12 ms·
This is somewhat to my annoyance, because I frequently find mobile-friendly pages less friendly on mobile than desktop pages. Specifically, mobile-friendly typ
by barrkel 12y ago
This is somewhat to my annoyance, because I frequently find mobile-friendly pages less friendly on mobile than desktop pages.
Specifically, mobile-friendly typically disables zoom, so that zooming can't be used to choose text size or to scroll through the page at a higher rate. Instead, everything is reduced to a kind of very long ticker-tape, where if you're deep into the page, you need to scroll many, many times to get anywhere.
Alternatively, you get a page broken up into expandable sections, like mobile wikipedia, where it's very tedious to visually scan the page. Wikipedia is one of the best examples of a site where I prefer the desktop page on mobile.
Another issue is limited functionality. Sites with complex forms typically present a hobbled or otherwise limited, basic mobile experience.
- mark_integerdsv 12y agoI agree with you. I think it has to do with a kind of counter-purpose development where the people who create the devices are trying to create a good experience on websites and the designers of websites keep moving the goalposts. Perhaps it's time that web designers are subject (or subject themselves) to a similar set of human interface guidelines that app developers are subject to, for instance.
- wlesieutre 12y agoIt's a shame the semantic web hasn't taken off. Yeah, it's neat what you can do with a webpage these days, but 99% of the time, "web design" today sucks to the point where I'm relieved when I end up on an old "black text, white background, underlined blue links" site. I would love to replace web pages with an RSS reader type program that just displays content and navigation in a legible format. But with all the fancy stuff that's being added on and on, it seems like the best we're going to get is browsers with a reading "try to unfuck the formatting" button once you've gotten to the content you want.
- BenjaminPatch 12y agoYou should try a text-based browser like Lynx (http://lynx.isc.org/ http://lynx.isc.org/). All CSS and JavaScript is stripped away, leaving the user with unaltered HTML. In my opinion, all sites should be usable like this. Styles and scripts should merely be enhancements, not requirements.
- wlesieutre 12y ago>In my opinion, all sites should be usable like this. Styles and scripts should merely be enhancements, not requirements. As much as I agree, many sites are not usable like this :( And there are aspects of CSS that I do want to keep, like making the navigation lists properly horizontal (and in some cases, nested with hovers). Without CSS, you sometimes have to scroll through several pages of expanded out header/navigation before you find the content.
- kbenson 12y agoThe problem is that we use the internet for more than just sites, we use it for web applications now too. Making sure the site works without javascript is usually possible, but often much more work. For sites that are presenting information to me, or where I'm interacting in a minimal way, a well defined static interface is preferable. For complex applications, I would definitely prefer a more rich experience than is provided by HTML+CSS and HTTP (although with HTML5 it's not as bad as it used to be).
- wlesieutre 12y agoDefinitely true. But I've noticed that web applications are usually not awful design offenders. An unusable webapp frustrates users and drives them off, but an informational page trying to be some kind of 1920's prediction of a futuristic interactive magazine is annoying at most. I can always figure out how to read the text, so I just put up with the stupid design.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoI recently realized how often web developers defending the status quo have internalized a circular reasoning regarding "what the Internet is for". So the Internet is for web applications now, so we need to have all that stupid crap in CSS and dump metric tons of JavaScript on everyone. But if you suggest that maybe we should then drop the content/layout "separation" and make CSS actually nice to work with, the same people will tell you that "web is for documents", so what we have now is good. I'm beginning to wonder if we shouldn't split the Internet into two - one for cloud apps and another for content - and design the tech stacks accordingly.
- tammer 12y agoIt's so odd that gopher sounds like a fresh solution to this over-proliferation of design. I wonder if there's potential for a modern version. I guess the problem is our attention economy. As a designer your job is to hold attention, and this drives design trends so far from competitors that usability suffers. Although we do see that people love the uniformity of the big social networks. I find Twitter's clean timeline much more helpful than visiting individual websites. I wonder if we'll continue to see a trend of the web separated into app-level experiences & information silos. I'm thinking there's a big void in the market for something like squarespace meets tumblr.
- wlesieutre 12y agoThe uniformity is definitely a big plus on sites like Facebook and Twitter. The rest of the internet feels like Myspace by comparison.
- mattmanser 12y agoAnd don't forget about being unable to zoom into an image when it's been made too small to be able to actually see the details. Thankfully in andorid's chrome you can actually turn off the zoom lock for all websites in the accessibility settings.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoThis. I can't believe Twitter actually does that; it's uber painful to browse photos in tweets, which unfortunately I needed to do quite often recently.
