5 ms·
For one thing, it's much colder in Montana than in Ethiopia. Next, what would we do with these people's agricultural output? The US government pays current far
by nine_k 12y ago
For one thing, it's much colder in Montana than in Ethiopia.
Next, what would we do with these people's agricultural output? The US government pays current farmers not to use land to keep food prices up. US have 721k farmers; Ethiopia has 86M population.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoThe point was, they want to feed themselves. Profit is further down the road.
- ido 12y agoI think for the cost of moving 86m people halfway across the world you can probably develop Ethiopia instead (Israel produces 95% of its own food while being more arid than Ethiopia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agriculture_in_Israel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agriculture_in_Israel)
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoJust to speculate on that: Talking about Tigray, with a population of 4.3 millions. I wonder if the equipment to farm to feed those people would actually weigh less than the people? A few thousand boat trips would serve to move them all. In fact, once a fraction had been moved, pressure would be reduce in Tigray to house and feed the remainder. Remember America took in 65 Million people over its history. Most of those came by steam ship. Today it would be faster and cheaper by far.
- ido 12y agoI wonder if the equipment to farm to feed those people would actually weigh less than the people I would certainly think so, considering how advanced modern farming tech is (or even 50 years old farming tech). 4.3m people plus food/water/other stuff they need to survive a couple weeks on a ship (plus then transporting them overland to wherever) weighs A LOT, fuel & vessels to transport them are also not trivial. The farm equipment also doesn't have to come from America, there are far closer manufacturers (Israel is ~3000km by ship from Eilat, Europe or India ~1000-2000 more). Anyway hauling millions of people over to America sounds like a pretty ridiculous solution to me. You think the US government would accept millions of refugees with open arms? Why did the majority of Iraqi war refugees had to come to Europe instead?
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoRemember the farm equipment needs support too. Like that food and water, you need fuel, tires, parts, lubricants, expert mechanics...so from a sustainability viewpoint, its likely easier to move people where the technology is, than to try to transplant the technology to where the people are. And the idea is more a speculative engineering question. What kind of solutions would be more efficient, IF ONLY politics didn't get in the way?
- ido 12y agoI don't know, but I would be really surprised if moving millions of people is more efficient than moving sufficient amount of agricultural equipment & some farmers to get them started on using them correctly (remember that a lot of these people are already farmers, just not using modern tools/fertilizers). Not to mention it's at least slightly offensive & like treating people like cattle to move them around wholesale like that. Ultimately the problem is not the climate or soil it's the (mis)allocations of resources.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoEthiopia has periodic crippling drought. So it is the climate. Water is very precious there. That's the impetus behind the question which can be stated as "Move the people to water, or scavenge water where the people are". Again, the 'offensive' argument is political. Trying to just compare outcomes, to know what to shoot for in the political realm. Remember, these are already refugees, there against their will.
- ido 12y agoAnd yet Israel has less hospitable climate and it's doing just fine, due to resources invested in water reclamation/desalination and high(er) tech agriculture[1]. I think you really overestimate how harsh the climate in Ethiopia is - it's not like trying to colonize Mars or Arrakis. It's hardly the Sahara either. The climate is in fact less harsh than fairly extensive parts of the US (particularly the West). [1] Israel was also doing quite well even when it was a fairly poor country in the 50s/60s (although it was never as dirt poor as Ethiopia).