5 ms·
> It's not hard to understand what happened, although economists, as a group, seem to be incredibly dense on this point. Computer technology allowed radical inc
by hammock 12y ago
> It's not hard to understand what happened, although economists, as a group, seem to be incredibly dense on this point. Computer technology allowed radical increases in productivity.
Not sure it's that cut and dry, nor that the rise of computers could be the cause of such a sharp inflection point. Bretton Woods ended around 1971-73...In fact the real wage of nonsupervisory workers peaked in 1973[1]
[1]http://www.nytimes.com/2006/09/01/opinion/01krugman.html http://www.nytimes.com/2006/09/01/opinion/01krugman.html
- jayvanguard 12y agoThat was my thought as well. The dates don't quite line up. Computers weren't widespread until the mid to late 1970s when mini-computers started to show up in smaller businesses. Even then, very small numbers of people were actually working with the computers and the paper office was still in full force. It wasn't until the 1980s that computers were ubiquitous in a way that it clearly affected the vast majority of the population.
- kevin_thibedeau 12y agoI would say it wasn't until the 90's that automation technology was sophisticated enough to start displacing workers. Before then it was used to do new things or amplify worker productivity. A TV remote from the 80's wasn't taking away a job from a house servant who would stand by to change the channel for you. Consider how the development of machine tools in 1800's created more opportunity for work in areas that were previously limited to skilled craftsmen.
- jjoonathan 12y agoHow is ending the "gold exchange standard" connected to the decline in labor bargaining power? I buy your argument that the rollout of computers doesn't quite line up as it ought to if it were the primary factor behind wage-productivity decoupling, but I'm much less familiar with Bretton Woods so I'd appreciate any dot-connecting you can offer.
- danuker 12y agoWorkers' savings become worthless through inflation. Voila! Wage slavery.
- jjoonathan 12y agoBut savings != income. I can see the argument that eroding peoples' savings would eventually reduce their bargaining power, but on the graph the effect seems almost instantaneous.
- LanceH 12y agoSavings implies income if inflation doesn't eat it up (and then some).
- leaveyou 12y agoIt kind of makes sense: In high inflation the savers subsidize the borrowers. Who tries to save is screwed and who borrows gets an advantage. The workers are usually net savers and the businesses & the investors are borrowers. edit: my mistake; When I said 'investors' I had in mind the people who buy shares with or invest borrowed capital..
- mtviewdave 12y ago>the investors are borrowers The investors are the lenders, not the borrowers. That's what the term "investor" means.
- gesman 12y agoSavings in money, yes. Savings in real estate - highly unlikely.
- mtviewdave 12y agoThat's only true for savings in physical cash. Savings in an interest bearing instrument or account (which is where most workers actually keep their money) does not have this problem.
- howeyc 12y ago> Not sure it's that cut and dry Maybe not, but seems plausible. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calculator#1970s_to_mid-1980s https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calculator#1970s_to_mid-1980s
- crimsonalucard 12y agoGiorgio Fischer, a gynecologist from Rome, Italy, invents liposuction in 1975. This allowed fat people to become skinny and therefore more productive. Correlation does not equal causation.
- astazangasta 12y agoAh, the ol' "blame the robots" gambit. They took our money! Except nothing about this story flies: first, the microprocessor did not produce some magically more productive economy. First look here: http://www.intellectualtakeout.org/sites/default/files/imagecache/chart_content/chart-graph/gdp_world_capita.png http://www.intellectualtakeout.org/sites/default/files/image... You can see that world real GDP per capita did not suddenly increase after the 70s, in fact growth actually slowed a bit. The story also doesn't agree with common sense - microprocessors didn't reinvent the economy, they couldn't even deliver the "paperless office" we were promised (something particularly close to their domain). The fact is that productivity has been growing at basically the same boring pace, and microprocessors are just another boring form of automation, not a game-changer. Finally, believing this story requires us to ignore all of the other things we know about - the introduction of fiat currency, the Fed's shift to aggressive inflation-squashing (read: preventing full employment), massive consolidation of corporate ownership, financialization of the economy, enormous tax cuts for the wealthy, trade policies designed to reduce worker bargaining power, etc., etc. Are we to believe that none of these changes had an effect?
- crimsonalucard 12y agoThe author of this article is just cocky. He thinks he has the world figured out so well he even referred to economists as "dense." Seriously, economists have actually worked out the reason behind the wealth gap, he didn't even address or critique the prevailing theory. Most likely because he doesn't even know what it is.
- limeyx 12y agoYeah. Reading the "Intel trinity" book it was interesting to note that around this time (maybe a little later) was when the chip companies successfully petitoned the Raegan government to reduce the capital gains tax rate which was at the time higher than regular income. Wonder how much that has to do with this ... (and also how interesting how suddenly keen the "free market" fanatics were to take government money ....