6 ms·
How is ending the "gold exchange standard" connected to the decline in labor bargaining power? I buy your argument that the rollout of computers doesn't quite
by jjoonathan 12y ago
How is ending the "gold exchange standard" connected to the decline in labor bargaining power?
I buy your argument that the rollout of computers doesn't quite line up as it ought to if it were the primary factor behind wage-productivity decoupling, but I'm much less familiar with Bretton Woods so I'd appreciate any dot-connecting you can offer.
- danuker 12y agoWorkers' savings become worthless through inflation. Voila! Wage slavery.
- jjoonathan 12y agoBut savings != income. I can see the argument that eroding peoples' savings would eventually reduce their bargaining power, but on the graph the effect seems almost instantaneous.
- LanceH 12y agoSavings implies income if inflation doesn't eat it up (and then some).
- leaveyou 12y agoIt kind of makes sense: In high inflation the savers subsidize the borrowers. Who tries to save is screwed and who borrows gets an advantage. The workers are usually net savers and the businesses & the investors are borrowers. edit: my mistake; When I said 'investors' I had in mind the people who buy shares with or invest borrowed capital..
- mtviewdave 12y ago>the investors are borrowers The investors are the lenders, not the borrowers. That's what the term "investor" means.
- gesman 12y agoSavings in money, yes. Savings in real estate - highly unlikely.
- mtviewdave 12y agoThat's only true for savings in physical cash. Savings in an interest bearing instrument or account (which is where most workers actually keep their money) does not have this problem.
- pjc50 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:US-Inflation-by-year.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:US-Inflation-by-year.png Doesn't really apply after 1980. In any case, workers typically don't hold large cash savings - what matters far more is the effect of inflation vs pay negotiations. The higher the inflation, the more frequently workers need pay rises and the larger they have to be. This makes the stakes higher and provokes strikes. This was a big driver of the UK industrial strife in the 70s. http://www.livingstandards.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/Decoupling-of-wages-and-productivity.pdf http://www.livingstandards.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/De... has a UK-US comparative study but only uses data from 1972 onwards, which doesn't help. It claims that runaway health costs are a big part of the equation, among other things. (I want to find some UK graphs covering the same time period to see whether they show the same effect, and for other non-Bretton Woods countries as well)
- ChrisLomont 12y ago>Workers' savings become worthless through inflation. Are your workers keeping their savings a hundred years? It takes about 21 years for inflation to cut the value of savings in half. Workers tend to have loans, such as car, house, college, etc. Inflation helps them by making their loans cost them less to make fixed payments on over time. Inflation costs lenders, not debtors. If a worker has substantial savings, then they should not hold it in cash, which has always been a terrible idea. Diversify, and invest in multiple classes of assets. Thus inflation is a net benefit to workers.
- fsk 12y agoWith a gold standard, you have little/no inflation. (Although from 1933-1971 it was only a partial gold standard, because individuals could not redeem their dollars for gold. Only foreign central banks could trade dollars for gold.) In a paper money system, you have inflation of 10%-30%. (The CPI is currently low, but it is a misleading and biased statistic.) When you have 10% inflation, who gets that new money? It isn't workers. That 10% goes to the government (deficit spending), big banks (quantitative easing), and large corporations (who can borrow cheaply). Inflation concentrates wealth among insiders, because they get to print and spend the new money ahead of everyone else. 10%+ annual inflation is a 10% tax on the total value of the economy, with it all going to insiders.
- ChrisLomont 12y agoInflation and deflation were terrible when on the gold standard [1], and the terrible volatility was a reason every single country in the world left gold standards. The research from the great depression demonstrating that having one's currency tied to the rate one can dig up metal, instead of tied to the needs for trade, put the nail in the coffin. See also the list of US recessions, and the behavior before and after the gold standard was removed [2]. When volatility is high, everyone has to have higher prices to help plan for an uncertain future, so it is a drain on all aspects of an economy. If inflation were zero, then planning could be perfect, and there would be a much more efficient system. However, zero inflation is nearly impossible to do, since there are accidents, demand shocks, wars, and other events that shake an economy. History has shown that deflation can lead to a deflationary spiral, seriously damaging an economy and putting everyone out of work, so the Fed targets slight inflation. This provides protection against runaway deflation and also provides stable, predictive economy so people and businesses can plan. See, for example, the Great Moderation and related literature [3]. The CPI is quite accurate, and matches multiple other places that also measure inflation, such as the MIT based Billion Prices project [4]. If CPI and actual inflation were vastly different, there would be a host of financial products one could invest in that capture the difference, since many items are tied to formal CPI. Knowing people that work in places that would create such trades, if CPI were as far off as you claim, I've asked them, and they say there is no arbitrage. Can you show me where people are consistently making money trading with their "better" knowledge of inflation versus the standard CPI? Finally, if inflation were 10%-30%, as you claim, then prices would double every 2-7 years, which is clearly wrong. Using your claims, prices from 1971 till now (2015-1971=44 years) would be 80 =2^(44/7) to 4,000,000 = 2^(44/2) times higher, which is clearly false, bordering on ridiculous. You're also wrong about who benefits from inflation: basically borrowers (you and me and mortgage holders, etc) owe less money in real terms, and lenders will get paid back less than they lent, in real terms. Over the life of a loan, future fixed payments are easier to make, not harder. So inflation transfers value from lenders to borrowers, not the other way around. Inflation hurts banks and benefits borrowers. You have your claims backwards. [1] http://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~ekerschn/courses/c150042/lectures/09_flations.pdf http://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~ekerschn/courses/c150042/lecture... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_recessions_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_recessions_in_the_Unite... [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Moderation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Moderation [4] http://bpp.mit.edu/about-us/ http://bpp.mit.edu/about-us/