4 ms·
Not about Elixir specifically, but don't people get tired of switching languages? What, people will now have to port all Ruby libraries to Elixir (or, at the ve
by pron 12y ago
Not about Elixir specifically, but don't people get tired of switching languages? What, people will now have to port all Ruby libraries to Elixir (or, at the very least, relearn them), and then a few years down the line to the next thing? Isn't this a huge waste of effort? Not to mention the poor CTO who gets a job at such an early-adopter company in 15 years, and finds out the codebase is made up of 7 different languages, four of them have been defunct for years? I mean, a language's benefit must at least cover all the switching costs, the fractured codebase costs and then some to justify adoption. Are all the new languages such huge advances over older ones that they do that?
- slayed0 12y agoI think the issue is that many CTO's don't take all of these factors into account when they do decide to switch to or add a new language to the companies codebase. It seems many are shortsighted and simply see A > B without evaluating all of the costs of switching from B to A.
- yellowapple 12y ago> Are all the new languages such huge advances over older ones that they do that? I don't know about other languages, but having personally migrated from Perl and Ruby to Erlang/Elixir, I at least believe that to be the case in that particular circumstance. A big part of it is that parallel programming is starting to catch on as mainstream rather than something to be shunned or avoided; whereas in the past folks were conditioned to avoid having to deal with threading or forking because of having to think about thread safety, there are now languages like Erlang (and its kids Elixir and LFE), Rust, Go, Scala, Julia, etc. that are meant to make parallel computing easier to reason about or less dangerous (or sometimes even both). On top of this, though, Erlang-and-kids' reliability features allow them to achieve the legendary "nine-nines" of uptime (99.9999999%) relatively easily (I say "relatively" because - while you certainly still have to think about it (particularly if you're trying to push a change to, say, how data is represented on the (D)ETS or Mnesia or CouchDB or SQL or whatever side of things) - it's much easier than with a lot of other languages). That level of availability has huge implications for a company's bottom line, particularly those companies that measure downtime in "thousands of dollars per second" instead of just seconds. A well-written Erlang/OTP (or Elixir/OTP or LFE/OTP or anything/OTP) application can do this on the software side rather effectively (on the hardware side, you'd still want redundancy wherever possible/feasible, including on the network side of things; most well-run hospitals, for example, will have connections with at least two different ISPs so that if one goes out, they still have the other, and will only lose connectivity in very extreme circumstances). In the case of Elixir, it makes for a very solid migration target from, say, a Rails codebase; the syntax is a bit more modern (I personally prefer Erlang's in many cases, but Elixir's pipe operator is a godsend) and familiar to Rubyists ("do" blocks, more flexible pipelining with the |> operator, etc.), while being fully compatible with the existing Erlang and growing Elixir ecosystems.
- pron 12y agoDon't get me wrong, it would be great if all Ruby developers switched to Erlang/Elixir, but what next? I mean, does switching a language more often than once a decade result in net benefit to the industry or net loss? I fear it's the latter.
- yellowapple 12y agoIt depends on how drastic the switch is. Most of these switches are driven by a shift to some new programming paradigm. We started with procedural programming, then made a big shift to object-oriented programming, and now we're starting to see a big shift toward functional/declarative programming. Who knows what'll be big next? If this happens too frequently, then there are certainly going to be problems, yes. The current trend, however, indicates that it's not happening too frequently, at least not yet; the current shift from object-oriented imperative to functional/declarative programming (with some object orientation here and there, though this isn't very pronounced in Erlang and its family tree) seems to be by necessity rather than adopting shiny for the sake of shiny, and I think that's what makes the difference here. Basically, the more dramatic the switch is, the more likely the switch to be a net gain rather than a net loss, since it indicates that the switch was truly necessary. Switching from Python to Ruby, for example, would be a net loss, since - while they have different syntax and in some cases different programming styles and ecosystems - they're both imperative scripting languages and you're not really changing all that much besides a bit of syntax and semantics. Meanwhile, a switch from Python to Haskell, for another example, is more likely to be a net gain, since you wouldn't even consider that switch unless you felt the need for the massive paradigm shift that's required to make such a switch. As a disclaimer, my claims above are mostly conjecture, though I think they correspond well with reality, at least by my own observations.
