2 ms·
> Just a note, you cannot see the last part ("her comment has subsequently been downvoted because people disagree"), only assume it. When the comment is not ab
by stephenr 12y ago
> Just a note, you cannot see the last part ("her comment has subsequently been downvoted because people disagree"), only assume it.
When the comment is not abusive, trolling, etc, the specific reason (I don't agree with her. I don't like girls!. She used the word "who" instead of "whom". etc) doesn't matter - it's a vote based on personal opinion of the comment (or the commenter), not based on the objective value of the comment.
> Upvoting/downvoting is best interpreted as "this comment is what I want to see on HN"
So, own it then. Make it blatantly clear that you expect and encourage people to shape HN comments to their own world view, regardless of reality.
> How does downvoting comments that contribute to a kind of HN you don't want to see and upvoting those that contribute to a kind of HN you do want to see not make sense?
The "kind of HN I want to see" is the kind where differing opinions are accepted. When that opinion differs from enough people who down vote, not only do they not see the comment, neither do I.
Seriously how is this point hard to understand?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 12y ago> When the comment is not abusive, trolling, etc, the specific reason (I don't agree with her. I don't like girls!. She used the word "who" instead of "whom". etc) doesn't matter - it's a vote based on personal opinion of the comment (or the commenter), not based on the objective value of the comment. Abusive and trolling are not objective things, they are subjective assessments (trolling is, particularly, a subjective conclusion about the intent inferred to underlie the content posted.) All downvotes are based on personal opinion of the comment. As are all upvotes.