3 ms·
Your gold standard meta-analysis is useless for the purposes of someone actually trying to lose weight. It merely takes the position that diet and exercise prod
by vinceguidry 12y ago
Your gold standard meta-analysis is useless for the purposes of someone actually trying to lose weight. It merely takes the position that diet and exercise produce better outcomes than either alone. That tells us nothing about which has the more powerful effect.
Anybody who's actually tried, and succeeded, in losing weight and keeping it off will tell you that diet is way more important than exercise when it comes to fat loss. Exercise absolutely produces health benefits, but they are largely orthogonal to the ones produced by changing how you eat. If you can do one but not the other, then diet.
Most people with a lot of weight to lose have willpower problems, that's why they have a lot of weight in the first place. Not all, but most. These people are better served conserving their willpower and taking more effective courses of action than the one they can't take. (both diet and exercise)
- DanBC 12y agoDid you read the paper? You start by saying it's useless; then you repeat what it says.