4 ms·
Rigorous interviews will increase the false negative rate, at the expense of false positives. It's part of the culture at Microsoft and Google and other compani
by wallflower 17y ago
Rigorous interviews will increase the false negative rate, at the expense of false positives. It's part of the culture at Microsoft and Google and other companies.
- cdibona 17y agoI don't know why people are downvoting you. I can tell you that I've seen the same thing and having dealt with the fallout of bad hiring, I'd rather miss some good or even great candidates rather than hire someone bad. Edi: To clarify: I work at Google.
- roc 17y agoYou always run the risk of hiring someone bad. Interviewing, particularly rigorous interviewing, is a game that doesn't map very well onto work itself. That's why the true test of a hiring process is the firing process. If you can get rid of people that can't hack it, rather than letting them gather as detritus in your system, you'll be far better off than if you simply pretend that you can actually avoid mistakes.
- cdibona 17y agoI couldn't agree with you more.
- tedunangst 17y agoHiring two people so you can fire one is a lot more expensive than interviewing 10 to start.
- Dilpil 17y agoBut what are the relative probabilities that each method will result in exactly one good employee?
- Periodic 17y agoRigorous interviews will increase the number of false negatives, but decrease the number of false positives. I think your wording doesn't make that clear. When the cost of a false positive is high, e.g. a bad employee can be very expensive in terms of time and money before he is identified and fired if he is fired at all, then it is worth the cost of a few more false negatives to be more sure that you aren't getting false positives. It seems that very often someone who is the victim of being a false negative will rail against the system and claim it is unfair. If you can get them to look at it from the other side they will often agree the practice is quite reasonable.