3 ms·
This combines much of what I've wanted in a voting system: o Physical Tokens - Something people can see and touch. Something that human beings can physically
by ghshephard 17y ago
This combines much of what I've wanted in a voting system:
o Physical Tokens - Something people can see and touch. Something that human beings can physically recount if they have to and will (at random) to confirm that the automated system has not been compromised.
o Cryptographic Verification - I can check after the fact to determine if my vote was counted. Supposedly only 2% of the population needs to check to determine if there was a compromise.
o Simple Counting system - The computer code required to count how many votes were cast for each party should be relatively straight forward and easy to verify.
After thinking about this for a while I'm not sure what happens with the False Positives - what if I write my number down incorrectly and can't find it after voting. I suspect that a certain number (0.5%?) will do so and now be convinced that there was fraud with the new system. Possible downside. Of course, the electoral commissioner will be able to take this into account - Let's say we have 100 Million people voting, and that 4% of those check their votes, and that 0.5 % of the people who checked their votes wrote the number down incorrectly, and 10% of those people report it to the electoral commissioner, there should be about 2,000 reports, on average, of Fraud.
Now - what about DELIBERATE false positive - an attack on this system is now to have the losing party overwhelm the electoral commissioner with reports of fraud.
The great thing about a system with Physical Tokens (Paper) is you can have scrutineers from both parties, in the presence of independent observers, _physically watch people count tokens and challenge_
Physical Ballot Box stuffing in a first world country is next to impossible, as long as you have strong representation from the population during the casting of votes and counting.
I hate the idea of purely electronic voting for things where the incentive to cheat is huge, and the recourse for the ordinary citizen to help ensure that the count is fair is absent.
Let's hope that this system (or something like it) takes off.
- bayareaguy 17y agoI write my number down incorrectly and can't find it after voting. Straightforward error correction techniques would help identify and compensate for minor errors and simple adding machine style recipt printers incorporating such logic could be made available within voting booths. Voters who want a recipt would just type the revealed code into the printer.