12 ms·
Supreme Court Rules Extending Traffic Stop for Dog Sniff Unconstitutional [pdf]
- ghshephard 12y agoThis ruling just created a great business opportunity for those companies creating technology that can effectively emulate a dog's smell-sensing capability.
- anigbrowl 12y agoThis articulation that the tolerable extent of a stop (or any other investigation) 'is limited to the [personal] seizure's mission' is an excellent articulation of principle that might have a bearing on many other cases. See for example this one - I have no idea whether this is appeallable procedurally (given the time that has elapsed since the conviction and so on) but the principle has troubled me ever since I read about it 5 years ago: http://www.alternet.org/story/146064/loud_sex_enough_for_cops_to_search_your_home,_court_rules http://www.alternet.org/story/146064/loud_sex_enough_for_cop... Here a police officer who reasonably suspected a rape or some similarly violent crime based on reports of loud screaming visited a home. Defendant explained that the screaming took place in the course of enthusiastic sexual activity and Defendant's girlfriend corroborated this explanation. The police officer nevertheless requested permission to search, which was granted. During the search, marijuana was discovered and defendant was arrested for that. To my mind the admissibility of evidence found during a search should have been limited to the original purpose; while it would not be entirely unreasonable to confiscate contraband found during a search, but it's not reasonable to prosecute the guy on that basis. Where it gets tricky is prioritizing the things you prosecute. To see why, turn it around - suppose the police officer knocked on the door to investigate an allegation of drug possession or trafficking, but in the course of the investigation discovered the perpetration of a rape or murder. We would not want the perpetrator of such a crime to get away with it just because the police officer was unaware of it during an initial legitimate investigation and stumbled across the evidence by accident.
- DannyBee 12y ago"To my mind the admissibility of evidence found during a search should have been limited to the original purpose; while it would not be entirely unreasonable to confiscate contraband found during a search, but it's not reasonable to prosecute the guy on that basis. " Sorry, but if a person who owned the place consented, the end result is always admissible. Period. If they didn't consent, it would be different. I can't see why you think this reasoning would ever apply here.
- sparkzilla 12y agoWhich is why you never consent
- anigbrowl 12y agoI didn't make it clear in my original comment (but see the other one in this thread) that I'm making a normative rather than a positive argument. I think the basis of consent ought to involve limitations of scope, such that discovery of a minor crime during the fruitless investigation of a major one should be treated differently. We want people to be cooperative with the police so as to minimize the incidence of violent crimes like the one the state troopers originally arrived to investigate. It's understandable that a neighbor got worried and called 911 (although we'll never know if the neighbor was genuinely worried or just irritated by the sexy sex noise). It's absolutely understandable that police would want to verify that no violence was going on after receiving such a report, even with the reasonable alternative explanation of sexual activity. It's much harder to argue that McGacken's 10 year prison sentence has made society any better off. The cost of trying and imprisoning him may well exceed the social cost of his production (and presumable sale) of marijuana, but they have definitely reduced the incentive of people to cooperate with police investigating other crimes. To me this is a prime example of how 'the life of the law has not been logic, [but] experience' - the law has been consistently applied, but the result seems extremely unfair and may even have had negative economic utility.
- Retra 12y agoYou really can't trust the police if they aren't looking out for your best interest.
- dsp1234 12y agoThere are some important differences between the case that you cite and this case. Specifically, in this case the officer said that he had no reasonable suspicion that another crime occurred, and the dog sniffing was not part of the exception for "officer safety". In the case you cited, the officers had an objective "reasonable suspicion" that a crime occurred (though obviously the accused in the case suggested it was not objectively reasonable, the court disagreed). Then during an investigation of the house, both for evidence of the crime in question, and to check the area for officer safety, the marijuana was found. If evidence of a crime if found while investigating a different crime (where the reasonable suspicion is met) or where it falls under the exception for "officer safety", then it's fair game. This decision doesn't change that standard, or even touch it since reasonable suspicion, and officer safety were not relevant to this case, and were relevant to the cited case. So on the surface, they may appear similar, but hit different points of the law. On the flip side, had evidence of the meth been visible in this case, or the officer had any other reasonable suspicion of a crime, then this case would have likely been decided differently.
