6 ms·
You Have to Hack This Massively Multiplayer Game to Beat It
- giancarlostoro 12y agoThe first challenge makes me think of the first Diablo game, in which all your player stats were hosted locally for online gameplay, so if you edited your files and gave yourself the best weapons locally, you were invinsible (or rather powerful) online as well.
- tsaoutourpants 12y agoWe generally call that cheating, not hacking, but whatever.
- sp332 12y agoTrue, however: That healing-wine hack isn’t cheating, say Jordan Wiens and Rusty Wagner, the two former Raytheon security researchers who created Pwn Adventure. In this World of Warcraft-style game, hacking the game is the game.
- Torn 12y agoEngineering the cheats and modifying the game client yourself is hacking
- cmdrfred 12y agoTo be honest this doesn't seem to be hacking or cheating, as the 'hack' is an intended part of the gameplay.
- EC1 12y agoIt certainly results in cheating, but the process is hacking.
- barkingcat 12y agoI'd argue it's not actually cheating if the game is meant to be played in such a fashion.
- EC1 12y agoIf the goal of the game is to cheat, you're still cheating. It just happens to be the main mechanism of the game.
- mburns 12y agoIf you are using the game as it is intended, you are by definition not cheating.
- BenTheElder 12y agoThe goal of the game is to 'hack' it to win. There's nothing dishonest about playing the game as intended.
- barkingcat 12y agoThat's the point of this game (according to the article) - the hack is the game, the cheat is the side effect but it's part of the game - so you have to hack to play the game.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 12y agoIf there was ever a time to not care about words and meanings this is it (or split infinitives). Also, Knuth[0] likes to play this way https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7159934 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7159934 too. [0] http://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~uno/ http://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~uno/
- cbd1984 12y ago'Cheating' is not playing the game the way your competition regards as fair. It's getting an unfair advantage by using techniques that your opponents wouldn't use. Consider this: Imagine a fighting game which is unbalanced. 'Unbalanced', here, means that one character is so inherently better that using it is a victory condition in itself; maybe it can spam a really effective move without giving the opponent a chance to retaliate. Whatever the details, the person who chooses that character is guaranteed a victory assuming they play to win. In that case, the community of people who play that game would effectively ban the character to make the game as it is played more balanced. Anyone who picks that character would be unable to find opponents, and everyone else would restrict themselves to the characters which offer both players a chance to win. My point is, in that not-entirely-contrived scenario, doing something the game software allows is cheating because it is something the game community has agreed to be cheating. Cheating has little to do with what the un-hacked code allows. In fact, in this case, hacking the code to remove the unbalanced character (or, more likely, to make that character unavailable on the selection screen) would remove a possible cheat, making the hacked version less amenable to cheating. David Sirlin wrote a book called "Playing To Win" which touches on a lot of what I just talked about. He was actually lead designer of Street Fighter HD Remix, Puzzle Fighter HD Remix, and Kongai: http://www.sirlin.net/ptw/ http://www.sirlin.net/ptw/
- BenTheElder 12y agoWell this looks fun. I'd be interested to hear about how they go about sand-boxing the server (perhaps for the previous games so as not to ruin the fun).
- psifertex 12y agoThere's no sandboxing on the server since all the challenges this year were essentially exploiting the trust relationship between the client and the server (or required reverse engineering that was just hard regardless of where the logic was). We certainly didn't /intend/ for someone to directly exploit the server, though it's always a possibility in these sorts of games. If so, they deserved the points they got (not all the flags were available even if you did hack it as some challenges were outside of the game). It was also somewhat mitigated by the fact that the game was deployed on AWS instances just for that weekend and it was easy to bring up new instances any time we needed it, so someone cracking the server could certainly cause trouble, but there really wasn't any long-term damage they could do.
- BenTheElder 12y agoThanks, sounds like it was a lot of fun.
- ccvannorman 12y agoReminds me of Code Hero, a game I once worked on -- https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/primerist/code-hero-a-game-that-teaches-you-to-make-games-he https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/primerist/code-hero-a-g... We need more games like this!
- bradjohnson 12y agoI remember playing this at PAX one year, it was a cool concept. Is the project dead now?
- ecaron 12y agoDead. https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/primerist/code-hero-a-game-that-teaches-you-to-make-games-he/posts/788367 https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/primerist/code-hero-a-g...
