2 ms·
Downvotes for disagreement and downvotes for non-constructiveness are sometimes hard to distinguish. At the most obvious, a comment saying justt "I think you're
by geofft 12y ago
Downvotes for disagreement and downvotes for non-constructiveness are sometimes hard to distinguish. At the most obvious, a comment saying justt "I think you're wrong" clearly expresses a position that at least one person disagrees with, but is also almost certainly non-constructive, and potentially abusive in the form of being disrespectful. If you have arguments, make them. If the person you're arguing with made an argument, give the phrasing of the argument the benefit of the doubt, and engage with it as if it is a serious argument. (And if there's no way to do that, then their comment should be downvoted, because it's non-constructive.) To do otherwise is disrespectful of the person you're replying to, as well as to the community of people reading comments.
A lot of times I see people making repetitive and poorly-informed comments that also happen to be disagreeable on the merits. They're relevant, they toe the line of "non-abusive", but they don't belong. For instance, a recent comment thread had someone asking about whether Microsoft accepts pull requests on GitHub. It got two replies: one person explaining that they were aiming to, and one person saying that, of course MS would never do such a thing. The latter comment got downvoted a fair bit. I'd imagine most of the people downvoting disagreed on the facts, since the comment happened to be wrong. But it also did not contribute to the discussion, since it was made out of ignorance and assumption, and rightly got downvoted on those grounds.
- robgibbons 12y agoIn this circumstance, downmodding may indeed have been the proper course of action -- although a simple link to the source would have been just as effective, and much more informative.
- DanBC 12y ago> A lot of times I see people making repetitive and poorly-informed comments that also happen to be disagreeable on the merits. They're relevant, they toe the line of "non-abusive", but they don't belong. This is a great example of where downvotes should be used. People should flag, not just downvote, abusive posts. Anyone can flag a post (click the timestamp to reveal the link). This deliberate design choice by the HN programmers leaves downvoting free for posts that are not outright abuse but which do not add value.