- xaa 12y agoThe question of whether the officer had reasonable suspicion here seems to be in dispute. The lower courts found there was no reasonable suspicion, and the majority assumed that in their response. Alito and Thomas' dissents cite some fairly compelling evidence that the officer did have reasonable suspicion: the vehicle occupants looked nervous, the officer smelled the overwhelming scent of air freshener (often used to mask drugs), and their story didn't make much sense. The dissents are a really good read: I'm against the drug war full stop but had to admit that within our current legal framework, this decision doesn't make much sense.
- belovedeagle 12y agoSee page 9 of the ruling: the Court did not rule on reasonable suspicion in this case, and Ginsberg tells it like it is regarding the dissenters' focus. IANAL, but I think the gov't might be able to appeal right back up to SCOTUS on that issue if they think they can win, and it sounds like they could.
- Wingman4l7 12y agoGood; now we need to extend this to TSA overreach. They are (ostensibly) there to prevent weapons from making it onto airplanes, not to investigate large sums of cash or bust people for narcotics possession: http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2009/nov/11/rules-changed-after-paul-aide-detained-at-airport/?page=all http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2009/nov/11/rules-change...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- hacknat 12y agoThis is great news, because other than DUI check points or being stopped by an officer with a dog in their patrol-car (which is just bad luck), I don't see that the police have a way around this one. I don't have any data, but I read in The New Jim Crow (good book, fyi) that this procedure accounts for an incredible amount of drug arrests. Good on ya, SCOTUS.
- BryanB55 12y ago>> this procedure accounts for an incredible amount of drug arrests. Good on ya, SCOTUS So are you saying you don't think people should be arrested for drugs? How is it good that it is now harder to arrest for possession?
- trose 12y agoYes, people shouldn't be arrested for possession.
- wmeredith 12y agoJust What Is So Wrong With the War on Drugs? [https://www.aclu.org/blog/speakeasy/just-what-so-wrong-war-drugs?redirect=blog/criminal-law-reform/just-what-so-wrong-war-drugs https://www.aclu.org/blog/speakeasy/just-what-so-wrong-war-d...]
- trhway 12y ago>So are you saying you don't think people should be arrested for drugs? How is it good that it is now harder to arrest for possession? weighting between some people not being arrested for drugs vs. police routinely violating Constitution?
- dragonwriter 12y ago> How is it good that it is now harder to arrest for possession? It would be easier to arrest for possession if searches, seizures, and arrests didn't require probable cause, and police could just arrest anyone, anywhere for any reason or none at all -- and search anything anywhere without consent for any reason or none at all, and use any evidence so obtained in prosecution. Much of the Bill of Rights -- and much of the concept of individual rights against government underlying and preceding it -- is based on the belief that making it easier for the government to arrest and prosecute people even for things that everyone agrees are bad is often less of a benefit than the powers granted to government in order to achieve that are a harm. So that's at least one school of thought on how this could be good even though it makes it harder to arrest for possession, even if one things that arrests for possession (where actual possession occurs) are a good thing.
- etjossem 12y agoBefore you tell your friends that Jay-Z has only 98 problems now: Rodriguez v. US doesn't say a dog sniff can't be part of a traffic stop. Alito mentioned in a separate dissent that - as a result of this ruling - he expects officers to change the sequence the activities involved in a traffic stop so that the license check and citation are not completed until a dog sniff is done. This ruling may be a bit of a moot point, except in cases where officers don't follow the proscribed sequence of events.
- hacknat 12y agoRead the opinion carefully, it explicitly says that the order of events is not justification enough. You are right in saying that this doesn't prohibit dog sniffs in all traffic stops. Period. However, you are wrong that stating that a dog sniff can be justified by simple ordering, see page 8: >>The critical question, then, is not whether the dog sniff occurs before or after the officer issues a ticket, as JUSTICE ALITO supposes, post, at 2–4, but whether conducting the sniff “prolongs”—i.e., adds time to—“the stop,” supra, at 6. and page 7: >>a dog sniff, unlike the routine measures just mentioned, is not an ordinary incident of a traffic stop SCOTUS is in fact saying that a dog sniff must be supported by what they call "individualized suspicion".
