3 ms·
>It is not proven that a million days of work equals superintelligence, even though obviously it would be more effective than 1 day. >This is not hypothetical;
by ikeboy 12y ago
>It is not proven that a million days of work equals superintelligence, even though obviously it would be more effective than 1 day.
>This is not hypothetical; the best known complete (not approximate) solutions to things like the traveling salesman problem, or to fitting odd sized containers into a container ship, are in fact exponential like that as far as we currently know.
Why would something need to solve problems like that to be significantly smarter than us? On real problems, working 1000 times as much time surely helps a lot. This is not even taking into account how much benefit you get from not being lazy and everything like that.
- DougMerritt 12y agoI am merely playing Devil's Advocate. I personally think that speedups of 1000-fold and million-fold etc. are a really big deal. "Quantity has a quality all its own." Nonetheless, it remains possible that there is a difference between fast intelligence solving things faster than we can, versus a superintelligence (from extraterrestrial aliens or something) that can create superior inventions or art or math or whatever that humans couldn't no matter how much time was allowed. Time is not always the issue. Anecdote from the Feynman biography "Genius": A physicist once said that there were two kinds of genius. The first kind was the sort that a good but non-genius physicist could imagine that they, too, could have achieved the same results as the genius, if only they could work on just that for decades or even lifetimes. But then he said that Feynman was the second kind of genius, whose results seemed to have been created by magic, and that ordinary physicists could not imagine achieving no matter how long they worked at it. The key thing here is that some pretty smart people already believe that there are at least two kinds of very high intelligence, one of which is not related to speed. So my point is merely that the same might apply to these other topics. We know so little about how to create a mind that there simply is no proof one way or the other. And that latter is an objective fact. There is no existing algorithms for creating human-level minds that merely needs more cpu + ram + disk to work, there just isn't. So we don't know. Different people choose to believe one way or the other. That's all.