4 ms·
Is the argument in your second paragraph still valid when we replace the word "scammers" with "murderers"? If not, why not?
by hollerith 12y ago
Is the argument in your second paragraph still valid when we replace the word "scammers" with "murderers"? If not, why not?
- bko 12y agoI'm not the author of the original comment but I think scams are a lot more subjective and often are the result of a series of completely legal actions. The only identifying attribute of a scam be the intent of the actions, which is subjective. The act of murder is illegal in its own right, although sometimes justified in the legal system. I think the original commenter's point was that if you take for granted that people will act ethically with no ulterior motives, you lose a healthy skepticism that is very beneficial to a market.
- fineman 12y agoAre most analogies valid if you replace one party with nazis? Murder isn't an economic action bordering on indistinguishable from normal interactions. Publishing some bids you don't really want accepted is.