4 ms·
So let me see if I understand your suggestion: I see Billy has posted a comment. Jane has replied to Billy's comment, with a dissenting viewpoint, and her comm
by stephenr 12y ago
So let me see if I understand your suggestion:
I see Billy has posted a comment. Jane has replied to Billy's comment, with a dissenting viewpoint, and her comment has subsequently been down voted because people disagree.
I happen to agree with Billy's point of view and disagree with Jane, but if I want to support a truly open discussion about the topic, I have to upvote a comment I disagree with?
How does that make any sense?
- DanBC 12y agoYou upvote comments that add to the conversation. When you see a comment that adds value you upvote it even if you disagree with it, especially if you think it has been unfairly downvoted. There are people on HN who do this. Edit: I mean, there are so many people saying "don't downvote to disagree" that the problem of greyed but constructive comments would be fixed if they just upvoted more often. Why don't they take this burden upon themselves, changing their own behaviour, rather than calling for other people to change theirs?
- stephenr 12y agoI'm having a hard time following your logic.. - Upvotes are to indicate a comment adds to the conversation, regardless of whether I agree with the view point expressed. - Down votes are to indicate that either I disagree with a comment, OR that the comment is abusive, argumentative, etc, but there is no way to specify which of those... ??? In reply to the edit: Some of us do actively upvote greyed comments, that's hardly a reason not to fix a system that's broken
- DanBC 12y ago> - Down votes are to indicate that either I disagree with a comment, OR that the comment is abusive, argumentative, etc, but there is no way to specify which of those... Yes. (You list misses "the tiny buttons are so close that people sometimes accidentally downvote") There are different people on HN and they use the downvote to differently from each other to communicate different information. I'm not sure why that concept is confusing? It's sometimes confusing if a post is downvoted. Don't pay too much attention to a single downvote if you can't work out why it happened. If you get two or three downvotes you might want to look at your post to see if there's a problem with tone or content.
- stephenr 12y agoWhen it's "accepted behaviour" to down vote merely because you disagree with the opinion stated, telling me "you might want to look at your post to see if there's a problem with tone or content" is fucking insulting. Do you seriously not see the irony in suggesting that removing dissenting opinions merely because they are not aligned with your own, is acceptable behaviour on a site called Hacker News?? For reference: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9C4uTEEOJlM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9C4uTEEOJlM
- DanBC 12y agoCalm down. > Do you seriously not see the irony in suggesting that removing dissenting opinions merely because they are not aligned with your own, is acceptable behaviour on a site called Hacker News?? A single down vote does not remove a disenting opinion. Multiple downvotes, and a lack of upvotes, remove a post. There are plenty of opinions that are eauivalent to trollingI don't want to bother with on HN. EG I don't want to bother telling a holocaust denier that they're wrong. I'm not going to change their opinion and everything I say is presented better by other people elsewhere. This is supported multiple times in the guidelines. (Deeply interesting, not shallow but intensely interesting.) When you're getting multiple downvotes it's usually for tone or style or factual inaccuracy, not because you've said something that people disagree with. Do you have examples of comments that were heavily downvoted that should not have been?
- stephenr 12y agoedit: forget it. you're right. the system works exactly as desired, for the intended market. I'm just clearly not that market.
- bjourne 12y ago> Do you have examples of comments that were heavily downvoted that should not have been? Here you go: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9409007 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9409007 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9405216 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9405216 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9399966 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9399966 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9400562 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9400562 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9400379 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9400379
- dragonwriter 12y ago> I see Billy has posted a comment. Jane has replied to Billy's comment, with a dissenting viewpoint, and her comment has subsequently been down voted because people disagree. Just a note, you cannot see the last part ("her comment has subsequently been downvoted because people disagree"), only assume it. > I happen to agree with Billy's point of view and disagree with Jane, but if I want to support a truly open discussion about the topic, I have to upvote a comment I disagree with? Sure, "upvote" doesn't mean agree and "downvote" doesn't mean disagree, though agree/disagree can be one of the factors that goes into upvoting/downvoting. Upvoting/downvoting is best interpreted as "this comment is what I want to see on HN" vs. "this comment is not what I want to see on HN". If you are interested in substantive, productive comments even when you disagree with them, that's what you should upvote. If you don't want HN to be full of substanceless comments that add nothing even if they restate positions you generally agree with, you should downvote those. > How does that make any sense? How does downvoting comments that contribute to a kind of HN you don't want to see and upvoting those that contribute to a kind of HN you do want to see not make sense?
- stephenr 12y ago> Just a note, you cannot see the last part ("her comment has subsequently been downvoted because people disagree"), only assume it. When the comment is not abusive, trolling, etc, the specific reason (I don't agree with her. I don't like girls!. She used the word "who" instead of "whom". etc) doesn't matter - it's a vote based on personal opinion of the comment (or the commenter), not based on the objective value of the comment. > Upvoting/downvoting is best interpreted as "this comment is what I want to see on HN" So, own it then. Make it blatantly clear that you expect and encourage people to shape HN comments to their own world view, regardless of reality. > How does downvoting comments that contribute to a kind of HN you don't want to see and upvoting those that contribute to a kind of HN you do want to see not make sense? The "kind of HN I want to see" is the kind where differing opinions are accepted. When that opinion differs from enough people who down vote, not only do they not see the comment, neither do I. Seriously how is this point hard to understand?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]