9 ms·
Nice Downtowns: How Did They Get That Way? People Made Them
- jseliger 12y agoNotice: It took a long time, but for nearly fifty years this effort has carried on, successfully I think, but hardly anyone recalls that the origins of the effort were very deliberate and came about when the nighttime downtown was the precise opposite of what it is today, and few people probably think of it as involving a conscious goal then or now. They just think "that's the way Seattle is." But Seattle wasn't. This should remind us of yesterday's post (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9400259 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9400259) about the importance of long-term planning. The good things about today came about because people decades ago consciously made efforts to make them happen. The good things that are to come—light rail, bike lanes, reasonable rents that stem from increasing housing supply—are only going to come if people consciously make efforts to make them happen. See also Zero to One (http://jakeseliger.com/2014/09/24/zero-to-one-peter-thiel-and-blake-masters/ http://jakeseliger.com/2014/09/24/zero-to-one-peter-thiel-an...).
- fennecfoxen 12y agoThose efforts also need humility. In San Jose, Rod Diridon and the VTA thought the city would radically reshape itself around the light rail, which didn't really happen: http://www.mercurynews.com/traffic-old/ci_22264605/25-years-later-vta-light-rail-among-nations http://www.mercurynews.com/traffic-old/ci_22264605/25-years-... For those not familiar with the VTA, I'll just say that it's the kind of light rail system that passes by the airport, but the closest stop to the terminal is more than a mile's walk away.
- WalterBright 12y agoNot serving the airport is amazing.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoIt runs so damn close along North First, its a crime it wasn't connected in the first place.
- jessaustin 12y agoI've seen this mistake repeated in numerous cities.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- eclipxe 12y agoArticle is a bit old but it is sorta happening along first street. There is a significant increase in density along the first street and Tasman corridor - anchored by Samsungs huge new campus. I expect light rail usage over the next 3-5 years to greatly increase at least in North SJ.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoAnd light rail along Tasman and North First is slow as heck.
- lawnchair_larry 12y agoYou're better off walking if you're in a hurry anyway. You'll get to your destination just as fast as the VTA will take you there.
- hueving 12y agoThere is bias here though. They mention that cities with good downtowns have stories histories that people come up with about the planning that went into it. That will happen with every single successful thing. Conversely, nobody wants to take credit for a failure so people are happy to say that a downtown got crappy because of a lack of planning. Downtowns die because money flows out of the city due to the economy or because the culture transitions to one based on suburbs. There are many people that have no interest in living in an expensive downtown apartment. If you start to lose the small percentage of the population that desires and can afford the downtown lifestyle, it will either on the vine regardless of the amount of planning that goes into them.
- BrainInAJar 12y agoCulture doesn't just "change", forces shape it. Culture moves towards a suburban, car oriented culture when the local governments pay (at great taxpayer expense) for an overbuilt highway system to quickly get people in and out of it.
- Cloudy 12y agoThe attraction of suburban life vs dense urban downtown would be mostly the same if public transit routes were just as available. (Although I would imagine the availability of easier transportation would certainly increase restaurant & entertainment offerings from outside commuters who don't normally have car access) Some people prefer their peaceful cookie cut house and desire nothing much to do with the big cities. More often then not it's zoning, job availability, and affordability.
- BrainInAJar 12y agoI'd wager what people actually prefer would be wide open fields where everything you see in front of you is yours but they can't afford that, hence they settle on a suburban lawn. Economics drive suburbanization, not any sort of actual human desire. If the economics skew away from the heavy subsidies for suburbs, people stop expanding them.
- erikpukinskis 12y agoI feel a little sad when I read this "this used to be a crack house and now it's a lovely restaurant" narrative. There is a glee with the notion of cleaning something up. That's an admirable thing of course. But I wonder about the people who were living in that "crack house". Where are they now? What municipal policies led to them being there in the first place? Was the problem really cleaned up, or was it just flushed away?
- ebiester 12y agoThis is where they went: http://www.salon.com/2013/12/17/more_proof_that_americas_prison_epidemic_is_a_complete_disaster_partner/ http://www.salon.com/2013/12/17/more_proof_that_americas_pri... By and large, we made it illegal to be poor in the city.
- rayiner 12y agoThat article triggered my "bullshit" detector: > In 2010, The Economist highlighted a case in which four Americans were arrested for importing lobster tails in plastic bags rather than in cardboard boxes. That violated a Honduran law which that country no longer enforces, but because it’s still on the books there its enforced here. “The lobstermen had no idea they were breaking the law. Yet three of them got eight years apiece.” When the article was published 10 years later, two of them were still behind bars. Yeah, that's a pile of shit: http://www.eenews.net/stories/1059964426 http://www.eenews.net/stories/1059964426. TL;DR version: they were arrested and convicted for importing over $15 million in illegal lobster tails. The plastic versus cardboard boxes issue is a red herring--it was the means by which they concealed the undersized tails, not the primary basis for prosecution. As for the Honduran law--the Court of Appeals determined that the Honduran law was in fact valid during the relevant time period. Moreover, the Lacey Act only criminalizes importing animals harvested in violation of a foreign law when the importer knows or should know about the law. The prosecution proved that the defendants took measures to conceal the undersized tails and evade inspectors.
