3 ms·
To my knowledge, the most prominent analytics-based example of where infinite scroll was harmful comes from Etsy. My most read personal blog post [1] was a summ
by danso 12y ago
To my knowledge, the most prominent analytics-based example of where infinite scroll was harmful comes from Etsy. My most read personal blog post [1] was a summary of a great Etsy talk given by then-engineer Dan McKinley on "Design for Continuous Experimentation" in which he mentioned how infinite scroll failed at Etsy:
http://mcfunley.com/design-for-continuous-experimentation http://mcfunley.com/design-for-continuous-experimentation
One of the examples he uses was how Etsy spent months engineering an infinite scroll feature in their product search -- without any debate over whether it would be successful (at that time, just about every big site, Tumblr, Facebook, Twitter, etc had implemented it)...When they finally finished, their A/B testing found that infinite scroll had a profound negative impact on user engagement. This talk was from a couple years ago, I rechecked Etsy and it still looks like they haven't gone back to infinite scroll.
McKinley said they didn't know exactly know or investigate why infinite scroll (he said that there didn't seem to be any technical problem) caused this negative effect, just that it was undeniably a negative effect, and it was a lesson in how you should not just jump into a big project without experimentation at every step. My theory is that when it comes to finding for what you are intentionally searching for (and this applies to Google and Amazon) and then acting upon it (i.e. a purchase), infinite scroll may seem more helpful but in reality, it may cause the user to get "lost"...The user might see something interesting in the first page of results, but rather than stopping to check out those results, the infinite scroll tempts them to keep going and going...and after having consumed several pages of results, the user forgets that there were good things at the top, and never returns to them.
edit: that said, when it comes to just browsing a stream, i.e. leisurely discovery for Facebook/Twitter/Tumblr...I think infinite scroll feels like the right feature.
[1] http://danwin.com/2013/01/infinite-scroll-fail-etsy/ http://danwin.com/2013/01/infinite-scroll-fail-etsy/