2 ms·
Granted, I have practically no background in academic psychology research. I am willing to believe that there is a kernel of science in psychology. And I 'beli
by analog31 12y ago
Granted, I have practically no background in academic psychology research. I am willing to believe that there is a kernel of science in psychology.
And I 'believe' in statistics, which is just math after all. This is notwithstanding the apparent fact that the social and life sciences seem to be in a state of panic right now due to issues regarding the use of statistics. At best, it means that a few reports should be discarded. At worst, I have to anticipate that there may be entire fields or subfields that are "science," but that have produced no reliable scientific knowledge base as of yet.
But for a layperson like myself, my only likely contact with psychology is at least a couple steps removed from academic science:
1. Does the application of scientific methodology actually produce useful scientific knowledge in all fields at the present state of the art?
2. Are people who claim to apply psychological knowledge in ways that affect me, likely to use that knowledge in an unbiased and ethical fashion?
In my life, we are talking about people such as educators (of my kids), HR managers, journalists, and little consultants. Should I trust these people to tell me anything that I don't already know about myself or through general common sense?
This is how it can come to pass that something is both "science" and "bullshit" when viewed from opposite ends of a pipeline from basic research to practical application.
- ryan-allen 12y agoLet's assume that when I say statistics I'm talking about the scientific application of statistics and not Fox New's use of statistics, now to your questions: 1. Not always, but that is the nature of scientific research and you should know this. 2. I would say that they would, if you found yourself or a member of your family and/or friends were affected by a mental illness. Which, by the way, is very, very likely. In regards to common sense, you can't always rely on it, and there is research to prove this. As for your utilitarian measurement of what is useful to you or bullshit, great! You sound like you'd make a great engineer, as opposed to a research scientist. Though don't hate on the researchers, they discovered some of the things you take for granted in your day to day application of what is 'not bullshit'.
- analog31 12y agoMy education is in physics, and I work in industry. I would at least admit that I would not be very happy trying to do research in the social sciences. As for being diagnosed with a mental illness, rumors that practitioners follow diagnostic fads and over-prescribe meds, would prevent me from even seeking a diagnosis unless my suffering were really profound, which it isn't.