3 ms·
I can hear the difference, I also produce music. It would be incredibly easy to produce a better test. The hard part is getting permission from copyright holde
by TheOtherHobbes 12y ago
I can hear the difference, I also produce music.
It would be incredibly easy to produce a better test. The hard part is getting permission from copyright holders.
Now - I'm sure a lot of people can't hear the difference because they don't know what to listen for.
The issue isn't that the difference doesn't exist or that it's "not audible" in some objective sense.
It's that they're not listening to the sound in the same way a producer or engineer listen to sound.
Listening is an active process. It involves a lot of unconscious focussing on specific elements of the sound/music.
You can argue whether or not this matters, but that's really an economic argument about distribution and storage costs, not an absolute argument about the physics of audio compression.
Saying the difference isn't audible at all is like saying that you may as well quantise all rhythms right on the beat because most people can't tell by ear if beats are early or late.
- JonnieCache 12y ago>Saying the difference isn't audible at all is like saying that you may as well quantise all rhythms right on the beat because most people can't tell by ear if beats are early or late. This is a great analogy that gets to the key point: most of the things that make records sound good are 'inaudiable.' That's why making music is so hard.