- lsiebert 12y agoNow they will simply add an extra officer. As long as he conducts the search while the other officer does traffic related things, I don't see how this would prevent a dog sniff search.
- dragonwriter 12y agoTo do that, you'd have to know in advance which officers were going to be making traffic stops in which they would want an excuse to make an otherwise unconstitutional excuse so you could preposition K9 units to assist them, or you'd have to have every patrol car have two officers and a dog. Either of these is impractical.
- SilasX 12y agoSometimes police will threaten to summon the K9 if you don't consent to a search. [1] If extending a stop for dog sniffs is now unconstitutional, does that mean any officer using this tactic was making an illegal threat, and thus any search thereafter must be thrown out as coercive? [1] At least, that's how the ACLU videos portray it; don't know how common this really is.
- MBlume 12y agoI suspect you'd need to call their bluff and then try to get whatever the K9 find thrown out (assuming they had to delay you to let them arrive)
- SilasX 12y agoThat would work also, but the thing is, even if they never summoned the K9, they are threatening to, and the law distinguishes between the police making legal vs. illegal threats. That is, if the threaten to run your license plate, that's fine because it's legal (even if it would find something bad). But if they threaten to ram your car or take your kids, then any consent you gave would be (IIRC) inadmissible as being under duress. This ruling would suggest that the K9 threat falls under the latter.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ctdonath 12y agoCall their bluff with "am I free to go?" Otherwise they'll use all kinds of squishy terms to persuade you to stay for the search when you don't have to. Recording it, of course, would be vital. IANAL, YMMV.
- dbbolton 12y agoRealistically a police officer in the US does not have to worry about such "illegal threats". Manipulating people into letting them fish for evidence is a pretty standard part of the job. Most likely a judge isn't going to throw out a search except when there is an egregious error on LE's part. E.g. if the suspect clearly stated "I do not consent to any searches. Am I being detained? If I am not being detained then I want to leave" and an officer proceeded to search anyway or detained the person, it would probably get thrown out, assuming there was video/audio evidence. If not, it's the cop's word against the defendant's (I'll let you guess whose the judge will believe). But if the cop lies and says you have to wait for a K9 unit, and you believe him without asking if you're being detained, anything that dog finds is likely going to be fair game just as if you were bullied into consenting to a search (a friend of mine once refused consent to a vehicle search and was then told by the officer that such a refusal constituted probable cause, so he relented out of fear). Keep in mind that this is all without probable cause. If they have probable cause, they can detain you and make you wait for a dog. With the Rodriguez case specifically, there was "erratic driving" which is likely enough cause for most judges.
- pXMzR2A 12y agotl;dr > The critical question is not whether the dog sniff occurs before or after the officer issues a ticket, but whether conducting the sniff adds time to the stop. [p. 3]
- lsiebert 12y agoYep. Expect two officers from now on, one to have the dog sniff while the other deals with the traffic citation.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Expect two officers from now on, one to have the dog sniff while the other deals with the traffic citation. If police departments could afford to make every existing single-officer patrol unit a two-officer K-9 unit, they'd already do that.
- vizeroth 12y agoWhile the K-9 may not be possible for most departments, I know a few departments in Virginia started requiring all units to have a minimum of two officers because gas prices were too high to send a second car every time they needed a second officer on the scene. Of course, the San Diego County Sheriff's Department can't seem to shut off the engine, park legally, or fit more than one officer in an SUV.
- stephen-mw 12y agoTurning down an optional search of your persons or belongings does not constitute reasonable suspicion. I wish the courts would have sent a stronger message to this point. Clearly Officer Struble interpreted mr. Rodriguez decline as a reason to be suspicious of him. Always say no. Always decline. This needs to be come the default/norm. Read about how inaccurate field substance tests are here[0]. People go to jail for this stuff even though they are law-abiding citizens who actually _didn't_ have anything to hide. http://stopthedrugwar.org/chronicle/2009/mar/06/feature_citing_startling_researc http://stopthedrugwar.org/chronicle/2009/mar/06/feature_citi...
- spiritplumber 12y agoI'm worried that it will.
