3 ms·
You're conflating a lot of issues. 1) Spam is not the same, you didnt ask for it so you are rightly refusing and actively blocking it. 2) Content is not free.
by manigandham 12y ago
You're conflating a lot of issues.
1) Spam is not the same, you didnt ask for it so you are rightly refusing and actively blocking it.
2) Content is not free. Someone had to create it, and they can either charge you directly or let you see it for free by also showing you ads. When you block those ads but still read the content, you're stealing the access/time/production/value of that content without letting the publisher recoup any of their investment or make any profit.
3) I'm not really sure where this anger comes from. Advertising is such a big and growing industry because it works. This is not some evil conspiracy nor are all the companies full of idiots. You will find regular people much like yourself working at all of the advertising agencies, networks and publishers.
Impressions do work. It's not a "belief", it's a fact. Think of it like an empty road with a billboard and a store at the next exit. You can have a blank billboard and see how many people stop at the store. Then put up an ad and measure again. That delta is a significant and measurable difference and with digital advertising, it can be tracked to a very specific level to prove it works. There are also many different types and formats of ads which work in different stages of the sales conversion funnel. YOU might not think it works, but that's not what the massive amount of data and results show every day.
- kyllo 12y agoHere's a thought experiment: Imagine someone invented "smart" sunglasses that detected billboard ads and filtered them out so the wearer saw only a blank billboard instead of an ad. By driving down the road while wearing them and not seeing the billboards ads, would I therefore be "stealing" from ClearChannel? My anger comes from the fact that businesses are constantly trying to sell me things by harassing me. I have no problem with paying for things that I actually want, and I gladly pay for content if it will make the ads go away, but it normally doesn't. If you buy a subscription to a news site you still see ads. I pay plenty for content when I buy books, though. If people are not willing to pay for the content on a site like BuzzFeed, it just shows how little that content is worth. And advertising is really not a growing industry, at least not as a share of GDP. It's basically a zero-sum game. Online advertising spending is only growing to the extent that it is replacing spending on radio, TV and billboard advertising. Source: http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2014-03-03/advertisings-century-of-flat-line-growth http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2014-03-03/advertisings...
- manigandham 12y agoYou're talking about different things. 1) Impressions do work, that's what my example was about. 2) Ads are the trade for free access to content. If the ads paid for the road you're driving on, then yes you'd be "stealing" access to the road by ignoring the ads. The businesses aren't harassing you, they're just spending on ads and those ads show up on publishers who have opted to use the advertising model instead of subscriptions/paid access. There are lots of issues with paid access like not enough demand, price sensitivity, hard to gain new traffic/shares, etc. Advertising is just more reliable and easier to implement and allows for quicker growth. If sites are using subscriptions and still show you ads (and you're actually logged in as a paying member) then they're trying to extract more money or the price is not covering all of their costs or something in between. That's an issue with the publisher, not the ad companies. Everything is zero-sum when measured to GDP because there's only 100% of the GDP to go around. GDP is a VERY big number and it's growing, and thus the absolute dollar amount of advertising is also growing and outpacing supply of inventory. That being said, advertising won't become a larger part of GDP because there are only so many buyers that also have to grow as businesses first to increase their total budgets. It makes sense that it tracks in line with the economy and it's not really feasible to make big changes because businesses are not going to stop spending on something like manufacturing their product to instead divert it to advertising.
- scrollaway 12y ago> If the ads paid for the road you're driving on, then yes you'd be "stealing" access to the road by ignoring the ads. Something which boggles the mind is how a lot of people who work in advertising still don't understand the concept that you do not have an innate right to your users' brains. Putting it down to the technical level: When you send me bits, I have complete right and control to refuse them on a selective basis. I have a right to write a program that will refuse them on a selective basis. I have a right to share that program with other people, and those other peope have a right to run said program. Adblock is not stealing, no matter how much you want it to be. If ads are paying for the content, the business that uses them should be made aware of the risks of adblock and the portion of people who are not willing to accept ads (and at which level they won't accept them). Advertising in its current form is broken by design. It's a wonder it works at all. And yeah maybe we would be better off without it. The businesses that depend on the kind of ads adblock blocks tend to be shitty, low-hanging fruits, "appeal to the masses" sort of sites. Yes exactly, Buzzfeed. That's a debate for another day, but the point still remains: broken by design. Don't blame the users who just fucking want to be left alone.
- vitd 12y ago"When you block those ads but still read the content, you're stealing the access/time/production/value of that content without letting the publisher recoup any of their investment or make any profit." No, you're not. Just as you're not stealing when you mute commercials on TV or go to the bathroom, or fast-forward past them, or use the 30-second skip button. If they want to try that business model, it's on them to make it work, not on users to make it work for them. They're saying, "Hey, we think our content is good enough that you'll put up with huge percentages of our pages being taken up by other irrelevant stuff." If it turns out the annoying stuff is too annoying, that's their problem to fix, and not putting up with it is in absolutely no way stealing.
- panglott 12y agoIf you don't want content to be free, perhaps you should not make it free? Lots of media IS free (say, Wikipedia) and there's lots of free stuff to read out there on the Web. Similarly there is a lot of paid content going over HTTP, and my Kindle and iTunes apps are full of it. Did someone have to create yet another dull top 10 list or quizzicle? Maybe, but the value of this writing, as determined by what a person would be willing to pay for it, is pretty low, aka essentially nil. Putting this up for free on the Web with advertising is one monetization strategy, but the simple fact that it's up for free doesn't create a reader obligation to look at the ads. Listeners don't have an obligation to contribute to NPR, either: they do so because they value the institution and its media.