5 ms·
"Could have if they wanted to" is the core signature of ADHD. Imagine knowing that there are lots of things you could, theoretically do with the resources you
by derefr 12y ago
"Could have if they wanted to" is the core signature of ADHD.
Imagine knowing that there are lots of things you could, theoretically do with the resources you have at your disposal—but having none of the "willpower" thing that lets people do things that are even slightly boring or unpleasant in the short term.
Imagine wanting to learn skills that require practice, but being unable to invoke whatever mysterious forces cause this "practice" to happen.
Imagine being amazing at stupid skills that you got because their training mechanisms involve short reward loops (for example, video games) and knowing your own potential, and hearing over and over everyone around you tell you about that potential and encouraging you to use it, but just feeling a stab of "ugh" whenever you even consider starting that is utterly insurmountable.
Imagine, even, having skills that could get you a great, well-paying job (e.g. programming—something, as it turns out, that has a short-reward-loop method of learning) but then just not being able to work up the desire to apply for a job; to go to the interviews you applied for; to come to work on time each day; to do anything other than surf the Internet once you're there.
This isn't abstract to me—
I failed out of university. I was homeless on-and-off for a year and a half. I went back to live with my parents for a year. Then (at the age of 24) I got diagnosed with ADHD and put on a medication for it.
Now, two years later, I'm making $250K/yr working as a CTO for a financial startup.
Many people I met while homeless, looking back, also had all the signs of having had ADHD—or, if not that, then major depression, or a social anxiety disorder. None of them thought of themselves as having a condition; they just "didn't want to work." They didn't realize that what they "wanted" was in large part a function of what they would or would not flinch away from because of pain; and that their pain response to attempting certain things was not a matter of "character", not and not something they had failed to learn or needed to "work through", but a treatable handicap, like nearsightedness.
I wish I could take every one of them to the same psychiatrist I went to, but it took me eight months on a waiting list to talk to them. There are far, far too few practicing psychiatrists to help all the people that need help. Something about this needs to change.
- IkmoIkmo 12y agoMan that hits home, only I'm still 24 with a complete lack of motivation. I keep telling myself that I'm using it as an excuse and that it's really laziness, but if I'm intellectually honest with myself I don't really believe that. It's like I miss some hormone that motivates me, similar to perhaps a gay person missing the sexual attraction to the opposite sex and not having any way to change that, in a world where nobody is gay and nobody gets why you don't have that genuine, inherent attraction. Feel free to elaborate a bit on how you eventually got out of this if you'd like, I'd love to hear more. Perhaps it'll help me, too. Thanks for sharing in any case :)
- ams6110 12y agoA good book to read on this is The War of Art by Steven Pressfield. While his experience was that of a writer overcoming difficulties with motivation and persistence, most of it applies very generally.
- IkmoIkmo 12y agoThanks!
- AustinG08 12y agoI used to struggle with motivation. Especially at your age (I'm about to 30). Motivation is a byproduct of discipline. You need to integrate some kind of discipline in your life. Something huge that changed my work ethic was when I bought a whiteboard. I always have two lists on it. One of the lists is "Everything I need to do." This has things like 'pay my taxes by X date', 'call my insurance company and find y out', 'start this project', 'build that dream car i have always wanted to build'. Some of the stuff might always be on it, at which point I can start really looking at those things and figuring out whether I plan on doing them, how bad I want to do it, and if it's worth my time vs the other stuff I want to do. The second list is titled "Today", and always leads with today's date. Under that are things that I should really do today, or at least try to start. Some times the things on it roll over to the following day, sometimes they get dropped back into the larger 'everything' list. But when I do something, whether it's "Take out the trash", or "Call Person X", I get to cross that thing off the list. It stays crossed out for the whole day until that night when I reassess my everything list, erase crossed out items, change the current date, etc. It has helped me stay on task and get things done tremendously. The whiteboard has had a tremendous impact on my productivity.
- Karunamon 12y agoThis is a completely separate problem than the GP poster described, and comes off as rather insensitive too, considering they described, yknow, getting on medication to fix their broken neurochemistry. I'm serious sir/madam, few good insights ever come of the form "You have $difficult_problem, you just need to do X to solve it". Personal example: I get done the stuff that I need to do, but for a good chunk of it, I hate every single minute of it. Example: I just got done with a number of uni assignments - they were not difficult, the material wasn't uninteresting, but I already knew the info, I already knew I already knew the info, so going through the motions to actually get credit for it sucks. As in "God, I wish I was doing just about anything else right now"-level sucks. The way they described that bolt of "ugh" that stops any motivation to do anything substantial? That is my fucking life right now, and I can't put down into words how much I want to get that part of me changed. All the whiteboards and organized-ness and "discipline" in the world only ensures that you're getting things done (going through the motions) - it does nothing to ensure that you will enjoy the process or even necessarily the results of the process. If you hate everything you have to do, what's the point in living?
- iowegoog 12y ago"I went back to live with my parents for a year" There you go. You were always rich ass spoiled kid. You chose homelessness. Parent or Parent->Parent commenters point is that many people ( at in least in SF) are homeless by choice. So at 24 you had ADHD. At 26 you are making $250k ?? Something doesn't add up. Thay's kick ass money google pays to 5+ yrs experienced engineers. Its people like you who shadow true needy homeless people. All resources you consumed while being homeless could have been helpful for true homeless. Also, no offence but which startup would hire ADHD person as CTO ? Its such a high responsibility position and many people's job depend on it ( directly or indirectly).
