3 ms·
>Getting all children outside for three hours every day is not realistically possible, and wouldn't be pleasant or even desirable for all of them: bad weather,
by trhway 12y ago
>Getting all children outside for three hours every day is not realistically possible, and wouldn't be pleasant or even desirable for all of them: bad weather, unsafe neighbourhoods, air pollution.
i don't understand that. Where do children are supposed to get daily multi-hour physical activity? On the treadmill in the basement? And if children aren't getting such amount of physical activity - that would border on neglect toward their health, physical and emotional. (of course my POV is affected by the fact that i'm a child of 197x-198x when we were "free-range" children back in USSR and from what i heard it was about the same in USA back then)
- derefr 12y agoThis is why modern parents are so in love with structured extra-curricular activities like team sports: they're effectively isolated corrals in which "multi-hour physical activity" is encouraged, rather than discouraged.
- leoc 12y agoIt's not a matter of whether it's generally desirable for all children to spend three hours outside every day. One problem is whether admonishing parents about it is actually going to make it so for all children. Another problem is whether it's actually possible and safe for all children no matter how desirable it might be in general. A third problem is how the strong the sun actually is while they are outside playing. For five days out of seven in the winter millions of children in northern Europe travel to school around sunrise, get maybe an hour outside during the day, then come home and play football under grey evening skies and sodium lights.
- jacalata 12y agoMost Russian children probably don't get 'daily multi-hour physical activity' - here is a study showing self-reported hours of activity: http://eurpub.oxfordjournals.org/content/eurpub/9/3/166.full.pdf http://eurpub.oxfordjournals.org/content/eurpub/9/3/166.full... I don't know of any developed country where kids are all getting that much activity, to be honest.