4 ms·
Apple Crushes Clone Maker in Court
- jrockway 17y agoHow long until your startup is crushed by someone with money that doesn't like what you're doing?
- unalone 17y agoProbably the instant I violate DMCA and break a company's user agreement. But I make it a point not to launch startups whose revenue is based on breaking the law.
- jrockway 17y agoHow long until what you're doing becomes against the law?
- unalone 17y agoAre you saying that it should be legal to steal another company's work and use it in your product? Because Apple makes a good product and I don't think it should be legal to break it and force it into your box. If I was doing something so despicable I'd hope it was against the law. I'm a happy guy, though. I trust my government not to go batshit.
- jrockway 17y agoHow is any stealing taking place? The Psystar folks are inserting a DVD they bought at the Apple Store into their computer and are booting it. They then sell that computer and DVD to someone else. (The "illegal part" is that Apple's DVD will only work if the hardware gives it a magic number. The Psystar folks made their computers give Apple's software the magic number, which is apparently a crime.) If Apple's business model is to prosecute anyone that puts their shiny widget into a computer that They Don't Like, then that is a pretty shaky business model. (But of course, that is not their business model, they are just being dicks.)
- unalone 17y agoYou can make registration codes sound silly by calling them "magic numbers" all you'd like, but they're there to make sure things go according to their designer's plans. This isn't grey territory. It's not DRM, which inconveniences anybody. It's black-and-white. Apple sells you the DVD and lets you know up front it works with Macs and only Macs. They're so nice they don't even prevent you from installing one copy of a program on a hundred Macs. And their DVD doesn't work on a non-Mac, and you know this buying it. When you get the DVD with any other intention, you're buying it with false intent. You've agreed not to do what you're about to do.
- ghshephard 17y agoThat's like suggesting that I could write some robotic surgery software and design it such that it would work only on certified surgery hardware. Oh, wait....
- jrockway 17y agoYou can do that, just don't let people buy the install DVDs at Best Buy.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jrockway 17y agoRe-purposing your own possessions is not illegal. I bought a "dining table" at IKEA, but I use it as a "computer desk". IKEA also sells "computer desks". Am I doing something illegal by not using it for the purpose they sold it to me for? Of course not. (What makes OS install DVDs so special?) Continuing with the analogy of tables, imagine there exists a set of tables and chairs and the table has special slots so that only approved chairs can slide under the table. You can use unapproved chairs, but they don't work very well, and don't slide under the table for storage. Is it a crime to saw off the things that prevent normal chairs from fitting under the table and reselling the table? So then why is it illegal when someone does the exact same thing but with software.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- pohl 17y agoThat depends: how far is what you're doing from the fringes of legality, and what is the rate of change along that frontier?
- makecheck 17y agoIf I were Apple, I'd do the same thing. There's a lot of low-level stuff in an OS to make things work smoothly. It's impressive how Apple used to go back and optimize things for G3s, while G4s and G5s were the latest models. Each model is practically running its own OS. So the last thing Apple needs is for their OS to run on hardware that they've never heard of. If something goes wrong because of hardware, it tends to manifest itself as a freezing or crashing machine. Psystar wouldn't be blamed for that, the users would simply think that Apple had made a crash-prone, piece-of-crap OS.
- jrockway 17y agoThe users would simply think that Apple had made a crash-prone, piece-of-crap OS. Turns out that this is not illegal. If you install Linux on a Macbook, people will think Macs and Linux are the same thing. Those people are dumb, and it turns out that I have no legal obligation to not confuse dumb people. Also, as someone who uses OS X on Genuine Apple Hardware, I think that Apple has made a crash-prone, piece-of-crap OS. (This is largely VLC's fault. But VLC works fine on Linux, so the problem is clearly Apple, right?) (As an aside, I wish I could post a comment at -4 so that nobody would have to waste their time downmodding it.)
- GHFigs 17y agoThis is largely VLC's fault. But VLC works fine on Linux, so the problem is clearly Apple. 10/10, A+++++, would get trolled again.
- jrockway 17y agoWhen you misquote out of context, it does sound like a troll. When you read my entire sentence in the context of the parent post, however, it is clear that I am trying to parody the "dumb user" that will blame Apple for creating crap when it's not actually Apple's fault. Oh yeah, but I kind of said something bad about Apple, and The Tribe Must Be Defended. (That part was the troll, for those of you keeping score at home.)
- rick_2047 17y agoIt would have been easier to release the machines with linux installed and post several artical/posts/tweets describing how to install OSX on it. They dont even have to use there names just some anonymous person make a cool hack for there machines. That ought to work i think, wont it?
- rightonmynigga 17y agoApple should be crushed for violating Xerox PARC's patents.