- tptacek 12y agoThey also at times routed their lobster tails through Canada to avoid detection --- for lobsters sourced in the jurisdiction of Honduras and destined for Alabama. People love to fixate on the "undersized lobster" part of this story, but that's an irrelevant detail. The important fact is that all fishermen were required to take lobsters under a specific set of rules, and report their compliance with those rules. This particular fisherman cheated the rest of the market by ignoring those rules. Nobody bats an eyelid when "banksters" are convicted and serve sentences† for violating rules far more abstract and far less connected to real-world consequences than overfishing regulations. † yes, this actually happens, probably more often than it does to fishermen
- pkaler 12y agoIn Vancouver, we call this Vancouverism: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vancouverism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vancouverism It is a long-term commitment to mixed used development, walkable streets, view corridors for everyone, public parks within walking distance, and mass public transit into and out of the core.
- pekk 12y agoThese things are by definition not for everyone who is driven out by high property prices
- joelgrus 12y agoSo I live in downtown Seattle, and there are not a ton of residents here. For one thing, there are no schools in downtown Seattle, and so almost no one with kids wants to live downtown. And while I wouldn't characterize it as "dead and deserted" at night, it's not particularly lively either. In fact, most people think it's weird that I live downtown. It's definitely not a common choice around here. It is largely true that young tech workers want to live "in the city" (as opposed to in the suburbs), but (at least in Seattle) that means one of the "cool" neighborhoods in the city, not downtown.
- dvanduzer 12y agoDowntown Seattle's geography didn't allow for the sheer number of parking lots Denver's earlier buildout phases did, but... We call them infills here. Watch for residential development popping up around you. Seattle is ripe.
- santaclaus 12y agoEven in America's largest city, 'downtown' isn't a terribly attractive area. How many people really want to live in midtown Manhattan? Most of the action is a bit further out, and you'll find a more lively nightlife somewhere like Williamsburg (I imagine Cap Hill in Seattle is similar).
- eclipxe 12y agoLower East Side/Chelsea had way more lively nightlife to me than Williamsburg. The burg just gets all of the hipster press and attention but it wasn't all that of a lively hotspot when I was there.
- FlannelPancake 12y agoEh? > 'downtown' isn't a terribly attractive area. > midtown Midtown is not downtown: Hence the name midtown - it's about midway between downtown and uptown. Most people would consider the villages as the start of downtown.
- bretthopper 12y ago
- mcjiggerlog 12y agoAs someone who has lived in the UK, France and Spain - the whole concept of it being normal that "downtown" is grim is really strange. Over here the city centre is typically the nicest (and most expensive) part of the city to live in. I guess it stems from the relative ages of cities in North America vs Europe. A typical city centre in Europe would have been the entirety of the city at some point and is therefore where the most historic buildings, oldest businesses etc. are located. Whereas in NA, cities are a lot younger and grew much faster meaning that is not so much the case.
- raverbashing 12y agoWell, Boston, NYC, amongst others in the USA have nice downtowns. Not to mention Toronto, Montreal, Quebec City, Ottawa and other cities in Canada.
- santaclaus 12y agoNative New Yorkers absolutely looooooove Time Square...
- Ollinson 12y agoTimes Square is not downtown new york.
- ardit33 12y agoUnion Square is the heart of NYC. Almost all lines intersect there, (the L from Brooklyn as well), and it is next to (within 10mins walk) of East Village, West Village, Lower East Side, Chelsea, FlatIron, Kips Bay, etc, which are the most interesting parts of NYC and have both commercial and residential buildings It used to be a dangerous dump 20 years ago, and now it is awesome.
- santaclaus 12y agoEhhhh, that area is a bit B&T at night...
- wdr1 12y agoI'm surprised he didn't mention Santa Monica's downtown. In the 80s it was generally considered seedy & filled with blight. The now-famous Santa Monica Pier was in disrepair. 3rd Street wasn't really a thing, nor was Santa Monica Place, Casa del Mar and so on. Today the area is hot enough that it commands rents comparable to SF & Manhattan. The median rent for the area is $3,200 and one bedrooms in newer construction (w/o an ocean view!) can go for $5k.
- beachstartup 12y agoi've lived in sm for 6 years now. it's changed dramatically even in that short period of time. i like to think of santa monica as an improved version of san francisco, with the rest of los angeles attached as a bonus. if you live and work (i.e. no commute) in santa monica, it's easily the highest quality of life in urban california, and i've lived in pacific heights, downtown san diego, and central LA proper.
- Cloudy 12y agoSan Fransisco has a more more diverse set of options for nightlife and culture compared to downtown Santa Monica. If you bicycle around Santa Monica/Venice there's not much going on compared to SF. Sure you could hop in your car and drive to Hollywood, DTLA, or other parts of the city but that's not really the same as the work/live urban core ideal.
- forkandwait 12y agoThe only thing that killed happy dense urbanism in the USA is 50 years of weird mortgage and highway subsidies that encouraged suburban growth even when it makes almost no sense whatsoever, combined with a lingering Anglo anti-urbanist set of cultural assumptions. However, worldwide, the USA is the weird place, and mostly the core parts of cities are better than the rest.
- fapjacks 12y agoI'm sorry, but where are the people who think that nice downtowns aren't the result of long-term planning and hard work by city officials? I'm genuinely curious, as this is not something I am accustomed to hearing. Whenever the conversation of a nice downtown comes up, it's almost always accompanied by conversation about the planning and execution that must have happened to make it that way.