3 ms·
> Getting all children outside for three hours every day is not realistically possible Then something is very wrong. - Walk (or cycle) to school: 10 minutes.
by Symbiote 12y ago
> Getting all children outside for three hours every day is not realistically possible
Then something is very wrong.
- Walk (or cycle) to school: 10 minutes.
- Morning break: 20 minutes.
- Lunch: 45-60 minutes.
- Afternoon break: 20 minutes.
- Walk home from school: 10 minutes.
That's around 2 hours already, and that's structured time at school. Add a sports lesson two or three times a week, and add one hour playing outside after school every day.
In England, break and lunch was outdoors unless it was actually raining. (Very light drizzle doesn't count.) Being inside wasn't allowed until I was 16-17, in 2002.
I read an article in an old New Scientist on this topic, and it said bright light wasn't sufficient -- it had to be combined with open spaces, which let the peripheral vision be in focus at the same time as the core vision.
- leoc 12y agoIf you're suggesting that a typical school day in England delivers enough or nearly enough hours of strong-enough sunlight then that seems hard to square with the large increase in myopia right across the developed world, not just Asia (unless one rejects the strong-light hypothesis, of course). If strong light on its own isn't sufficient then of course adding artificial light to classrooms won't be sufficient; but in that case the Yangxi school experiment presumably won't be successful either.
- Symbiote 12y agoI'm not going quite that far, but I am suggesting it is realistically possible.
- superuser2 12y agoRecalling public middle school in Wisconsin: >Walk (or cycle) to school: 10 minutes School starts at 7:40a; most days walking between 7:15a and 7:30a; for most of the year that walk is in the dark or the sun is very low and not very bright. >Morning break: 20 minutes Never got one of those >Lunch: 45-60 minutes Try 20. >Afternoon break: 20 minutes Never got one of those >Walk home from school: 10 minutes. Figure one extra-curricular with a duration of 1 hour. For most of the year, the walk home for me was 4:00p-4:15p which was entirely dark.
- Symbiote 12y agoThat's a very long day! And unfortunate with the timezone. Here (London), even in December at least morning is in daylight, and hometime is at dusk (well before twilight). The school next door to my workplace has this schedule (from their website), for 5-11 year olds: 8:45 - children start to arrive 8:55 - children go inside 10:20-10:35 - morning break 12:00-13:10 - lunch 15:15 - hometime! 15:45 - still lots of children playing, parents chatting 16:00 - most have gone by this point, though on a nice sunny day they can easily still be playing and chatting at 17:30. The nearest school for 12-16 year olds with info on their website do 8:30-15:00, but only have 45 minutes for lunch. My own school had an hour for lunch, but finished at 15:30. These schools don't have an afternoon break.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]