3 ms·
This sounds like it may be possible only because of the exceptionally weak US-UK extradition treaty, which gives the USA unusually strong powers to grab people
by mike_hearn 12y ago
This sounds like it may be possible only because of the exceptionally weak US-UK extradition treaty, which gives the USA unusually strong powers to grab people from the UK without any equivalent ability for the UK to extradite people from the USA. The one-sidednesss of this agreement has caused political problems before as it is seem as epitomising the slavishness of British politicians to Washington.
If "spoofing" was really only outlawed in the Dodd Frank act then it seems likely that most countries wouldn't have any laws against it, and an extradition would fail on the grounds that what Sarao is accused of would not be a crime in his country of origin.
I'm sure the UK Government will love the idea of sending a trader to the dogs in America regardless of whether or not this is actually illegal in the UK itself, just because it's election time and like all politicos everywhere they want to be seen as whacking financial types. But it seems to lead to a bad precedent. If trading strategies can be simply made illegal in a law so large even the people who voted on it didn't read it, then how can anyone really know if their trades are illegal or not?
- tptacek 12y agoThe last time this was hashed out on HN, all the available documentation seemed to establish that the UK-US extradition treaty had recently changed --- to correct an imbalance that had historically favored the UK, and is now more equitable.
- learnstats2 12y agoEquitable? Why does it matter if this is equitable? In practice, UK citizens now have to obey US law or risk being extradited - in this case, for conducting their work legally in their home country. This is not right.
- tptacek 12y agoYou cannot be extradited from the UK to the US for things that aren't crimes in the UK. Check out the treaty.
- learnstats2 12y agoThis doesn't seem to me to be true in practice, e.g. Not a crime in the UK at the time http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/norris-loses-us-extradition-battle-but-says-he-will-appeal-877866.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/norris-loses... UK citizen entrapped by US agent (entrapment would likely be thrown out of a UK court, but is now being tried in the US...): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christopher_Tappin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christopher_Tappin Even if the treaty is applied in this way, which it doesn't seem to be, US penalties are still not appropriate for UK citizens. The UK has abolished the death penalty on human rights grounds - and yet the UK government can send someone over to the US for this punishment. If you commit a UK crime on UK soil, you should be subject to UK punishment, and you should not be the subject of the law and punishment of any and all nations of the world.
- tptacek 12y agoCan you be clearer about what crime Norris is being charged with that is illegal in the US but not illegal in the UK? Every European country extradites only on the provision that the death penalty will not be sought. It's also part of the ECHR. Your last sentence suggests that your problem isn't the specifics of the extradition treaty, but rather the concept of extradition in general.
- learnstats2 12y ago> Your last sentence suggests that your problem isn't the specifics of the extradition treaty, but rather the concept of extradition in general. You misrepresent what I said. I don't particularly object to extradition for crimes committed in US law on US soil, although I do think countries have a responsibility to protect their own citizens first and foremost (which is surely the primary purpose of nations). If an extradition treaty means I am effectively subject to inter-national law while in my home country, then I object, yes, very much.
- mike_hearn 12y agoCould you link to that discussion? The article here suggests otherwise: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK%E2%80%93US_extradition_treaty_of_2003 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK%E2%80%93US_extradition_trea...
- beagle3 12y ago> If "spoofing" was really only outlawed in the Dodd Frank act then it seems likely that most countries wouldn't have any laws against it, and an extradition would fail on the grounds that what Sarao is accused of would not be a crime in his country of origin. "spoofing" has generally been outlawed since forever - at the very least since 1934. Dodd Frank may have defined spoofing better, but "intent to execute" (which, in imprecise language is the complement of "spoofing") has been a requirement for much much longer, and in every regulated exchange in just about any country. But even if it was only outlawed in 2010 and only in the US - Sarao was trading the CME -- that's the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, thereby putting himself in the jurisdiction of US trading laws.
- fineman 12y agoWe can't legislate that you don't spoof - it'll simply be an arms race. If you want to participate in a market without spoofers, simply require a deposit for offers cancelled within a certain period of time. The problem is that the market is only capable of defending against what it is used to dealing with, if we "ban" scammers we end up with a market susceptible to scammers. If we "allow" everything we'll end up with markets that can withstand a sybil attacks. As another poster said, the "correct" metric is accepted offers, not outstanding offers. ("Correct" is complex of course...) It's like passing laws making web-scraping for email addresses into hacking. It feels like it'll make us safer, but because "only criminals have guns" it just ends up shooting a few people in the foot and weakening us overall against actual threats.
- beagle3 12y ago> We can't legislate that you don't spoof - it'll simply be an arms race. If you want to participate in a market without spoofers, simply require a deposit for offers cancelled within a certain period of time. That's like saying "we can't legislate vendors don't do a bait-and-switch" or "we can't legislate against false advertising". We can, we have, and it made life better for society at large. The false advertising arms race is still on - but the collateral damage to consumers is significantly smaller than it was before those laws were enacted. We can legislate "don't spoof", and we have (for some proverbial we), but any law is useless without enforcement - and there is no enforcement for these regulations. Additionally, at present the SEC is a part of the spoofing arms race, and is massively (and some say willingly due to regulatory capture) underfunded and incompetent in that race with no intent to win. You want to legislate it so that it has teeth? Publish pseudonymized order flow six months after the fact (changing identifiers every day, for example), and give someone who can use this data to prove spoofing 10% of the proceeds of any fines levied thanks to their work. (Sure, pseudonymity is hard, and may be impossible. But 6 months after the fact is enough time for that to matter little in case of trades). You want to stop it without changing enforcement mechanism? Charge for unexecuted orders, or otherwise limit their numbers. In fact, some european exchanges have very stiff penalties if you have >10:1 ratio of orders:fills - and spoofing there is almost nonexistent. But SEC behaviour indicates that they have no intention of fixing that aspect of the market. > It's like passing laws making web-scraping for email addresses into hacking. It feels like it'll make us safer, but because "only criminals have guns" it just ends up shooting a few people in the foot and weakening us overall against actual threats. No, it's not. Exchanges are few and (supposedly) extremely well regulated. The number of "bad actors" (spoofers or otherwise) is also small and under strict regulation. Your claim that it is is nonsensical. An equivalent claim is "It's like making shooting people in the streets a crime. It feels like it'll make us safer, because only criminals will shoot people but it ends up weakening us overall against actual threats". We have made that a crime, we've done what's needed to enforce those laws, and it has made us stronger, not weaker.