag. I would have been cheering PsyStar on if that were the case.
- kls 17y agoI understand what PsyStar was doing and that was covered in my post, with the copyright portion. My post was specifically focusing on the intention that you stated. In which, rightfully so the intentions of a company after first sale are none existent. PsyStar was trying to confuse this with a host of other items to try to convolute the issue.
- ghshephard 17y agoFair enough - can we agree that we should all respect the author's intent (even after sale) when it comes to: o Whether you can distribute duplicates to others. o Whether you have to provide Attribution on duplicates o Whether you can distribute modifications o Whether you can resell duplicates for $$$
- kls 17y agoo Whether you can distribute duplicates to others. Yes and no depends on who produced the duplicate. Each OSX apple produced dvd is a duplicate of the original work. o Whether you have to provide Attribution on duplicates Yes o Whether you can distribute modifications This is dependent on copyright, but in the case of Apple's stance I would say no. o Whether you can resell duplicates for $$$ Yes, if they are duplicates produced by Apple. No, if you are producing the "back-ups" and you are just a reseller. The "US" courts have been clear on personal use back-ups before.