3 ms·
Do you have an offering that would allow me to code up a SystemVerilog->Verilog translation script on a hobbyist budget? I'm stuck coding for my SP605 in Verilo
by jjoonathan 12y ago
Do you have an offering that would allow me to code up a SystemVerilog->Verilog translation script on a hobbyist budget? I'm stuck coding for my SP605 in Verilog (or VHDL) but I would really like to be able to use structs and interfaces from SystemVerilog.
Coming from software dev it's insane: The $500 devkit doesn't support structs and I would have to pay $1300 to get one that does. Meanwhile C has had structs for 40 years... :(
- UncleOxidant 12y agoHow about using VHDL and records? I think these are synthesizeable outside of ports. VHDL is a much better language from a software engineering standpoint than Verilog.
- jjoonathan 12y agoI know nothing about VHDL -- I vaguely remember hearing someone say it suffered from the same issue so I didn't pursue it. Thanks for the tip!
- UncleOxidant 12y agoVHDL is more strongly typed than Verilog (I consider this a good thing). Sure, it's a bit more verbose, but the language is more expressive than Verilog - allows overloading operators, for example. A nice example of the advantage of VHDL over verilog is that there's a FixedPoint type in VHDL (as of VHDL 2008, I think) whereas in Verilog you're on your own to line up the binary points - very annoying.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- elovlie 12y agoI've had similar needs but couldn't find an existing tool, nor a parser on which to build. There are some open source parsers [0], but they don't seem to do preprocessing and hence lose a lot of context. So I made a parser that might work for your use-case given some work: https://github.com/svstuff/systemverilog https://github.com/svstuff/systemverilog It works for some fairly big codebases, so I know it's not completely broken. I'm not very proud of the scala code, it's quite ugly in places. But at least there are some tests :p [0]: this also seems active worth checking out: https://github.com/gburdell/parser https://github.com/gburdell/parser EDIT: added link to other parser.
- jjoonathan 12y agoThanks, looks promising! My needs are pretty minimal at the moment but it will be both refreshing and educational to give this a go. Duplicating all the DRAM wires at each and every level of abstraction was just hideous.