27 ms·
The Cray 2 Super Computer (1985) [pdf]
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI find it interesting to review and contrast the architecture of super computers with modern day processors. The clock speed and memory quantity are higher, but often there are large differences in memory bandwidth and I/O bandwidth. This shows the Cray 2 with multiple 4 Gbit paths to I/O (think PCIe x ~2).
- dm2 12y agoThis table indicates that PCIe v2 is 4 Gbit/s per lane (64 Gbit/s for 16 lanes) and PCIe v4 is almost 16 Gbit/s per lane (up to 252 Gbit/s total). Is this correct or am I misunderstanding what you are saying? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PCI_Express#History_and_revisions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PCI_Express#History_and_revisio...
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI was thinking PCI Express, Version 1, by 2 lanes. There are four of those if I read correctly which would be essentially 8 lanes of ver1 PCIe. Rather a bit more I/O bandwidth than your iPhone has, but not as much as say a current desktop.
- dm2 12y agoHere is an interesting page: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_device_bandwidths http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_device_bandwidths
- userbinator 12y agoTo put the specs in more modern terms, it's roughly a 64-bit quadcore with 2GB of RAM and a clock speed around 250MHz. Enormously powerful for 1985, but probably slower than a typical desktop system in 2005. No mention of secondary storage... but with 2GB of RAM, maybe it didn't need any?
- ChuckMcM 12y agoDisk channels to SMD or SCSI disk subsystems (maybe IPI but those disks were temperamental at best). As I recall it wasn't until SSE3 instructions which were in the mid-2000's that an x86-64 desktop could compute an image convolution in the same time it took the Cray 2 but I'd have to ask Ram Nevatia. He was always finding the fastest way to do various image analysis programs.
- gefh 12y agoSo 2GB of memory, 4 cores at ~250Mhz (was the foreground processor the same? Brochure seemed unclear), runs a *nix. About 15 years ahead of a late 90's Pentium I guess, but more ram. Just need the spare 16 square feet of floor space.
- tiernano 12y agoand 300KW of power to run it!
- jwr 12y agoAnd don't forget that you also have to get rid of 300kW of heat. Having worked in a supercomputing center, this is a major problem — think about how quickly you have to shut your computers down if your heat exchanger goes down, before the room gets too hot to enter.
- TheOtherHobbes 12y ago100 domestic fan heaters running at the same time? Toasty... It's not that the Cray 2 isn't amazing, it's that modern chip tech puts at least that much power in your pocket, while desktop chips are far faster. Aaaaand - it's all air cooled and apparently effortless, and the CPU does it all with <100W or so, and it's so cheap almost anyone can buy it. Really, that's at least as amazing as the Cray series.
- frozenport 12y agoRoomer has it that the original Cray 1 design didn't have a tunable cooling unit. One day the test machine crashed, and the engineers came in the next morning to see a giant icy glacier.
- guiambros 12y agoI had the opportunity to use a Cray Y-MP 2E at university in the early 90s. At the time there were strict export restrictions, so I had to get a special approval from the U.S. Government (this was in Brazil). It was a beautiful machine. The C-shaped purple machine was impressive, and the refrigeration system took most the space. And we had some nice SGI Indigo as front-end workstations, so you could optimize your (Forth) code before moving to UNICOS - the Unix flavor used by Cray. In hindsight, it's ironic to think about all the paranoia and secrecy - for just 666 Megaflops. My not-so-new Core i7 has 150,000+ Mflops, not counting the GPU.
- seanp2k2 12y agoAhh yes, modern computers put these older systems to shame in some regards, but what did the typical desktop have back then? There's a person out there who made a 1/10th scale cycle-accurate Cray-1A...which is truly pretty cray http://www.chrisfenton.com/the-numbotron/ http://www.chrisfenton.com/the-numbotron/
- martin1b 12y agoIf we say that about the Cray 2 30 years later, interesting to think what they will say about the cloud in 30 years.
- kjs3 12y agoI'm always annoyed at the "my shiny new desktop is faster than that old Cray". A better comparison would be "how fast a computer can you buy for 2m 1990 dollars adjusted for inflation?". That's more than US$3.7m; that's a lot of computer. I got to use a Y-MP48 in the old days. Good times.
