5 ms·
You can stop talking about right and wrong if you like. But the rest of us are comfortable using it for moral terms. If you think those things need a stronger e
by wpietri 12y ago
You can stop talking about right and wrong if you like. But the rest of us are comfortable using it for moral terms. If you think those things need a stronger epistemological basis, you are welcome to work on constructing that.
> all opinions deserve a hearing
If you believe that, then I'm sure you're out working for making sure the voiceless and downtrodden get their opinions heard. In addition to your time here arguing to make sure socially dominant groups get their already-familiar opinions heard yet more.
I don't believe it, though. Here are some people expressing opinions:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elizabeth_Eckford#/media/File:Little_Rock_Desegregation_1957.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elizabeth_Eckford#/media/File:L...
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:WBC_20051202_sacco-topeka5.jpg http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:WBC_20051202_sacco-to...
I don't think racist or homophobic opinions need to be heard more. That is not to suggest taking away their right to speak or publish. But their rights do not override the rights of other people to speak in response, or their right to freely assemble.
To think otherwise is to confuse the standards of a particular kind of academic discourse with a much broader set of dialog. Major social change doesn't happen only through polite disagreement. That's especially true when the social changes are about the relative power of groups, and the way powerful groups maintain dominance through silencing people they don't like.
America isn't free because we petitioned the king and he said, "Gosh, your points are reasonable." We fought. The slaves aren't free because the American South said, "Oh, now we see that these folks are equal." We fought. Women's suffrage, the civil rights movement, the gay rights movement: all of it involved a lot of shouting and major social unrest.
Whatever you intend by it, applying your argument to any of these would have aided the continuance of oppression. And that's exactly how many people apply your argument today. So you can keep making it, but it's not going to convince me; as much as I like civil dialogue, I like civil rights more.
- Karunamon 12y agoYour last comment strikes me as quite possibly the largest and most possibly damaging false dichotomy I've heard in a long, long time. This: as much as I like civil dialogue, I like civil rights more. If that's the way you actually think, to the letter, if this wasn't just a turn of phrase or perhaps not worded correctly on accident, you've very well scared the hell out of me. You've described your mindset as it's people on your side in one corner, and "civil dialogue" in the other, with the latter given short shrift because, as you well know, you are In the Right, and all of those people who want civil dialogue must therefore necessarily be In The Wrong because they are necessarily against $good_thing. This is fundamentally irrational, and the fact that you treat that as a badge of honor is hardly admirable. I'm archiving this thread.. perhaps someone else will be able to respond to this line of reasoning, because it's fundamentally alien to me.
- wpietri 12y agoI don't think that civil rights and civil dialog are dichotomous. But I don't think that the former can always be achieved with the latter. If you have example of major improvements in civil rights that were achieved solely through meek, polite dialog, you are welcome to share them. Given that, the rest of your comments don't seem to apply. Also, the "I am seizing the final word" thing is kinda lame.
- wpietri 12y agoComing back to this, I wonder: What other relationship do you see as possible between civil dialog and civil rights? If you like civil dialog more than civil rights, then you're basically saying people should be oppressed so you don't have to deal with unpleasantness. On the other hand, you could be saying that the two are never in conflict. But that's an empirical claim that under every possible circumstance civil dialog is the absolute best way to achieve civil rights. That is bold claim for which you've presented no evidence. I've given plenty of historical examples that suggest otherwise. Is there some other construction you could possibly mean?
- Karunamon 12y agoYour claim is, essentially, people must behave uncivilly to gain representation/rights for themselves - and the logical conclusion of this, you've excused any and all antisocial behavior as long as the cause is good enough. Society does not work that way.
- wpietri 12y agoThat is not the logical conclusion of my view. That is you slippery-sloping your way to a straw man. And you again dodge the hard questions: How much oppression are you willing to tolerate so that dominant groups never have to feel uncomfortable? On the other hand, if you believe that civil rights are always achievable through polite dialog, where are you examples? Where is the demonstration that the US's revolutionary war was just a big stupid mistake? I believe you don't have them because you don't actually have a functioning theory of social change or a big interest in ending oppression. Whether you like it or not, the only real effect of your behavior is to maintain oppressive social structures. You may say that you want something else, but the first rule of working therapists is that when words and behavior conflict, always believe the behavior. Why shouldn't I believe your behavior here?
- atlantic 12y ago> In addition to your time here arguing to make sure socially dominant groups get their already-familiar opinions heard yet more. You seem to have fallen into your own trap. You've assumed that I belong to a particular social group (wrongly, as it happens, but that's irrelevant), and consequently dismissed my argumentation out of hand, without effectively countering it. And regarding your historical arguments, they rely on a somewhat naïve view of the process of history, as driven by exceptional individuals such as civil rights campaigners, rather than by large-scale currents. It would be just as easy to argue that such movements as enfranchisement and feminism succeeded when they did (after failing so many times in the past) because the social and ideological climate was ripe for change. Which would mean that social action movements are a lot less relevant than you would like to believe. You're in the domain of irrationality. You "know" you're right, and I should just shut up because I'm affiliated to the "wrong" social group, while your own group can shout down and bully into submission everybody else. You're taking democracy for granted, and undermining the very system that is giving you the freedom to express yourself. Do you think that the slavers of the past thought that they were wrong? No; they "knew" they were right, and it was "obvious" that the white man was superior. Beware of the obvious; common sense is not your friend.
- wpietri 12y agoI'm not assuming anything about you and don't "know" I'm right. I'm talking about your behavior. You could be an AI or an uplifted dog for all I know. But an argument that demands that change only happen through meek, polite statements is in effect arguing for the status quo. I also disagree that my view of historical change requires exceptional actors. I think it happens mainly on the individual-to-individual level. But I don't think it can happen politely.
- atlantic 12y ago> But an argument that demands that change only happen through meek, polite statements is in effect arguing for the status quo. That's a caricature. Change should happen through dialogue between the various parties involved, and that dialogue should be based on rational argument, until some kind of consensus or majority decision can be reached. Nothing revolutionary here; I'm describing how democracies work. I didn't say anything about the tone of the dialogue itself. What you seem to be arguing for is that certain parties be shut out of the dialogue altogether, because their opinions deviate too far from those of your group; and also that your opinion does not necessarily require rational underpinnings, so long as you feel certain enough of the righteousness of your cause.