4 ms·
Ask HN: Is the term 'software craftsman' sexist?
In engineering postings for our company, we currently use the position name 'software craftsman'. It is meant to describe the emphasis that we put on creating elegant software and honing our craft. We want to continue to focus on this, but we don't want to unwittingly be turning some people off with the title. Does it seem like a sexist title to you?
- robin_reala 12y agoIt doesn’t jump out as being so, but it’s the subtle biases that are the difficult ones. Artisan has the same feel without a specific gender?
- zxcvcxz 12y agoIf someone doesn't want to work for your company because you used the word "craftsman" instead of "craftsperson", then it sounds like you just dodged a bullet. These types of people bring nothing of value to any community and are often more concerned with politics than actually creating something.
- cauterized 12y agoYou're ignoring the fact that terminology has subtle psychological effects. A woman might fail to apply not because she's consciously offended by the label but because she subconsciously identifies with it less than she would with a gender-neutral term.
- tptacek 12y agoIt's a silly title, and an <strike>obviously gendered</strike>† one. I'd lose it just because there's no upside to calling developers "software craftsmen". You remember Subway used to call the people behind the counter "sandwich artists", right? † may not actually be true, huh. still.
- gamechangr 12y agoAnyone who gets offended at that title, you are moments away from another conflict with them. Remember you want the builders, not the "we'll hold you to saying everything right"-ers.
- tptacek 12y agoYou could make the same argument about any role name.
- zxcvcxz 12y agoUntil I was about 14 years old I always thought craftsman and other words ending in "man" were based of the word "human". Even the word "woman" has "man" in it. Can we stop pretending these words are sexist? It's even more bigoted to assume sexism based on use of a common term ending in "man". It's border-line insanity and people just use it to push other people around and further a political agenda.
- dalke 12y agoIt's tempting to suggest to use "crafter", but that term has its own connotations different from "craftsman/craftswoman/craftsperson". See http://www.potters.org/subject46874.htm http://www.potters.org/subject46874.htm for examples from 2001: > [person #1:] I am uncomfortable with the word "crafter." I think it is used by people who do not know better in reference to anyone who practices any kind of craft. When we use the term "craftsman" or "craftsperson" we have a very definite concept in mind, and it is nothing like "crafter." > [person #2:] Crafter, hmmmm. The image that comes to my mind is a person who makes toilet seat covers from little pieces of foam rubber and similar do-dads from the kits A.C. Moore and similar stores sell. > [person #3:] I suspect that "crafter" is the newspaper's politically correct solution to the dilemma of the "man" in "craftsman". Kind of like "server" instead of "waitress/waiter". Unfortunately, the term "crafter" conjures up (in my mind) images of hot-gluing egg carton cut-outs together to form Christmas stars, and making poodles out of empty bread bags . . . you get the idea. Several in that thread preferred instead to avoid the issue and use "artisan". The Wikipedia entry http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Craft http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Craft concurs: "The traditional terms craftsman and craftswoman are nowadays often replaced by artisan and rarely by craftsperson (craftspeople)."
- brudgers 12y ago"Artisan" connotes work supported by patronage. Why not just be disruptive and go with "prima donna"?
- dalke 12y agoAre you sure about that? Perhaps you have mixed up "artisan" and "artist"? Both come from the root word ars (“art, skill”); from which we also get "artificial", for "made by skill", and the web site "Ars Technica" for the art/skill of technology. Quoting again from Wikipedia, at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artisan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artisan : "Artisans practice a craft and may through experience and aptitude reach the expressive levels of an artist" and "Artisans were the dominant producers of consumer products prior to the Industrial Revolution" Of course, WP can be wrong, so I pulled up a few examples from Google Books from the 20th century, so there could be no feedback from Wikipedia usage: I found https://books.google.com/books?id=CIH912O6ogAC&printsec=frontcover&dq=artisan&hl=en&sa=X&ei=hxM1VbaMBsyesgGh0IG4DA&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=artisan&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=CIH912O6ogAC&printsec=fron... : > Nehemiah Wallington was a London Puritan artisan .... Wallington remained in the house of his birth, where he learned his father's trade as a turner and became free of the Company of Turners by patrimony. And https://books.google.com/books?id=oRgNAQAAIAAJ&pg=PA34&dq=artisan&hl=sv&sa=X&ei=7BQ1VYXwH8a3sQGcroGICQ&ved=0CE8Q6AEwBg#v=onepage&q=artisan&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=oRgNAQAAIAAJ&pg=PA34&dq=ar... : > His set of motivations, ambition, resentment, acquisitiveness, duty, and altruism, is typical of that shown by the uneasy class of artisan and petit bourgeois reformers. Like Lovett, Place, and later George Howell, Linton was confident of his skills and entrepreneurial abilities and needed litle capital to make an income; but he, like them, remained vulnerable to market changes, indignant at his lowly status, and sensitive to rebuffs from superior powers. .... William Lovett, the upright, self-educated artisan radical ... And https://books.google.com/books?id=8YukeIgFlL4C&pg=PA105&dq=artisan&hl=sv&sa=X&ei=OBY1VdmEMMKqsgHbm4DgDA&ved=0CCAQ6AEwADgU#v=onepage&q=artisan&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=8YukeIgFlL4C&pg=PA105&dq=a... : > In olden days, these village artisans used to be self-sufficient in meeting their family requirements through the payments received by them by operating agriculture supporting artisan enterprises. ... Among the several artisan enterprises, the business of only blacksmiths, carpenters, cobblers and ropemakers is in existence today None of these suggest patronage of any sort. Until the industrial age, artisans were self-employed, and free from direct financial ties to a single patron.
