4 ms·
Revolutionary war, not civil war. And the French joke is about France being quickly overrun in WWII, followed by being kicked out of a colony by the natives (Vi
by vacri 12y ago
Revolutionary war, not civil war. And the French joke is about France being quickly overrun in WWII, followed by being kicked out of a colony by the natives (Vietnam) at a time when the US war machine was seeing victory everywhere. That the US was kicked out by the same ex-colony is generally forgotten amongst the general projection of power they otherwise enjoyed around the globe.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- vacri 12y agoIt's hard to take a lecture on irony seriously, when it's given by someone who can't read past two sentences.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wtbob 12y ago> That the US was kicked out by the same ex-colony… Except that we weren't. We won the Vietnam War: when we left, North Vietnam had pledged to allow the people of South Vietnam to decide their destiny. Then they broke their promise and invaded, the Congress refused to aid South Vietnam, and that was all she wrote.
- vacri 12y agoIf you mean the Paris Peace Accords, that was never ratified by the US Senate (is it a promise if the other side don't hold up their end?), and the US had been reducing troops for nearly four years by that point ('Vietnamization') due to domestic public opposition. Ultimately the USA's primary war goal was to keep their puppet state of South Vietnam - a goal that certainly wasn't met. You have to squint your eyes pretty hard and turn your head sideways to claim the US won the Vietnam War.
- icegreentea 12y agoFinishing a war with exit conditions that you can't enforce doesn't really sound like winning in any meaningful sense.
- wtbob 12y agoWell, we promised to assist if North Vietnam broke its promises, but after Watergate the Congress felt it could break that promise. It really was a terrible time.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Except that we weren't. We won the Vietnam War North Vietnam achieved the political objectives for which it fought the war, the US did not. The US unambiguously and absolutely lost the war. That the US momentarily achieved a pause during which it could claim that it was in the process of securing the aims for which it fought the war does not mean that it won the war.
- bryanlarsen 12y agoTypo corrected, thanks. And yes, the meme about French military incompetence has some basis in reality, as all good memes do. But many other countries made horrible mistakes during WW2, and lost empires. Why do we make fun of the French and not the Dutch or Austrians or British or ...?
- protonfish 12y agoI suppose because a few years earlier France was believed to be a superior force - the only European country that could stand up to Nazi Germany. The fast and complete defeat by the Nazis demonstrated France to be incompetent and overconfident. Austria and Czechoslovakia were more political defeats (and France did nothing to stop these) and Britain fought until the bitter end. Poland also suffered significant military defeat, but didn't earn any more respect than France for it.