4 ms·
He's talking about right after that gap. At the start of the gap the disparity between real and expected holdings is small, but right after the gap, the dispari
by jstanley 12y ago
He's talking about right after that gap. At the start of the gap the disparity between real and expected holdings is small, but right after the gap, the disparity is huge, implying a lot of btc were lost during the gap, or a mistake has been made in the analysis.
- wongarsu 12y agoYes, almost all of the ~600BTC from that huge increase in expected BTC holdings during Jul-Oct 2011 are unaccounted for. But this seems completely orthogonal to the fact that they loose track of ~450BTC during that timeframe, which this "gap" is about. Those are two seperate events in the same timeframe: The ~450BTC which cause the gap all reappear in November 2011, while the disparity is growing at a rate that perfectly matches the disparity growth after the gap (see third graph). Also these ~500BTC aren't "almost all" "missing" bitcoins, but only half of the bitcoins they can't account for.
- makomk 12y agoThe problem is that they have no way of knowing how many BTC they actually lost track of during that period or whether all of it did reappear. For those 5 months they have no idea which addresses Mt Gox was keeping the vast majority of their BTC in or how much they had, and if any funds remained in those addresses after November 2011 the whole argument breaks down. They're assuming that none did because the amount of funds in addresses they know about after the gap is roughly the same as before the gap - but the amount of BTC that Mt Gox's accounts claimed they have doubled during that time period, and there's no way to tell whether Mt Gox actually had a shortfall or there was more BTC but only a portion of it got moved to known addresses.