- freerobby 12y agoIt's pretty demoralizing to me that there are 3 SCOTUS justices who think it's Constitutional to detain people without probable cause as long as it's not for very long. As I think Justice Roberts once quipped, if you "briefly" hold someone without cause, you've "briefly" violated their Constitutional rights.
- justonepost 12y agoI disagree. That's not the problem. The issue here is not the detention, it's the dog sniff. Why didn't the cop just ask in the beginning if he minded if he did the dog sniff? Why can't a cop just call in the dog squad while he lingers going through the paperwork of a regular traffic stop? That's what is going to happen here. He's not detaining, he's just finishing up the traffic stop. what's demoralizing here is the war on drugs is getting us nowhere except rampant crime, huge homicide rates, and over crowded prisons full of minorities.
- MCRed 12y agoIf everyone who opposed the War on Drugs had instead of voting for it's Architect in the last two elections, or the other guy, had actually voted for either the Green Party or Libertarian Party candidates, things would be very different in this country. Even if both the Greens and Libertarians still lost, the Democrats and Republicans would have been shocked out of complacency and rushing to end the war on drugs. The problem is, everyone's voting for evil because they fear the other evil is greater.... yet there were two "Good" candidates running!
- btdollar 12y agoIt's the US voting system! Imagine if we hadn't voted for the other guy, then the architect(s) would be back in there a third year. I saw a thought experiment once on choosing lunch with coworkers under a US-style voting system showing why it inevitably ends up being bipartisan. It was fantastic, I sure wish I could find it again.
- Lorento 12y ago
- krschultz 12y agoThe supreme court often times feels like the only institution protecting the rights of the citizens. If they ever flip, it's pretty much game over.
- greenmountin 12y agoThe opposition did a terrible job of defending dog sniffs during the oral arguments. They could not articulate a reasonable rule for when they should be allowed (except that they were ok until the ticket was written). The justices repeatedly presented hypotheticals, but the guy just didn't get it. [1hr MP3 of oral arguments] http://www.oyez.org/cases/2010-2019/2014/2014_13_9972 http://www.oyez.org/cases/2010-2019/2014/2014_13_9972
- spacemanmatt 12y agoAll drugs should be legal.
- robot22 12y agoI agree the entire argument is a farce. Only antibiotics should be regulated.
- ctdonath 12y agoThe issue at hand isn't drug legality, it's delayed exercise of rights. There are other enumerated & implied rights which are equally trampled on by undue delays: right to assembly & free speech, delayed by requiring slowly-approved public assembly permits; right to keep & bear arms, delayed by long background checks & permit/license approvals (days or months when such information could be processed in seconds); right to speedy trial, often delayed for years; etc.
- beedogs 12y agoFinally, the Roberts court gets one right.
- aidenn0 12y agoIANAL, but this is probably still allowed in Virginia, since all traffic violations are arrestable offenses, they have cause to detain you.
- twoquestions 12y agoI fail to see how this matters. As it stands it's perfectly legal to lie to you about the consequences of not consenting to a search, and even outright cold blooded murder on a police officer's part is extremely difficult to seek justice for. It is a tiny step in the right direction though, hopefully followed by more.
- moey 12y agoIsn't it strange that its normal and "constitutional" for a unrelated dog sniffing to occur "during" (before the ticket is given) a traffic stop but not after. What allows to to be legal during but not after? They cited safety reasons, but I don't understand how searching for unrelated contraband increases the safety of the officer in any way.
- unprepare 12y agoSeems obvious to me that it would make the situation much more tense, and thus more likely for something unsafe to happen. Even people who dont have drugs arent going to be comfortable being treated in that manner, and people are already on edge when they get pulled over.
- chrismcb 12y agoAllowing a dog sniff to be reasonable suspicion is what is strange. But unfortunately it is. If you are stopped, such that the police dog can sniff your car, then they can sniff your car. But the cops can't stop you just to let the dog sniff, without more suspicion. Since the car is stopped for a traffic stop, it gives a chance for the dog to go work. Put it another way, the cop is standing on the side of a road near a traffic light. If the car is stopped at the light, the dog can sniff away. But the cop can't stop you, or hold you longer than the light.