8 ms·
FBI overstated forensic hair matches in nearly all trials before 2000
- dmurray 12y agoHow does this not get all FBI testimony thrown out by judges? If there is an organisation who pays its employees to lie in court, and they are known to suffer no ill consequences for lying, all of those employees' testimony should be considered worthless.
- themartorana 12y agoI fear that even with this gross miscarriage of justice over decades, people may not be granted a retrial. It's the entire reason the Innocence Project exists. http://www.innocenceproject.org/free-innocent/improve-the-law/fact-sheets/access-to-post-conviction-dna-testing http://www.innocenceproject.org/free-innocent/improve-the-la... I've never understood how the possibility of new evidence doesn't immediately reopen a case (in general). I thought we wanted real, actual, blind justice based only on facts and absolutely nothing else. It turns out it is rarely that simple.
- Retric 12y ago$
- johndevor 12y agoThis is a valid point. Those in law enforcement want to rise up the ranks. Closing cases quickly and getting promoted does come with a nice raise.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoSee also: The prosecutor problem.
- MCRed 12y agoAll people have an agenda. Their agenda generally favors themselves in some way or another. We, as the potential victims of injustice want a real, actual, scientific, blind justice system that presumes innocence and requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt, checked by a jury that can nullify laws, and the like. Politicians want to be "tough on crime" so they appoint judges and prosecutors who get convictions. Judges want to be re-elected because they are "tough on crime" (in places where judges are elected) Prosecutors want to have a successful career so they will do anything they can get away with to get a conviction. The police want to have the case be off their hands and to be "closed" so that their stats look good because it's good for their career because the Mayor wants to be "tough on crime" and so the police find the first plausible suspect and try to build a case. All these organizations are in cahoots, literally, and so no prosecutor is going to indict a judge or cop unless they absolutely have to. So long as the public can be lead to believe they live in a society with the "rule of law" not the "rule of man" then nothing more needs to be done. And the public is very gullible! (Especially when you control the schools and you raise them to be gullible.) IT's not that these people are evil. ITs that they are self interested. The founding fathers attempted to put in checks and balances and they did a damn good job. But over the past 200 years, they have been systematically eroded.
- wongarsu 12y agoBut there are far more potential victims of injustice than politicians, judges etc. Since we're talking about a democracy here, it should be possible for this majority to create an environment where the selfish interests of politicians and judges align with the need to protect innocents. Yet this same democracy creates an environment where protecting innocents puts officials at a disadvantage. Things are clearly very backwards.
- task_queue 12y agoConviction rates matter. Also the justice system "congestion" that judges and prosecutors are always pointing to as an excuse for their failure to uphold real justice.
- ars 12y agoThey didn't lie, they believed that the hair really matched. The problem was that the method they used, i.e. how they were taught, was incorrect. So it's not so easy to throw it out as you might suspect - it's the job of jury to decide if the evidence is "good" (they hear lots of evidence, much of it conflicting). True, the jury relied on false information on what counts as good. But because the jury accepted the evidence undoing that is not as simple as you think unless there are specific laws about it.
- Riseed 12y agoPerhaps we are lacking in specific laws about reopening such cases (I do not claim to know). However, I think the lack of specific laws (and/or the difficulty in creating them) is one reason there exists a general law about it: clemency.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoDoesn't seem like they lived up to the "beyond a reasonable shadow of doubt" standard in the methodology, whether they believed they were telling the truth or not. The methods could not support the level of certainty they were obligated to obtain.
- scotty79 12y agoToo big to fail?
- r00fus 12y agoJustice needs a meta-moderation function.
- smtucker 12y agoIt does have one. But the situation has to be very bad for enough people to be willing invoke it.
- ChristianBundy 12y agoAm I missing something, or are you talking about a violent revolution?
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y agoSurely there's a spectrum of active participation.
- reubenmorais 12y agoI don't know if this is what smtucker meant, but isn't the Supreme Court supposed to fill this role?
- MCRed 12y agoSupreme Court, Legislative and ultimately voting are all mechanisms that should moderate corruption. The problem is all of these mechanisms are controlled by the government, which is the source of the corruption. Even voting-- I do believe that the voting machines are corrupted about 50/50- half for democrats and half for republicans. But that only serves to reinforce our one-party-with-two-wings system and exclude greens and libertarians. I long for the day when all of the nationally televised presidential debates include the Libertarian and Green candidates. (At the 2004 & 2008 elections they put their differences aside and travelled to the debates and tried to get in, and got arrested attempting to do so as a protest of being excluded. And then had a libertarian-green presidential debate. Loved it.)
- smtddr 12y agoI don't know about a "violent revolution", but I'm very skeptical of fixing a broken system while working within the rules of said system.
