3 ms·
From outside, US education seems astonishingly bad, especially for a 1st world country. In US, 14 years old kids just start to learn how to solve for X, while i
by golergka 12y ago
From outside, US education seems astonishingly bad, especially for a 1st world country. In US, 14 years old kids just start to learn how to solve for X, while in Russia it's time to finish trigonometry and move to calculus.
- S4M 12y agoWow, that indeed doesn't look good. In France I learnt trigonometry at 13 (I gonna turn 34 this year so maybe it has changed by now).
- jostylr 12y agoThe problem is less about when someone learns math (an easy subject once one cares), but rather the attitude about math. In the US, people walk away from math education hating and fearing math. "Math is important, but I can't do math" is the attitude many have. What is the attitude of general people in France? Do they take math ignorance as a point of pride as they do in the US or they take math knowledge and use as a point of pride?
- thaumasiotes 12y agoIn the US I had trig and the first semester of calculus in 9th grade (age 13-14). It's not about the country. Educational standards written with people who never learn to read in mind aren't binding on everyone. Moving the standard higher decreases the number of kids clearing it, and moving the standard lower increases the number of kids clearing it, but neither has much effect on what people learn.
- hurin 12y agoMaybe you are thinking of Soviet Russia. As far as I've heard of late the quality of education in Russia has fallen a lot, not to mention bribery, corruption etc. As for the US - yes it is somewhat astonishing, it's probably on a similar level of dysfunctional as healthcare.
- golergka 12y agoI was 14 in 2002, and it still was true.
- hurin 12y agoI just googled "Математика. Учебник для 11 класса" and browsed through the index for a few books released within the last 5-10 years. From the look it's about same level as AP Calculus AB.
- golergka 12y agoTBH, I honestly don't know how representative of overall situation my own experience was, but personally, when I was 14, I was solving this (https://gitorious.org/studies-maths-science/maths57d00/raw/533f51602cc95cdf8edd8df8e59a57663fb87a85:m57d00.pdf https://gitorious.org/studies-maths-science/maths57d00/raw/5... — I think you can determine overall math level without knowing Russian, just by reading math notation part of the tasks), and I doubt that overall level could be really different. I hear a lot of bad things about education system in Russia lately though, so it could get much worse.
- hurin 12y agoYes, I should qualify my experience somewhat - I don't think I learned any math till around grade 6 (btw the town I lived in had the second highest expenditure per student in State - this is not just a underfunded school system problem). English classes were particularly bad as well. I'd imagine in Russia you read Pushkin in first or second grade. In the US I don't think we were assigned an English classic instead of one of those bestselling children novels till grade 7 or 8. Around Highschool it got a lot better, classes became differentiated based on student levels, also AP courses (we were offered the opportunity to take other AP subjects which weren't taught in school for free online as well). Also I certainly don't think IPads are the cure here, as far as I am concerned ed-tech is a blatant scam to build a business from poor administrative use of tax-payer money.
- Grue3 12y ago