- derefr 12y ago1. ADHD can come and go, like the major depressive episodes of clinical depression[1]. I had 5+ years of experience (I started programming when I was 11, in fact); my period of homelessness came after having already worked several great jobs (that I got no thanks to my parents—a retired tradesman and a gas-station attendant with a combined income of $20k/yr.) I've also built out a pretty good portfolio of work in realtime distributed systems engineering. I "burned out" of one job I had at the time, and just never looked for the next one. I lived off savings[2] for a year while trying to start a startup, until my savings ran out. Then I was homeless. 2. I was eliding a lot by saying that I was living with my parents. My parents are bankrupt, now divorced, and live in the country. (My father is bipolar, which drove much worse things to happen in their lives for decades—a string of half-baked entrepreneurial ventures each dropped after heavy investment whenever he entered his depressive phase, for just one. Moving out at 16 was a decision I still do not regret.) I actually went to live with my grandparents, illegally, in their no-tenants-under-the-age-of-retirement condo, because they insisted that I stay with them even though they couldn't afford to support themselves, let alone me. (They certainly couldn't bail my parents out.) This was a move that caused me to be two hours' commute from the nearest city of population greater than 10,000. While looking for a new job, I commuted that distance, both ways, nearly every day. It wasn't that I wasn't actively looking for a job; it was that each individual job application was, effectively, an arduous process it would take weeks/months to recover from. The strain I put on them was what made me finally decide I needed to see a psychiatrist. That was only for the last few months of my "stint" at homelessness, though. Before then, I was just ducking my almost-always-absent landlord, effectively squatting in the room I had previously been renting, and trying to scape together a dollar or two each week to buy bags of rice and such. Should I also mention that I mostly paid for living expenses while going to [community] college—for the year or two I did—by getting student loans and then avoiding spending them on anything non-essential, like textbooks? 3. I was never on welfare, or employment insurance, or on any government assistance programs of any kind. You know why? They were too much effort to get into! Also, they effectively required applications to their services to happen near-simultaneously with the loss of one's job. One of the most common effects of ADHD is putting off paperwork, homework, filing your taxes, etc. until it's far too late. I was homeless, but I wasn't a beggar on the street. Instead, I was couch-surfing without a dollar in my bank account, tens of thousands of dollars in credit-card debt, no friends within a thousand miles of the city I lived in, and a rapidly-worsening state of health because I couldn't pay for my own healthcare. 4. I wasn't hired as CTO; the previous CTO quit, and I worked my way up. This isn't a big company, so just think "tech lead", not "guy in an expensive business suit who bosses around tech leads." I've never mentioned having ADHD to anyone at any job I've worked at since beginning treatment for it. Medicated, I'm normal; just as a nearsighted person wearing glasses is normal. Effectively, in my mind, I don't have ADHD now—ADHD is a condition I would get (again) if I stopped taking my medication. ADHD is a deficiency of an essential chemical my body cannot produce on its own—to wit, a vitamin deficiency. Do we say that people with scurvy always have scurvy, but were are just temporarily well as long as they continue to consume vitamin C? No; they're normal on vitamin C. --- [1] I've almost come to believe that all the talk of "burn out" in programming is because ADHD is pretty common in programmers—or rather, programming is a pretty common thing to get into for people with ADHD—and so, to someone who has undiagnosed ADHD but to a degree that's normally manageable with self-medication through things like caffeine, a stressful+unrewarding job can heighten the symptoms to the point that it can't just be managed/brushed aside, and has to be addressed as a problem. But, since it required the triggering event (a bad job), it gets blamed on the trigger-condition instead of on the vulnerability it exposed. [2] Savings amounting to a few thousand dollars. Junior programming jobs here don't tend to pay well, nor was I very savvy about what I should charge for the contracting work I did, nor was it very easy to get hired by places with money given my lack-of-a-college-diploma. I did figure it out the general solution, in the end: working remotely for US companies, instead of accepting the local prevailing wage.
- Karunamon 12y ago..holy shit, you just described my life. I've always described it as "hyper boredom". My desire to do stuff is just nonexistent a lot of the time. but just feeling a stab of "ugh" whenever you even consider starting that is utterly insurmountable. This, holy fucking shit, this! This problem, right here, is a massive thing in my life! How did the diagnosis process work? You just explained your symptoms to your GP and they referred you or..?
- soylentcola 12y agoVery similar story here. It had been suggested that I see someone regarding ADHD when I was younger but my dad didn't really "believe" it existed. Nothing that couldn't be fixed with old fashioned grit and character building. Dropped out of college after losing almost all motivation to go to class or constantly forgetting things I had to do. This just started a cycle of self loathing and depression and feeling like a worthless fuckup. Eventually landed a low paying job despite not having my degree and with the help of my SO, got through the long waiting period and other hurdles to see a doctor. Got treatment, went back to school and finished my degree with nothing lower than a B in any class. Not making nearly what you are but where I live at least, the difference between $20k/yr and $60k/yr (especially as one half of a pair of "DINKs") is massive. Medication to tweak the dopamine response curve isn't perfect but I have it to thank for at least enabling me to do the normal hard work of making it in life.