3 ms·
>> I suspect it's young people who just weren't around before Agile. I was around before Agile became the thing that everyone was doing. Myself and many of my
by Nursie 12y ago
>> I suspect it's young people who just weren't around before Agile.
I was around before Agile became the thing that everyone was doing. Myself and many of my contemporaries are very cynical about it because what it most often seems to boil down to "what we were doing before but with more meetings and heavier process".
I've worked in places where Agile Evangelists would regularly take teams of people away from their desks for process-related meetings (retrospectives, planning, errr.... who the hell knows what else) for several hours at a time, more than once a week.
I've heard Agile consultants say things like "And the great thing about Agile is that if you start falling behind, you can take what you have to the customer, involve them in the process, and deliver even more at the next sprint!" as if it would miraculously provide extra developer time/effort for free.
And I've seen true-believers who seemed to think that if the project wasn't making progress then people probably just weren't doing 'Agile' hard enough, and probably needed even more meetings and process.
I like the manifesto. I don't like what often actually gets applied out in the field, and the consultants/evangelists are basically cultists AFAICT.
- BurningFrog 12y agoWeird. The kind of XP I've been involved in is near obsessive about maximizing programming time. Which means meetings are kept short, with minimum attendance.
- Nursie 12y agoThat sounds like doing it well, in accordance with principles, rather than doing it badly in accordance with consultants... --edit-- I wouldn't claim to know about XP, I've never worked somewhere that embraced XP specifically, just places that decided to go 'Agile' and then proceeded to bog themselves down in so much procedure that projects started to fail. I've only worked in one place where the morning stand-ups actually worked as they were intended - 5 developers go round the room, give a quick status and state any problems they have, identify who they need to talk to to get it solved, the get out again in under 10 minutes. Everywhere else I've worked they devolved into either developer chat/argument time or management info-broadcast time. For at least an hour. Every day. groan