- ckeck 12y agoKickstarter backer here...and sadly, yes. As far as I can tell anyways. Never received anything that actually worked :(
- TillE 12y agoJust checked the website, and surprisingly there was an update yesterday. I wouldn't be terribly optimistic, but it's not completely dead. http://primerlabs.com/ http://primerlabs.com/
- nerdy 12y agoI've been involved in the gamehacking scene for longer than I'd like to admit; it's a tremendous amount of fun and feels rewarding but it's a very hollow reward. Sure, you can build programs to manipulate game clients to do all of those things. The problem is that there's most often no legitimate way to openly bring the fruit of that labor to market as a result of the MDY vs Blizzard case regarding wowglider[1] and more specifically with the DMCA. I wasn't sued but paid for intellectual property counsel to examine how the Ninth Circuit ruling would translate across the US and they didn't exactly tell me to go ahead. There are plenty of legitimate reasons to extend games, which is why WoW had LUA and many other games are at very least hooked into for parsing capabilities. These kinds of 3rd party parsers are in many cases not legal, so not openly marketable. So for anyone considering a future for-profit project, hire a lawyer and review all those nasty agreements and see how the DMCA might come back to haunt you before you're too invested in it. For anyone who's considering it for fun: Just understand that the time you spend on gamehacking probably won't result in a revenue-producing project. If you're looking to learn, gamehacking can teach you a lot about a variety of things like memory (address space/pointers/offsets), rendering, assembly code, geometric and pathfinding algorithms (Dijkstra/A*), pattern matching/signature scanning. Many of those things have real-world applications such as signature scanning for virus definitions. You'll get plenty of hexadecimal math practice. You can learn about DirectX or network traffic. You can have really enjoyable learning experiences working with games at a lower-than-intended level, but keep in mind that any time not learning is only about as well-spent as time playing video games... it's fun but incredibly addictive and they're already at "Pwn Adventure 3" so there's no end in sight! [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=MDY_Industries,_LLC_v._Blizzard_Entertainment,_Inc.&oldid=646787903 http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=MDY_Industries,_LL...
- dikaiosune 12y agoFYI, HN seems to bork that link. Tried replying with the "correct" link and something was reformatted to make it no longer work.
- nerdy 12y agoWeird... tried everything I could think of to get it to work and also could not fix it.
- whybroke 12y agoSo is it a felony to play this game as intended? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act
- BenTheElder 12y agoI am NOT a lawyer but: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act#Criminal_offenses_under_the_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act#Cr... 1) it's not a government server or data. 2) pretty sure they've authorized you to access the server. 3) see 1) 4) no fraud involved. 5) playing the game (as intended) is not causing damage. 6) no commerce involved. 7) no extortion involved. So no, I'd hazard that it is not a felony to play this game...
- psifertex 12y agoI'm really confused why people bring this up. You're not the only one, so I don't blame you in particular, but it's still strange to me. One of the key elements of CFAA is "without authorization" -- it's literally in the first sentence. Given that the explicit, stated purpose of these types of challenges (of which there are many, many other examples (https://ctftime.org/) https://ctftime.org/)) is to be backed, it'd be pretty weird to think someone could be charged under CFAA for it.
- gtank 12y agoI highly endorse this sort of thing! Reverse engineering online games is how I really got started with computers. It's a great teaching tool because the reward loop is short and immediately relevant - you get superpowers, in the game you already play with your friends, in almost direct proportion to how much you've learned. Depending on the game you'll learn about binary reversing, executable formats, networking, rendering, x86 assembly, C, JVM bytecode, or more advanced topics. We dove right into hard things because it was fun and there was no one to tell us they were too hard for kids. The end result among my group of friends seems to be several careers in tech with a decided systems and security skew. edit: I remember Runescape in particular. They applied such an escalating series of obfuscations to the client code and network protocol that we deployed things I now recognize as AST analysis and machine learning to work past them. These days, I really wonder what the view from the Jagex security team was like. Did they have fun constantly coming up with new challenges for bored teenagers?
- stickydink 12y agoI too got into my game development career by essentially, trying to hack Runescape. I sank an unhealthy amount of my early teenage years working on Runescape bots, for both original and RS2. Every time I think back on it, so many happy and exciting memories. From AutoRune scripts, to writing bots, to computer vision, all for one game. That turned into an obsession with an industry that had me move half way across the world to work on our own multiplayer virtual worlds. The community was pretty active, and at one point I was building/hosting the most-used public bots/sites. I can imagine our paths crossed one-way or another at some point!
