5 ms·
> People have to come to terms with each other without attacking each other or we end up in a civil war. Are you talking about physical attacks or mere vigorou
by wpietri 12y ago
> People have to come to terms with each other without attacking each other or we end up in a civil war.
Are you talking about physical attacks or mere vigorous disagreement? If the former, I agree, but that seems off topic. If the latter, then could you please name some major societal changes that happened without disagreement so vigorous that people felt attacked?
I also think that for topics of social justice, your standard is one-sided. Historically oppressed groups are attacked, and not just verbally. Look at America's long history of lynching, for example. Or gay bashing, both physical and verbal. A standard that requires people pursuing social justice to be forever meek but doesn't as vigorously require that of those sustaining injustice is in effect a standard that helps maintain injustice.
> But now you're talking about generalities when we're dealing with individuals.
The article is about general patterns, so perhaps our best compromise is that we are talking about general patterns of individuals. If you want to talk about an individual case, we could certainly do that. But that would be a change of topic.
> Your counterargument seems
I was addressing the discussion here. If it appears to relate to one of the many points in that article, I apologize; that was not my intention.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> Are you talking about physical attacks or mere vigorous disagreement? There is a distinction to be drawn between vigorous disagreement and intentionally causing harm to the other party. Trying to get someone fired or similar is not a "physical" attack but it is certainly an attack. > I also think that for topics of social justice, your standard is one-sided. Historically oppressed groups are attacked, and not just verbally. Look at America's long history of lynching, for example. Or gay bashing, both physical and verbal. A standard that requires people pursuing social justice to be forever meek but doesn't as vigorously require that of those sustaining injustice is in effect a standard that helps maintain injustice. It isn't a double standard. Neither side should be engaged in any such thing and anyone who does is wrong regardless of which side they're on. > The article is about general patterns, so perhaps our best compromise is that we are talking about general patterns of individuals. If you want to talk about an individual case, we could certainly do that. But that would be a change of topic. It's not about a specific individual case, it's about the concept of applying generalizations to individuals. "There is more variation within a race than between races."
- wpietri 12y ago> It isn't a double standard. Neither side should be engaged in any such thing and anyone who does is wrong regardless of which side they're on. My point isn't about the standard. It's about selective enforcement. That is, the people I see telling people interested in social justice that they're just too darned strident don't obviously demonstrate an equal desire to police the people causing the injustice. > It's not about a specific individual case, it's about the concept of applying generalizations to individuals. I think that can be done poorly, but I think it's a generally useful first-pass heuristic. Especially so the way I'm applying it here, which is to say that my fellow white dudes should spend more time listening to voices they would not otherwise hear before holding for on topics which they are much more likely to be ignorant. Those who have already done the listening are not harmed by that.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> My point isn't about the standard. It's about selective enforcement. Then you're trying to fix the end that isn't broken. The problem is not that people are objecting to bad behavior in the one case, it's that they're not objecting in the other. > I think that can be done poorly, but I think it's a generally useful first-pass heuristic. So is not interviewing black job applicants because they are more likely to have received a poor education. But we ought not to do that because the heuristic is often wrong and the individuals have no ability to control what box you put them in when it is.
- wpietri 12y agoThanks for your advice on how I should spend my time, but I think otherwise. If you would like to fix the hypocrites, you are welcome to do so. I think the way to fix that is reducing the power imbalances so that the shitty opinions of formerly dominant groups are irrelevant to the currently downtrodden. As I mentioned elsewhere, I value civil dialogue, but I value civil rights more. When the two conflict, I am ok with some incivility in the service of fixing bigger problems. >So is not interviewing black job applicants because they are more likely to have received a poor education. But we ought not to do that because the heuristic is often wrong and the individuals have no ability to control what box you put them in when it is. No, we ought not to do that because it reinforces a major societal oppression of black people. If you've ever run a hiring process, you'll know you use all sorts of possibly-unfair heuristics. The point of hiring isn't to be maximally fair to every individual; it's to get good people while not contributing to negative externalities like, say, America's centuries-long history of being shitty to various minority groups.