4 ms·
> If you are downmodding out of disagreement Regarding the downmod: I completely agree with your post. Users are generally incapable of using downmods correctl
by zamalek 12y ago
> If you are downmodding out of disagreement
Regarding the downmod: I completely agree with your post. Users are generally incapable of using downmods correctly. No matter which community. The UX of HN tends towards moderation usage of the arrow - heavily downvoted comments get grayed out and disappear from the discussion: they have become moderated.
Regarding the downvote (disagreement): Indicating that the arrow can be used for disagreement means that the downmod argument becomes irrelevant (ignoring the UX concerns). The truth is: your disagreement is completely worthless if you cannot vocalize that disagreement. Bad arguments will fall below the good arguments by virtue of the votes the good arguments receive.
One of the greatest memes on the internet is possibly: "can someone tell me why my comment has been downvoted?"
Either remove the arrow, only show it after you have responded to a comment, and/or make it cost 1 karma to downvote.
- DanBC 12y ago> your disagreement is completely worthless if you cannot vocalize that disagreement. I would far rather see pedants downvoting than leaving comments. I would far rather see two people who dislike each other just downvote each other than carry out a tiresome argument. > Bad arguments will fall below the good arguments by virtue of the votes the good arguments receive. A bad argument that recieves comments that are upvoted is pushed higher up the page. Do young the top comments on an article to be someone saying something dumb, with replies telling them why they're dumb?
- zamalek 12y ago> just downvote each other than carry out a tiresome argument. You can't currently downvote a reply. > I would far rather see two people who dislike each other just downvote each other than carry out a tiresome argument. HN seems to limit the depth you can go to within your own comment line, I'm not sure what the exact rules are but once you reach a certain depth the reply option disappears. > A bad argument that recieves comments that are upvoted is pushed higher up the page. Which means that those upvoted comments hold value - so, yes, I'd still like to see them.
- DanBC 12y ago> HN seems to limit the depth you can go to within your own comment line, I'm not sure what the exact rules are but once you reach a certain depth the reply option disappears. Yes. The reply option takes longer and longer to appear as threads get deeper. Even the software wants to prevent those people from replying to each other. > You can't currently downvote a reply. Ann posts something. Bob hates Ann. I would prefer it if Bob just downvotes Ann rather than making a post. I can upvote Ann if I think she's been unfair downvoted.
- stephenr 12y agoSo now, personal disagreement with another person is a valid reason to down vote, regardless of what they said? Next on HN: down vote people who prefer a different breakfast cereal.
- DanBC 12y ago> so now Now? It's been accepted for longer than you've been a member. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171
- stephenr 12y agoThat comment mentions disagreement, and the context implies it means disagreement with the comment itself. You said: > Bob hates Ann. I would prefer it if Bob just downvotes Ann rather than making a post. How is that not abuse: down voting because of who the person is (Bob hates Ann) rather than because of the comment itself.
- DanBC 12y agoYou're right, and I should have been more careful with my wording. Bob hates everything that Ann says. Ann makes a post. Ideally Bob would read it charitably and reply carefully. What sometimes happens is that Bob reads it critically and replies harshly. I would prefer Bob to do the former, or just ignore the post, or just downvote it and move on, (in this order) to grumpily answering Ann. Yes, a downvote in this example is abusive, but a simple solution exists - upvote often. (Btw: please do remember that I'm just one person and that very many people on HN agree with you that downvote should only be used for low quality posts that don't reach the threshold for flagging. You definitely are the target audience.)