- gtank 12y agoI have a very similar set of good memories. I put more time into deobfuscation, updating, detection evasion, and (eventually) server emulation than bots per se. My contact info is in my profile, it would be cool to see if we ran into each other back then.
- rampant 12y agoMe too! It was such a fantastic experience in retrospect. I've never been so incentivized to learn than during my reverse engineering years. I started off writing SCAR scripts for Runescape and then got into development for the Aryan bot and private RS servers (if any of those ring any bells). I remember deobfuscation tools being consistently released and updated, but I left the runescape scene for warcraft before I could that far involved. I have a friend who worked on anti-cheat technology for a very well known gaming company. He in fact started off selling hacks for said company and was hired to protect against them many years later. It was entertaining because part of his job was to maintain his old aliases and create new ones and frequent all the hacking forums and IRC channels to listen in on all the discussions. He would even sometimes contribute random information as part of his ruse. The best part is when his team would leave secret messages to hack developers (like in the byte patterns of the signature scans or embedded within the anti-cheat modules that were being mapped into memory). They had a great sense of humor and the hacking community picked up on it and loved it. I think coming from our background and having to work in a security capacity like that would be fun as hell. It's very open-ended and like a never ending cat-and-mouse game. I'm sure the Jagex security team felt a similar drive back in the day.
- ShaneWilton 12y agoPwnadventure 3 debuted at the Ghost in the Shellcode CTF this year, and it was an absolute blast. If anyone is hoping to break into security or CTFs, I can't recommend this contest enough. I play as part of the team that placed 2nd this year, Samurai, and all of us were in awe at how well put together the problems were, and how great the experience was overall. Here's a link to a writeup I did of one of the quests, that involved reverse engineering a massive circuit, then using it to open a locked door: https://medium.com/@shanewilton/ghost-in-the-shellcode-2015-blockys-revenge-7074a119115e https://medium.com/@shanewilton/ghost-in-the-shellcode-2015-... The official website for the CTF is here: http://ghostintheshellcode.com/ http://ghostintheshellcode.com/ Edit: If you enjoyed that writeup, here is a (In my opinion), much more interesting writeup I did of a similar problem last year: https://medium.com/@shanewilton/9447-ctf-2014-hellomike-writeup-ba812f012d5 https://medium.com/@shanewilton/9447-ctf-2014-hellomike-writ...
- borski 12y agoI like to think I'm good at this stuff, but that HelloMike writeup still boggles my mind. I need to get better at NFAs, etc.
- iosengineer 12y agoHack'n'Slash goes MMORPG!
- psifertex 12y agoOur first previous version of the game (ghostintheshellcode.com/#pwnadventure2) was also a 3d hackable MMORPG and was released earlier than Hack N Slash. So really it was more like PwnAdventure went 2d. ;-)
- pulverizer 12y agoI remember years ago in a multi-player shooting game. I switched clothing index in the client code. So to me the enemies are wearing vivid jungle color while running in snow scenes and bright white color while hiding in jungle scenes. Easy to pick them up at a distance with my machine gun. I was Pulverizer.
- mkoryak 12y agoI once "hacked" an online game called bombermine and made myself a god(or at least able to kill anyone) by exploiting a few bugs I found: http://imgur.com/a/QeYJ7 http://imgur.com/a/QeYJ7 Some day i should do a writeup about the man in the middle thing i had to build to make this possible
- z3t4 12y agoWhat you should learn from game programming about security is to: Never thrust the client! I'm baffled that in games like Minecraft, the server sends all blocks to the client, instead of just the blocks that are visible. Or that you can give yourself any weapon and infinite ammo in DayZ. etc ...
- asgard1024 12y agoTo be fair, it's very hard to do, especially in a sandbox game - the computer has not only to have a good model of the world, but also a model of how the client sees the world. And in Minecraft it's not really a problem, because the game is more cooperative than competitive.
- EGreg 12y agoAnyone played RoboWar for the mac? Anything comparable out today with a community?
- RockofStrength 12y agoThis reminds me of the silly tight melee formations in Myth 2 that were necessary to compete online.