- morgante 12y ago> Wikipedia is one of the best examples of a site where I prefer the desktop page on mobile. I actually have the opposite opinion, that the mobile wikipedia version is much better-designed and intuitive. I prefer the mobile version on desktop.
- ComputerGuru 12y agoI absolutely despise the fact that all sections are collapsed on load on mobile. That means "search in page" is broken and Wikipedia without search in page isn't Wikipedia at all.
- icebraining 12y agoThat only needs an "expand all" button; apparently that's been denied, though: https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T21924 https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T21924
- MatmaRex 12y agoThat is an ancient bug report not related to the current mobile interface ("MobileFrontend"). I think it predates that by a year or two.
- speleding 12y agoYou have "search in page" on your mobile browser? (My iPhone doesn't have that!)
- DanBC 12y agoChrome on iOS has in the burger menu "Find in Page". That burger menu scrolls.
- ComputerGuru 12y agoIt's iPhone's number 1 unknown feature. I've been using computers since I was two and it took me more than a year to find this: just type in the search term in the safari search bar, then scroll down in the autocomplete results (without hitting go or enter). It'll come up after autocomplete and history/bookmark matches - and it's been there since at least iOS 6. Worst. UX. Ever.
- leephillips 12y ago" mobile-friendly typically disables zoom" That's just a stupid choice made by (so many) web developers. I checked a sampling of my own sites with Google's tool and they all passed as mobile friendly, but none of them disable zooming. (HN fails, of course.)
- rndn 12y agoI made a bookmarklet for that reason: javascript:m=document.querySelector('meta%5Bname=viewport%5D');m.content=m.content.replace(/.*(width=%5B%5E,%5D+).*/,%22$1,maximum-scale=10,minimum-scale=0.1,user-scalable=1%22); And a second one to disable CSS-based responsiveness: javascript:m=document.querySelector('meta%5Bname=viewport%5D');m.content=%22width=1024,maximum-scale=10,minimum-scale=0.1,user-scalable=1%22;
- tripzilch 12y agoWhat's a good way to easily call up bookmarklets on mobile? I use short, unique bookmark names. If you know of any better method, I'd love to hear it :)
- pjc50 12y agoI really want a "disable zoom disable" button. HM doesn't disable zoom, it just displays in a teeny tiny font.
- coldpie 12y agoThis is a well known and hard to fix bug that I've been following. It affects other websites too, typically forums and other pages with large tables and short paragraphs of text. https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=707195 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=707195
- guelo 12y agoFirefox for Android has the Always Zoom extension, https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/always-zoom/?src=search https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/always-zoom/?....
- einrealist 12y agoI agree. I switch to the desktop version whenever I can. And if I can't, I tend to avoid the page. But the reason is mostly different: Often I know the desktop version and offering me the mobile one means that I need to relearn where stuff is. I guess, that is different for people who go online on a mobile device, only.
- soperj 12y agoI don't know about apple's offerings, but Chrome on Android has an option in the menu to request desktop version.
- currysausage 12y agoPlus, you can force-enable zoom for all sites in the accessibility settings.
- Shorel 12y agoI agree with all that. One example of mobile zoom disabled is Gamasutra. Not only zoom is disabled, but the fonts are tiny and tiresome to read.
- flooq 12y agoOlder versions of iOS had a bug where zoom levels would mess up when device orientation was changed. For a while disabling zoom was a reasonable alternative but it's not justifiable anymore On the other points I think it's because a lot of companies are still treat their mobile UX as an afterthought, even the ones who wouldn't like to admit it. It's a lot of work to handle all the variables well and few are willing to commit the resources in the right places early enough to implement a good mobile experience without awkward technical workarounds later.
- debaserab2 12y agoI find mobile sites are often tailored towards use cases that are very narrow and specific to what the site operators believe are the reasons a person would visit their site. This sort of thinking leads to sites highly tailored for mobile that ignores a segment of their audience.
- URSpider94 12y agoI made my legacy web pages (one almost 20 years old and including an image map) mobile-friendly by google's standards simply by adding a viewport. This had no impact on the usability of the site on a desktop, and only slightly changed the formatting (for the better) on my iPhone. I don't think that what Google is mandating here is a separate, crippled site for mobile devices.
- pcurve 12y agoI get instantly annoyed when I go to a site on my desktop browser and see the hamburger icon. Another huge annoyance is site with 5 break points.