4 ms·
Whole Brain Emulation is far off, even putting in moore's law, because we still are far off from understanding the brain. Yes, optogenetics and the connectome a
by Balgair 12y ago
Whole Brain Emulation is far off, even putting in moore's law, because we still are far off from understanding the brain. Yes, optogenetics and the connectome are going to bring us a long way there, but at the end, we have to understand that the brain is far to plastic to really know at any time point what is going on.
Experiments with macaque motor cortex (M1) provide a great example. When you cut off a finger or toe and record from M1 at the same time, you can watch the synapses change in real time. The remapping of M1 in the monkey starts the second that the nerves are severed. This remapping is poorly understood as it stands. Typically, the brain will allow innervation of the areas the control the other digits into the now useless area where the missing digit is. Even more interesting is when a pair of monkeys were stolen by anti-vivisectionists (The silver spring incident, I think [0]). When returned, the monkey's M1 had totally remapped from it's original state. Hippocampal neurogenesis [1] is also very poorly understood as it is today. Why our brains make new neurons and mostly for the more short-term memory centers in the hippocampus is a mystery.
What I am getting at is that we do not understand our own intelligence from the standpoint of it's mechanics enough to emulate a brain near at all. It is a looooooong ways off. To truly emulate it, you have to know that it is a moving target, and therefore any emulation is a moving one as well. One that has to live in a body that you emulate in a world that impinges on it. Trying to take the mind out of the body is impossible as well as trying to take both then out of the world. The results would have no meaning.
[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silver_Spring_monkeys https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silver_Spring_monkeys
[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neurogenesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neurogenesis
- foobarqux 12y agoThe point is that the danger of AGI is much easier to understand through whole brain emulation, not that whole brain emulation is necessarily imminent. That said, the most pernicious risk in AGI is that it will happen "slowly, then all at once"; that it will always be a long way away until the day it isn't. That said, it isn't obvious to what extent we need to understand the brain in order to transfer it to another substrate: much of engineering relies on a simplified understanding of the world.