- brudgers 12y agoWhat you're [with kind hopefulness] trying to say: + Our company wants to hire an engineer. + Our company values craft. Just say that. "Craftsman" creates an impression about your company. That impression is a first impression among the talent pool. Whether it is sexist or not is irrelevant, it conveys self-absorbed tone deafness. That's why you're asking. If the goal is to hire self-absorbed tone deaf staff, it's pitch perfect. To me, and I believe in the idea of craft, the choice of "craftsman" suggests a cluster of negative perceptions of the company: + true? == andmap complete_list_of_human_differences tone_deaf? It also suggests a deprofessionalization of engineering. Engineering is a higher standard than craft. Professional progression is: craftsman -> engineer not the other way round. Good luck.
- wglb 12y agoI have been known to get into arguments about this sort of label. My argument is that it is not sexist seems to be backed by Linda Greenlaw (made famous in the movie The Perfect Storm) who is called by many "the best fisherman", and on her website, describes herself "Between her three New York Times bestsellers and her role in the Discovery Channel's current hit series Swords, Linda Greenlaw has undoubtedly become America's best-known fisherman." I don't win many over with this argument, but I think there are better places to spend our energy in not making women and girls feel uncomfortable in this profession. We as an industry are doing a terrible job. And I think that "developer" is a good label in any case.
- dalke 12y agoOn the other hand, consider terms like "cowboy", "best boy", and "bus boy". While "cowgirl" exists, it's usually associated with a different set of roles than a cowboy. We also usually find "cowboy coder" in a negative context, but a search now for "cowgirl coder" finds more positive contexts. Eg, "My name is Tarah Wheeler Van Vlack, and I blog about Linux, coding, current technology, and women’s issues in the IT workplace right here at The Cowgirl Coder." and "I was one happy cowgirl coder, so I just kept going—learning as much as I could about design, development, and tech in general." (The general neutral term seems to be "cow hand" or "cattle handler".) The term "best boy" appears to be used for both men and women, with no difference in their roles. This would be a non-sexist, or at least minimally sexist, use of the term. The term "bus boy" appears to be disappearing, in place of busser. This is part of the general trend towards gender-neutral job titles, but part of me thinks it's also part of a longer trend of egalitarianism. That is, "boy" when directed towards an adult can indicate superior status. Hence why "garçon" - French for "boy" - should not be confused with the polite way to get the attention of a server in a French restaurant. As a more direct example, traditionally "boy" was also used by many white people to refer to any black male, no matter the age, specifically because blacks had inferior status than whites. (And then there's "cabana boy", which can be used in contexts where "young male" is an essential aspect of the job, in the same eye candy way that "young woman" was an aspect of being a cigarette girl.) You could pick out how "boy" is used in "best boy" to argue that it isn't a sexist term. But that argument would be incomplete because the issue isn't about any single title but the default-is-male implication in many titles. I believe that your argument with "fisherman" is similar. If I ask "how many businessmen wear dresses?", I suspect that most would be be confused, and think I am asking about male transvestites, and only secondarily consider that many businesspeople are businesswomen who wear dresses. I can ask the same question using other gendered topics. How many firemen have given birth? Of the policemen with heavy periods, do most prefer pads or tampons? I think more people would have a double-take with these -man/-men titles compared to the general-neutral forms of "firefighters" and "police officers". If I'm correct, that would suggest that -man in those titles comes with an assumption that they will be held by males, which makes them more sexist than the gender-neutral forms.
- ChikkaChiChi 12y agoI don't think it's sexiest, but I do think it's over-engineered. If you want to describe the emphasis you have on creating elegant software, do so in the description; which is meant to describe things.