- waskosky 12y ago"Whistlebower" Dr. Bill Deagle, MD claimed that the unique Gallium Arsenide chip technology that was being worked on by the Cray Computer Corporation essentially became classified by the US Air Force, and that it was developed much further than is publicly known, and that he witnessed a "Cray 5" computing array in operation. https://youtu.be/tOz0-Hy1rm8?t=462 https://youtu.be/tOz0-Hy1rm8?t=462 (7:41) When you compare the properties of Gallium Arsenide to Silicon chips, it makes a lot of sense that the military would be highly interested. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gallium_arsenide#Comparison_with_silicon http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gallium_arsenide#Comparison_wit...
- math_and_stuff 12y agoListening to him talk really doesn't inspire much confidence. Especially his claims that GaAs "enables quantum computing".
- Animats 12y agoThat guy is bogus. There have been some real cryogenic computing devices, though. IBM and NSA put huge efforts into that back in the 1950s. ("I want a thousand megacycle computer. I'll get you the money" - NSA director).[1] The first generation technology, cyrotrons, sort of worked, but mainstream technologies pulled ahead, and that technology was abandoned in 1965. IBM kept plugging away at cyrogenic computing through the 1980s, with Josephson junctions being the next technology. Those run at liquid helium temperatures. With great difficulty and at huge cost, they got some experimental electronics (not a full CPU) running at 300MHz. By this time, it was 1982, and while that was about 10x faster than the fastest microprocessors of the period, it looked like the upper limit of the technology was around 1GHz. That, plus high cost, plus all the headaches of working in liquid helium, indicated the Josephson junction was a dead end. Standard CMOS was going to outperform the exotic technology. So, in 1983, IBM pulled the plug on that project. They're trying again.[2] IBM is working on superconducting quantum computing, and has been busy since 2012. Maybe this time it will be useful. It will definitely be expensive. [1] http://www.ewh.ieee.org/tc/csc/europe/newsforum/pdf/RN28-1.pdf http://www.ewh.ieee.org/tc/csc/europe/newsforum/pdf/RN28-1.p... [2] http://defensesystems.com/Articles/2014/12/04/IARPA-cryogenic-exascale-supercomputing.aspx http://defensesystems.com/Articles/2014/12/04/IARPA-cryogeni...
- trimbo 12y agoAh, heady days when the world's best computers were made in Chippewa Falls, Wisconsin and featured waterfalls of Fluorinert for cooling. By the time I saw a Cray-2 in person, it was shut down (it was so outmoded it was not worth running). But an awesome sight.
- germinalphrase 12y agoAs a Wisconsin native, that Cray was situated in Chippewa Falls was always a fun piece of tech trivia.
- Animats 12y agoA few years ago, somebody got a Cray 2, barrels of Fluorinert and all, and was going to restore it. Whatever happened to that? Probably not much. Restoring old computers is a huge task. The Computer Museum in Mountain View worked for years to restore an IBM 1401, a small mass-produced machine from the 1960s. They had techs who'd worked on them and access to the original designers, and it was still very hard.
- CamperBob2 12y agoThe biggest challenge may be powering it up. The brochure says it sucks down 300 kW. I'm guessing it'll need a 440V polyphase feed to run the 400 Hz motor generators...
- kjs3 12y agoYeah...the Cray 2 basically required it's own power substation be installed.
- seanp2k2 12y agoKids these days with their data center-sized supercomputers which are a bunch of x86 rack servers in a big cluster. Back in the 80s and 90s, supercomputers looked the part, and had cooling waterfalls
- tiernano 12y agoI started to read this and remember seeing [this][1] from a couple of years back... with the liquid cooling, etc, i would love a replica of the 2... [1]: http://www.extremetech.com/extreme/191877-how-to-build-your-own-110-scale-cray-1-supercomputer http://www.extremetech.com/extreme/191877-how-to-build-your-...
- jdalgetty 12y agoYes, but can it run Crysis?