4 ms·
> If you think of the voting as a way to improve the ordering of the comments on the page and not as a way of doling out punishments and rewards But we aren't
by stephenr 12y ago
> If you think of the voting as a way to improve the ordering of the comments on the page and not as a way of doling out punishments and rewards
But we aren't just talking about changing the order of things. Down voted comments get hidden
This is the entire argument - opinions and points of view that go against the "hive mind" are regularly down voted into oblivion until no one can see them.
> the lack of a precise specification makes more sense
Sorry, but no. When moderation and user agree/disagree functionality is mangled like this, nothing makes sense.
> (because you hope a preponderance of users want the comments to appear in an interesting order, not to click and clack to suit their worldview).
That's exactly what happens though.
- maxerickson 12y agoThat's exactly what happens though. I only made the point implicitly, but you have no idea if this is the case or not. Nor do the moderators, even though they have much greater visibility into the voting dynamics. Nor do I. Because I can say I voted for whatever reason I want, even if I really only downvote comments that contain a capital "V". I don't particularly see a hive mind here (but maybe I'm too much a part of it), the majority of the comments that get presented as brave iconoclastic free thinking aren't really.
- mod 12y agoMaybe an appropriate response is to stop hiding comments, then. I personally make sure to read all of the (non-short) greyed out comments as usually I find the perspective interesting (and wrong, but interesting). I wouldn't care if it was flagged somehow but left entirely visible.
- stephenr 12y agoExactly my point. There is nothing wrong with indicating you disagree with something. There is something very wrong when disagreement with an opinion leads to the removal of that opinion.
- maxerickson 12y agoThere is an option in your profile "Show Dead". Turn it on. You can now see anything that has not been directly deleted (deletion is something a user can do to their own content for a short time, the mods mark stuff as dead instead of deleting it).
- mod 12y agoHe's not talking about comments from dead users, rather the near-impossible to read comments that have been downvoted.
- maxerickson 12y agoThat is not how I read down voted into oblivion until no one can see them. I could be wrong but "oblivion" and the emphasis on "no one" are what I am going on.
- DanBC 12y agoDo you have any examples of comments downvoted by the hive mind?