4 ms·
Except HTTPS does not (currently) solve data integrity issues in real life use cases, getting a certificate issued for someone else's domains is far from diffic
by ryanlol 12y ago
Except HTTPS does not (currently) solve data integrity issues in real life use cases, getting a certificate issued for someone else's domains is far from difficult... Especially since DNS is still plaintext.
- talideon 12y agoDNSSEC is meant to solve the integrity issue. Now, whether you feel it actually does the job is another matter. Personally, I use it on three domains, one which was done for testing purposes, and the other two because there are DNS records I would like to keep secure from manipulation. It'd be nice if TLSA/DANE was more widely supported, if only to be an additional bar against certificate forgery, but unfortunately it's not. It'd be good if DNS servers other than Knot had decent native support for signing, but they don't in general.
- icebraining 12y agogetting a certificate issued for someone else's domains is far from difficult Is it? Please provide a cert for ycombinator.com. Thanks.
- ryanlol 12y agohttp://krebsonsecurity.com/2015/02/webnic-registrar-blamed-for-hijack-of-lenovo-google-domains/ http://krebsonsecurity.com/2015/02/webnic-registrar-blamed-f... http://www.zdnet.com/article/revenge-hack-put-5-5-million-domain-names-allegedly-at-risk/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/revenge-hack-put-5-5-million-do... http://www.educause.edu/educause-security-breach-and-password-change-information http://www.educause.edu/educause-security-breach-and-passwor... If you're missing my point, these all of these hacked orgs had the capability to issue SSL certs.
- icebraining 12y agoFrom what I can tell, they're only resellers, the companies that actually issue the certs are GeoTrust and Symantec. In any case, I know it can and does happen, I just don't agree that it is "far from difficult". Having to hack an SSL provider is out of reach for the vast majority online thieves and casual snoopers.
- ryanlol 12y agoWell yes, none of them would actually have their own name on said certs. But all of them had API access to make symantec or geotrust issue certs. End result is the same. Having been involved in all of the hacks I linked, I wouldn't describe them as anything extraordinary.
- icebraining 12y agoWell yes, none of them would actually have their own name on said certs. But all of them had API access to make symantec or geotrust issue certs. End result is the same. Last time I used a RapidSSL reseller, I had to authenticate my domain against a GeoTrust controlled page before the cert was issued. Is this not the case with WebNIC?