5 ms·
Skip Child Support. Go to Jail. Lose Job. Repeat
- AdmiralAsshat 12y agoI was thinking, "Why not just garnish his salary?" until I read this: When parents fall short, the authorities escalate collection efforts, withholding up to 65 percent of a paycheck, seizing bank deposits and tax refunds, suspending driver’s licenses and professional licenses, and then imposing jail time. I don't see how this is legal. If they've seized 65% of your paycheck already and it's still not enough, isn't this basically amounting to debtors' prison?
- spdustin 12y agoBecause when it comes to child support, you've been ordered by a judge to pay. Violating a court order is a criminal offense. There are other ways to manage overburdening debt collections, even court-ordered ones. The situation escalating to incarceration is largely avoidable.
- geebee 12y agoThis is interesting. Could you explain how it is avoidable? I am genuinely asking, not looking for something to argue about (I may disagree, just want to make sure you know I'm not looking for something to disagree with, I am asking this because I really don't know). My limited understanding is that people can be sent to jail for failure to pay even if they have turned over all existing assets (i.e., no concealing assets or fraud) and have made no effort to evade payment. For instance, if someone "loses" a job and the judge believes that the person is not making a sufficient effort to find one and resume payment, that can be sufficient to send someone to jail. Is that the case?
- Canada 12y agoMy understanding is that effort is irrelevant. Either the man pays or is imprisoned. I wonder how much of these debts not money paid by the state to the monther, but are fines or penalties that generate revenue for the state itself.
- Someone1234 12y ago> Because when it comes to child support, you've been ordered by a judge to pay. Violating a court order is a criminal offense. Explaining the legal mean doesn't preclude the above person's point that the entire system essentially amounts to debtors prison. > The situation escalating to incarceration is largely avoidable. If the person literally cannot afford to pay, how is it avoidable? I assume if the person had assets, the court would have already seized them.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> I don't see how this is legal. If they've seized 65% of your paycheck already and it's still not enough, isn't this basically amounting to debtors' prison? In theory, the order is based on findings which include proven resources in terms of income, assets, etc. If there is an error or change that justifies changes to the order, there are, in principal, mechanisms available to get the order revised. Until it is revised, the presumption that if garnishments/seizures are not sufficient, the income or assets (which were found to suffice to support the amout of the order originally) have been shifted in such a way as to make them outside of the scope of garnishments/seizures, not that they have declined to the point to warrant a change to the order. The collections process and the process for adjusting the order based on changed circumstances are decoupled by design. Now, if the mechanisms for adjusting orders are slow, inaccessible, ineffective, etc. -- as, from what I understand, they often are -- there is still a very real problem. But the problem is with those mechanisms, not with the fact that the part of the system designed to do enforcement just does enforcement.
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoSome jurisdictions calculate based on what you should be able to make according to the judge who is likely not well informed of the market. Also to note, putting a child's father in jail where they can neither see nor support the child is not in the best interest of the child, yet that is their war cry every time you question their reasoning. Debtor prisons need to go.
- Someone1234 12y agoI legitimately don't understand America's obsession with sending so many people to jail. If you fail to pay child support here, all they do is just garnish your wages both for payment and also for repayment of missed child support. The employee actually never "sees" the money as it is taking directly from the employer.
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoDon't think of it as jail, think of it as slavery by corporations. Look into how prisons (even the public ones who outsource a lot of their business) make money off of their prisoners.
- Torgo 12y agoWhere is "here"?
- jseliger 12y agoI legitimately don't understand America's obsession with sending so many people to jail. It's not a widespread phenomenon—people don't think, "Let's send everyone to jail!" It's a set of incremental choices, somewhat similar to America's problems with regulatory thickets: http://www.city-journal.org/2011/21_4_regulations.html http://www.city-journal.org/2011/21_4_regulations.html . The U.S. also seems to be weirdly bad at doing cost-benefit analyses regarding jails.
- DanBC 12y agoHere's a BBC radio four programme that talks about some tiny cities in Missouri, and how they raise money from minor traffic violations, and how many people either can't pay the accumulating fines or can't get time off work for the court case and thus a bunch of people end up in prison. http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b05pqskm http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b05pqskm > Are excessive traffic fines and debtors' jails fuelling community tensions in suburban Missouri? Claire Bolderson reports on a network of ninety separate cities in St Louis County, most of which have their own courts and police forces. Critics say that their size makes them financially unviable and allege that some of them boost their incomes by fining their own citizens and locking them up when they can't pay. > This edition of Crossing Continents goes out and about in St Louis County to meet the people who say they are victims of a system which sees arrest warrants issued for relatively minor misdemeanours. Many of the victims are poor and black. The programme also takes us into the courts, and out onto the freeways with some of the County's police, who say they are upholding the law and promoting road safety. > The US government is not so sure. One of the towns in question is Ferguson where riots erupted after a white police officer shot a young black man dead last summer. In a recent report on the riots, the Department of Justice concluded that the Ferguson police had been stopping people for no good reason. It said they were putting revenue before public safety. > Claire Bolderson investigates how widespread the practice is and considers the impact on relations between citizens and the authorities that govern them. It's weird. The consequence for driving at twelve MPH over the speed limit shouldn't be prison (unless you're drunk, or by a school, or some kind of speeding unrepentant criminal). ("Crossing Continents" is a generally good, interesting programme and it's well worth listening to it.)