3 ms·
I've seen a lot of people cheering for him. I've seen the man in person at various cons, and I think he's brilliant. The problem is, what are we supposed to do?
by freehunter 12y ago
I've seen a lot of people cheering for him. I've seen the man in person at various cons, and I think he's brilliant. The problem is, what are we supposed to do? Responsible disclosure: companies don't give a shit and will hide it. Full disclosure: you get sued and thrown in jail. Stunt hacking disclosure: people get scared even though it's easy to do. People demand something be done about it. The person who did the disclosure is alternatively viewed as a hero or a villain, but the thing is people are talking about the issue.
What's going to get people talking about security? "Target got hacked" "Oh, what a shame, I'll replace my card then go shopping at Target again". Or what about "I can bring down a plane while it is flying without needing a bomb. I can shut down hydroelectric dams from my living room and flood the entire state of Washington". Now you've got people talking.
"It's not particularly difficult" is the precise problem. It should be difficult. People should be demanding that gaining access to flight control and SCADA systems be made impossible by the general public. Dismissing a hack as "easy" means you're forgetting that it's a hack. It's not supposed to be possible, let alone trivial.
- tptacek 12y agoHow about this: don't publish a message to the world on Twitter saying that you are tinkering with what you believe to be flight control systems on an actual aircraft in transit?
- freehunter 12y agoThe problem is, he's done it before. And reported it to the airlines. And they've done nothing about it. I've heard him talk for years. Same thing every year. So seeing what I saw on Twitter was no surprise. He's not publishing an exploit on Twitter, he's making a joke to the followers he has that all know what he's done. He's making the joke that this year, again, the flight control systems are still vulnerable to literally anyone with a laptop and an ethernet cable. It's not that he's saying he's tinkering with what he believes to be flight control systems on an actual flight in transit. Of course he wouldn't do that... again. He's already done it once, years ago. Why was there no outrage then?
- tptacek 12y agoChoose your own adventure: (a) There is no real flaw here, other than the potential for maybe sending scary messages to people's In Flight Entertainment screens, and so the disruption he's causing by suggesting that there might be a flaw has no upside. (b) There is a real flaw here, for instance a message he can send across in-flight wireless that would deploy an oxygen mask, and his broadcast that he intended to tinker with that system is actually threatening. Am I missing a case (c) here?
- droopybuns 12y ago>>The person who did the disclosure is alternatively viewed as a hero or a villain, but the thing is people are talking about the issue. This is what I have concerns with. It's this "ends justify the means" argument that disregards some important consequences. There are many ways to breach these topics. You can go to the FAA. You can go to the individual companies. You can post on mailing lists. Ultimately, it may be a grind. But going the press route with inflammatory statements has consequences that exceed your own experiences with law enforcement. The legislators want to regulate infosec. It won't be pretty when they do. We need people to understand that a successful disclosure doesn't require headlines in arstechnica. You have to be empathetic to interactions with large organizations. Flashy press may get attention to your issue, but it can also have disastrous consequences for the rest of the community. Is it worth it?