3 ms·
"Economists have been crying out "bubble bubble !" on china for 10 years. The science of capital as applied to western countries do not apply to a system like c
by jerf 12y ago
"Economists have been crying out "bubble bubble !" on china for 10 years. The science of capital as applied to western countries do not apply to a system like china where there are so many SOE."
Ah, there it is... the "this time it's different!" argument.
I fear that the different that the number of "State Owned Enterprises" will have is that where the bubble would "naturally" be popped by "natural" market forces, the incentives in China will cause it to inflate even farther, even faster, until it pops even harder.
Bubbles are not created by "capitalism". Bubbles are created by feedback loops feeding on themselves, which are unavoidable (where there is any form of negative feedback, there are oscillations). A State may well keep a bubble alive where capitalism would have popped it. That it hasn't popped yet could really be a sign that this time it's different; China does have greater capacity for growth on the same tech stack than the US does. But it could also mean that the malinvestment is getting even farther than the US tech bubble ever did. Bubbles being what they are, the greater capacity for growth could even be making it worse... if the economy could support X more growth but the bubble inflates that into 10X more investment, that could mean the greater capacity for growth is itself a participant in the inflation.
The "pop" isn't caused by "capitalism" either... bad investments that can't pay for themselves are bad investments that can't pay for themselves, regardless of the economic system in which they occur.
(I fear, because no one will escape this unscathed if it happens. The Western economies still haven't recovered from their last recession and are quite rickety themselves (since the West seems to have fallen in love with centralized management once again itself, and there is perhaps not a bit of book cooking here too). If a Chinese bubble does pop and it is that bad, it's not going to be any fun for anyone.)