- pron 12y ago> Most of these switches are driven by a shift to some new programming paradigm. Most of the switches should be driven by one thing, and one thing only: reducing the cost of software development (or increasing the quality, which is really the other side of the same coin). Whether a new programming paradigm actually achieves that or merely advertises itself as achieving that is the cause for the very high churn in fashion-driven SV and low churn elsewhere (where people are actually interested in cost reduction only). > the current shift from object-oriented imperative to functional/declarative programming As someone familiar with the software industry, I can tell you that there is no such shift happening other than in the minds of some wishful-thinkers. Are functional concepts being adopted by OO languages? Sure! (although Gilad Bracha would tell you, correctly, that most of these concepts were already in some OO languages -- i.e. Smalltalk -- long before people in the industry started using the term FP). But people aren't really switching languages outside those sectors that have made switching languages every few years a lifestyle choice. > Basically, the more dramatic the switch is, the more likely the switch to be a net gain rather than a net loss, I completely agree with that. > since it indicates that the switch was truly necessary. But not with this. Dramatic changes do have the potential to make a dramatic impact, but 1/ they rarely do, and 2/ when they do, it's mostly in the runtime -- not the language. Erlang is certainly an excellent runtime that has a big impact (though personally, I prefer the JVM, which can do anything BEAM does only better), but Haskell? Haskell is a very, very unproven language. I remember that about 15 years ago everyone was talking about it, saying how it's going to be the next big thing. 20 years into its existence, though, the largest single Haskell program is still its own compiler, which is not particularly large. The truth is that nobody really knows Haskell's actual benefits (in terms of real impact to project development) because in twenty years no one has tried to actually use the language for anything big (and small projects are usually cost-effective in any language). Its impact could be great but it may well be negative. Nobody knows. So if anyone tells me they've switched to Haskell out of necessity, I call BS. But switching to BEAM is always a good idea (sooner or later) for large projects (unless you're already on the JVM), although if you're making the switch, I'd advise on the JVM, as it's a safer bet (both in terms of future, as well as likeliness of addressing the needs you may actually face; BEAM is a slow runtime, and many Erlang shops rely on C for important parts of their code).
- lectrick 12y ago> Not about Elixir specifically, but don't people get tired of switching languages? Are you a developer because you don't want to keep learning? Maybe you walked into the wrong room? ;) > What, people will now have to port all Ruby libraries to Elixir (or, at the very least, relearn them), and then a few years down the line to the next thing? Isn't this a huge waste of effort? In this case, Elixir actually has a selling point, as Erlang has existed for over 20 years and has its own fairly mature box of tools (which are all easily accessed from Elixir). From a bigger picture, a lot of code construction of late has moved to a SOA paradigm, in which case you can still call into perfectly-working Ruby codebases, except as a client from another language.
- pron 12y ago> Are you a developer because you don't want to keep learning? Maybe you walked into the wrong room? ;) Don't you rather be learning new concepts rather than new syntax/APIs? Not that Elixir doesn't bring new concepts to Ruby developers (it does), but even so, I think switching a language for production code has a terrible cost/benefit ratio compared to learning a new algorithm or even a new approach without switching a language. Since when has "learning" in CS meant adopting a new language?
- lectrick 12y agoIf we would all just have used Lisp from the get-go, then none of this would have even been necessary. ;) > Don't you rather be learning new concepts rather than new syntax/APIs? I ran out of new things to learn in Ruby, around the time I wrote a fizzbuzz implementation using pure functionals without any conditionals. And the mutability issue was bothering me in a very real way (I spent a month, A MONTH, tracking down a dropped-session issue which ended up being a stray mutation of the gigantic ENV variable in the middleware stack... That class of bug would not exist in Elixir/Erlang). Elixir/Erlang provided very brand-new things to learn... pattern-matching instead of complicated nested logic, explicitly passing around state instead of holding it everywhere, macros, OTP, I mean pretty much everything underneath is different except for the syntax. ;) You can't learn something like macros in Ruby, at all. If certain things aren't core language features, it's just difficult to learn them, period.