- datashovel 12y agoThis only reinforces my perspective that even highest levels of law enforcement need to be operating in a fully transparent way.
- researcher88 12y agoReminded me of George Carlin's last standup special, where he said "it's part of their [cops'] job to commit perjury whenever it helps the state's case": https://youtu.be/jgxyCudDiM4 https://youtu.be/jgxyCudDiM4
- fiatmoney 12y agoThe fact that the matching process is not double-blind indicates that it is designed to be corrupt.
- polymatter 12y agoNot being double-blind makes it cheaper. Hence takes less budget, lower taxes, everybody cheers. Anybody proposing to make it double-blind is going to need to find the money, either from other departments or by raising taxes. Without a chorus of public support behind them, this is a very hard sell. And easily reversed after the next election.
- mikeash 12y agoI'm constantly amazed at how terrible criminal forensic science seems to be. Everything except DNA matching appears to be no better than voodoo, and even the DNA stuff is tricky. Is there something about this particular field that attracts charlatans and incompetents? Is it purely a motivational problem, wherein the people who pay for these results are more interested in a conviction and don't care if it's right?
- fenomas 12y agoSome time ago when I was reading about the accuracy of fingerprint analysis (similarly a horror show), the culprit seemed to be the professional association of analysts. IIRC their official line was that fingerprint analysis was 100% accurate(!), and they forbade members from taking part in research studies on the subject...
- revelation 12y agoDNA testing may be theorethically sound, but in practice it's restricted to testing about 13 different loci, which is a miniscule porton of the actual information at hand. Starting from that weak position, the FBI then ignores basic statistics: http://freakonomics.com/2008/08/19/are-the-fbis-probabilities-about-dna-matches-crazy/ http://freakonomics.com/2008/08/19/are-the-fbis-probabilitie...
- MCRed 12y agoThink about the hypothesis that all fingerprints are unique. That's voodoo. First off you would have to fingerprint everybody to check it. And secondly they don't actually match fingerprints, but match a description of the fingerprint that throws out most of the data (like taking a million books and reducing them all into one byte hashes of their text, and then claiming that Moby Dick is a plagiarized version of Henry V because they produce the same 8-bit hash!) The problem is, these things were indicators, but they have been manipulated to be used as if they were proof. If the suspect is a red head male, and the witness describes seeing a red head male, then the jury is inclined to think that's the same guy. IT's human nature. Even in New York City. Where there are at least 84,000 red headed males!
- realusername 12y ago
- mwsherman 12y agoLegal arguments, like most things in life, reward narrative over truth. “Truth” is an unbelievably high bar to pass – even basic ideas like confidence level are beyond the understanding of the legal system. “Beyond a reasonable doubt” is actually a decent epistemic standard. The problem is that juries and judges are not exposed to the information that would lead to reasonable doubt in these cases. So basic epistemology already makes bad outcomes likely. Add the incentives (political, organizational) in cases like these, and terrible things happen.
- smsm42 12y agoThe problem is the incentives go to one side (winning the case) without a counterbalance incentive (being not punished for misconduct). If police misconduct such as perjury and fraud routinely led to grave consequences for the person doing it, the balance of the incentives would be closer to what it needs to be. But the Blue Wall[1] and general reluctance of the justice system to punish their own, prevents it from happening. Even when the fraud is discovered, the perpetrators frequently are not sanctioned in any way, the worst that happens is that convictions get thrown out, but that does not create counter-incentive. Thus, no balance. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_wall_of_silence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_wall_of_silence
- brohoolio 12y agoAm I the only one who wonders what this costs each time something like this happens?
- datashovel 12y agoIf you mean the cost in terms of trust citizens have in these institutions, then certainly I think the answer is no.
- smegel 12y agoI wonder if partial DNA "matching" will one day be the hair strand analysis of our time.
- MCRed 12y agoA few years ago I remember reading reports of the FBI forensic labs doing much worse-- taking evidence from the crime scene and contaminating evidence taken from the accused with it so that it would produce a "match" and the like. It was a big scandal. In fact over the past 20 years I've heard this story at least a dozen times-- where crime "labs" at different levels of government and in different states (eg: state labs, federal lagbs, etc) were caught doing this. And when it happens, that isn't enough to get people to be able to appeal unless they have evidence the lab did it in their specific case. One of the problems of our system is that the criminal system is lacks checks and balances. The judges, prosecutors, police all work for the government. They all have the same interests-- they all report to people who want to look "tough on crime". Since the police immediately take over crime scenes and collect the evidence and then get the evidence analyzed, they have a lot of power to be corrupt in the interest of more convictions-- and the consequences are negligible for being caught. Whose going to try a dirty cop? You can shoot a guy in the back on video and never get put on trial for it in this country. (I left Texas when a cop gunned down an unarmed black kid who was on his knees crawling away from him... shooting him multiple times in the back... on my college campus. The cop lost his job and then joined the police force in a suburb. No charges were filed. Apparently a black kid crawling away was "threatening" to the white cop. Alas, I moved to a liberal state and was then myself the victim state corruption- though fortunately, the damage was only $3k to a lawyer.) This is why I think any evidence submitted in court needs to come from an independant lab, done in a double blind way, and with several audit cases sent to that lab regularly (eg: taking dna from people not involved in crimes and send it in as if it was part of an investigation and see if they are fabricating evidence.) The idea that the government is independant and objective is to me, now that I'm older and have seen these scandals over the years, laughable. Every time it happens everyone acts like its' a rare thing. It's not.
