3 ms·
...what? Maybe try starting at the top of this thread and going through it again? Nobody's claiming a right to anyone's brain. It's the fact that you're access
by manigandham 12y ago
...what? Maybe try starting at the top of this thread and going through it again?
Nobody's claiming a right to anyone's brain. It's the fact that you're accessing content that was only offered with the advertisements.
Boiling things down to the technical level just avoids the actual discussion. Sure bittorrent is just a protocol and software, but downloading movies illegally is still piracy right? You can build whatever software you want, but if it's used to DDoS someone then there's a problem. It's not about the tool, it's what its used for.
By blocking ads, you are breaking the terms of use of all the sites that provide you content for free in exchange for ads. If you want to be left alone, then just dont go to these sites... Advertising isn't broken, it's the morality of users who want anything and everything for free.
- scrollaway 12y ago> By blocking ads, you are breaking the terms of use of all the sites that provide you content for free in exchange for ads. No... you're not. You're just not. When I visit a website, I don't agree to any terms of use. I don't sign anything. And if there's some out there that make me tick some bullshit box, it's nothing legal. You have a superbly warped view of the world and I really can only encourage you to get out of your advertising bubble and try to look at websites with a less-informed eye, a process which is not easy to do I'm well aware. Users don't want "anything and everything for free". They just don't want you. I'm happy to pay sites, apps I use on a daily basis but I'm not happy to let them serve me ads. Especially when those ads suck - and they do suck. This is content I am not willing to subject my retinas to, and by extension my computer because it only serves to slow it down, and sometimes be an infectious carrier. You're claiming a right to people's brains. You're claiming people who don't observe that right are breaking "terms of use" (they're not). "Just don't go to these sites" doesn't work. The internet is not a place where I research the publisher of the content I am about to consume before I even consume it by clicking the link someone just sent me. You're not fooling anyone, and I really hope you're not fooling yourself in thinking that.
- manigandham 12y agoI'm not sure why you're refusing to see the value exchange here and instead keep focusing on your ability to do something vs. whether it's acceptable. Terms of use dont require a signature and online/global environment makes it more difficult but they are real and do apply. Perhaps you've never actually created any content but you can talk to the millions of creators out there who would like to be paid for their work and get some more perspective. Users do want to get stuff for free. The creators/publishers give away content in exchange for ads. If they choose to have paid access, then that's your option. It's up to the publishers to decide how they want to give access to their content and service. If it's through ads, then that's the deal. If you don't want ads, then you should only stick to publishers that offer paid subscriptions without ads. You don't need to research the publisher, if they have a paywall then you'll see it when you click. Otherwise they're opting to show ads instead. Tampering with their response to only see what you want isn't ok just because you have the technical ability to do so. It's similar to pirating movies, just because you can doesn't mean you argue that its legal or right. Maybe more people are willing to pay money to read articles without ads, that's something content publishers need to research and offer themselves but that's a completely different topic. Adblocking right now is somewhere in the gray area of legality and morality and while you can choose to do it, please don't assume that means it's right or fair or that we're all idiots trying to force it on you.
- scrollaway 12y agoYou're trying really hard to make this an ethical argument where there aren't grounds for it. I work with content creators in the gaming community on a regular basis and I am well aware of the "content creator's perspective". Believe it or not, a lot of content creators fully understand why someone would use adblock. They also understand that their success isn't measured in how many ads they print, but how much reach they have; and if you start pissing on people who block ads (Who are going to be a huge part of your userbase), you will suffer for it. ESPECIALLY in the gaming community, which holds grudges like you wouldn't believe. The only ones who believe blocking ads is in a "grey area of morality" are advertisers. You can't just claim something is unethical because it hurts your business. I boycott Paypal for example, and I'm sure Paypal would make the case that it's unethical to boycott them. Entering the business of giving free shit in exchange for the good will of people to funnel them advertising revenue is, and should be, a calculated risk. There is no such thing as an "exchange of content for ad impressions". The "exchange" between the user and the content producer is free, and the real exchange happens between the content producer and the advertiser. The interaction between the business and the user is limited to the content they offer, and anti-value added by the advertiser (which is then an exchange between the user and the advertiser). As a user, I choose to make an exchange with the business (in most cases not involving money), and I choose not to make an exchange with the advertiser because I don't trust the advertiser. I don't want the advertiser anywhere near me or my children. Work on that image and we can talk.