5 ms·
You are right that most place and cancel orders rapidly, but that isn't necessarily spoofing, which requires some intentionality. For example, Nasdaq even has
by cma 12y ago
You are right that most place and cancel orders rapidly, but that isn't necessarily spoofing, which requires some intentionality. For example, Nasdaq even has an order type that auto-adjusts itself such that it will never execute, but it was mainly created to help market-makers dodge quoting requirements, not to enable spoofing.
In symbols where they are a registered market-maker, market-makers are supposed to be obligated to make a market in the symbol. In exchange they get several regulatory benefits, like being able to naked short a stock (sell it without even locating/borrowing the shares).
In practice most automated market-makers used to just put out bogus quotes they never expected to fill at $0.1/$1000000.0 bid/ask. The SEC tried to regulate this and say you had to really be making a market and put your quotes within X% of the current bid/ask. Market-makers started automatically cancelling and replacing at exactly X% away, but that was too much for them. So they had Nasdaq create an order type that automatically cancels itself and replaces it X% away from the bid/ask anytime the NBBO changes.
What they are doing in that example is completely wrong, but not analogous to what the guy in this article was allegedly doing (this guy put his quotes near the money to make fake interest, market-makers put theirs as far away from the money as possible to be fake market-makers and get regulatory benefits like naked shorting in exchange, their orders don't appear like real buy/sell interest in the same way this guy's allegedly did).
---
The author of the article tries to distance algorithmic-HFT from this guy operated, to cleanse its name, but come one:
Sarao may have been a spoofer, but he doesn't seem to
have been doing the sort of high-speed algorithmic
trading that usually qualifies as "HFT." He himself
claimed to be "'an old school point and click prop
trader' who had 'always been good with reflexes and
doing things quick,'" and the "Layering Algorithm"
that he used was a customized version of "a program
that allowed non-programmers to engage in automated
trading using spreadsheet commands and functions." He
was also the sole owner and employee of his trading
firm, which he "operated from his residence." In style
and substance he is not all that different from other
spoofers we have known and loved, who did their high
speed trading by just punching keys really fast.
In style and point-and-click background maybe he wasn't a goliath HFT operation, but in substance, spreadsheet automated trading at faster than human speeds, he definitely was.
--
If the charges hold up, they will have been able to convict this guy because of evidence of intentionality (the emails to his FCM). But with trading strategies now starting to delve into modern deep-learning techniques, we're probably going to start seeing algorithms learn to spoof from a blank slate. The only way to tell if one of these algorithms is really intending to buy or sell or is spoofing would be to reverse engineer something rather inscrutable... And is it the author's intentionality or the algorithm's we're really concerned with? Likely we'll end up holding things to some gamable metrics that will do about as good a job as the market-maker quoting requirements do in assuring market-maker algorithms are providing liquidity.
- ikeboy 12y agoWouldn't that be illegal under Dodd-Frank then?
- bko 12y agoDo you know the name of that type of order?
- DeanWormer 12y agoHe's probably referring to a Market Maker Pegged Order.
- justonepost 12y agoThanks! Love HN.
- devinhelton 12y agoIt seems like the real fix would be to have a cancellation fee. If an order is canceled within 60 seconds, penalize the trader .1% of the total amount of the order. That would make all this gamesmanship unprofitable, and the order book would actually be a collection of people wanting to buy and sell shares. It seems very wrong to me to make an activity feasible, and allow it to be profitable, but then arbitrarily drop the hammer of criminal penalties when a trader crosses some murky line.
- pas 12y agoThere already is. If you add liquidity you get a bit of a bonus, if you remove it (cancel your limit order), you are charged a small amount. Why are people so fixated on the order book? The real information is the spot price and how fresh is that information (and the volume), the order book is a fantasy anyhow. There are people willing to buy stuff at pennies always, and sell at thousands. How does that help you? What if they cancel? It shouldn't matter if someone does it closer to the spot price, or closer to the best bid-offer. If you want to buy, look at the price, decide how much you think it's worth, put in a limit order at that price. Go to bed. If you want to sell, basically do the same. If you want to live on trading, then smarten up.