- PythonicAlpha 12y agoI think, the problem is similar to the trouble we have with judges in our country. One judge recently said something that really put a very shady light on many of his colleagues. I regret, that I don't remember it exactly, what he said. The trouble in my opinion with some judges in my country and with the police in some countries is, that everybody just assumes, that because they work for law enforcement, they have a high level of integrity. But when you look how they are educated, the subject "integrity" is not even touched (I even don't think, that it is taught in law schools). In my country, when somebody is already a judge, there is nearly no chance at all, that this person will be held accountable for misjudging. I think, not even the highest courts can replace a judge that repeatedly and knowingly is bending the law. At least I don't know of any case at all where a judge was punished or even replaced. And don't think, that all judgments are correct in my country. In my opinion, when there is one thing to be learned from history, it is that any person can err and even the best meaning persons can change into dictators over time depending on situations.
- late2part 12y agoAgain we see that our law enforcement branch is overreaching, acting in error, and effectively breaking the law. What penalty is appropriate for this? How do we rebuild our country to stop this? I believe the answer is to hold the perpetrators responsible. Easy to say, but we need financial and jail times far beyond the pain these people cause. We need to root out this corruption, whether it's intentional or negligent.
- o0-0o 12y agoI posit white collar crime should carry more severe penalties than blue collar crime.
- ryanlol 12y agoHave you noticed that at least in the US, white collar crime already carries ridiculously high sentences compared to the rest of the world?
- o0-0o 12y agoThat's not my point, but yeah since you mention it.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoThe severity of the penalties is totally irrelevant if there is no enforcement and the existing penalties are quite sufficient if there is.
- nitrogen 12y agoThis is an interesting perspective with which I am currently inclined to disagree. Could you provide more rationale to justify the idea that nonviolent crimes should be punished more severely than violent crimes?
- eropple 12y agoI'm not that poster, but people with more power should be held to account more strictly for abusing it. While there are noteworthy exceptions, violent crimes are (generally speaking) low-leverage crimes that rarely impact more than a handful of people, whereas the ramifications of even something as "non-violent" as this sort of fraud can be significantly more harmful to much bigger groups of people. (I am also of the opinion that corporate protections are largely bullshit and that executives and boards should be civilly and criminally liable for wrongdoings perpetuated by their companies. Probably the only way to make them act decently.)
- malandrew 12y agoThey really oughta have a "blind" approach to testing forensic evidence where samples are prepared by other forensic professionals to be sufficiently similar but not matches and real matches, neither of which are from a real trial. The forensic examiners should never know when they have evidence from a real trial.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pdkl95 12y agoJust call it a variation of the well-known "line up" that everybody already understands.
- godgod 12y agoJustice for all...unless you are dealing with the FBI.
- augustocallejas 12y agoThis is a great short documentary on the history of hair analysis at the FBI: http://www.retroreport.org/video/how-dna-changed-the-world-of-forensics/ http://www.retroreport.org/video/how-dna-changed-the-world-o...
- endymi0n 12y agoI'm thinking about how much their incentivization might have influenced them. One fundamental difference between German and Anglo-American law is the prosecuter's task, as mandated by law. In the US it is to get as many convictions as possible (guilty or not). In Germany, the law wants a prosecutor to "find out the truth and use all evidence against AND also for a defendant". Methinks the former case is one of the driving forces behind the "Bazaar" mentality.
- Illniyar 12y agoI did not understand from the article what "overstated" means. Was it a partial match that they described as 100% accurate? did they hide the statistical probabilities? was the evidence faked?
- asveikau 12y agoThe headline is inaccurate. The article says more than 20 years preceding the year 2000. They are not precise about what more than 20 years means, but I read that as late 1970s to 2000. From the headline and HN title it would seem like it starts from the beginning of time. Edit: I see now that the hn title matches the wapo headline, changing to reflect that. Still a bad headline.