4 ms·
Anybody have the opposite perspective on this? Supposedly, "most people" nowadays think that children should not be allowed to roam, but I only ever hear from
by sanderjd 12y ago
Anybody have the opposite perspective on this?
Supposedly, "most people" nowadays think that children should not be allowed to roam, but I only ever hear from people who think that's ridiculous. For instance, I just scrolled the comments here and they are literally 100% "I can't believe how paranoid we've become". The conversation I read and hear on this is so one-sided that I really have no sense for what the argument of the other side even is.
- sneak 12y agoI think this is just media sensationalist bullshit. You wouldn't hire a ten year old to babysit your six year old. End of story.
- abfan1127 12y agounder particular circumstances, yes I would. If my 10 year old was responsible and my 6 year old was responsive to my 10 year old's responsibility, I'd let them go down the street to the park. What's sensationalist bullshit is the garbage the police are spouting and the garbage CPS will be spouting as they take kids from their parents. They seem to think the foster care system will do a better job of raising the kids than these parents how have raised kids to be able to play at the park unattended.
- mml 12y agoYou're completely right. I wouldn't pay a 10 year old, but I'd have one watch my kids for a bit while I nip down to the store.
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoI routinely rode my bike around the neighborhood at that age. On Saturday, I'd make my own bowl of cereal for breakfast, then ride around until I found my friends grouped on their bikes and we'd hang out as long as we wanted or until supper at 5:00 PM sharp (don't be late!). Ten years old is not an infant, and can responsibly navigate their own neighborhood if trained and allowed to learn.
- zeroonetwothree 12y agoI watched my brother while my parents were gone when I was 6 and he was 4. There's a huge difference between siblings and strangers.
- Crito 12y agoI frequently babysat my six year old twin brothers when I was eight. You should seriously consider the possibility that you are the victim of media sensationalism. The world is safer for children today than it ever has been. Children do not need round-the-clock adult supervision.
- jqm 12y agoI babysat my younger brothers and sisters at 11 for a few hours here and there. We had neighbors and a phone. I knew how to use it. I credit this early responsibility for a lot of valuable workplace attributes I have today.
- mml 12y agoThey exist, believe me, I know a few, and it's pretty terrifying. Law-enforcement is basically backing their paranoia and confirming their biases on the daily. It sucks, but there's little that non-terrified people can do, without risking having their kids abducted by the state, which is actually significantly more terrifying, and far more likely than the prospect of stranger abduction.
- rsync 12y ago"It sucks, but there's little that non-terrified people can do" Although running away from the problem is perhaps not the most noble solution, I would like to point out that this entire discussion and the behavior of all the actors involved is completely irrelevant in a small, rural community made up of large landowners. You can indeed live apart from these norms and depending on your matrix of needs/wants/conveniences, it might even be a lower cost of living.
- rjsw 12y agoI scanned the comments below the article, they seemed to me to be mostly against children being able to roam.
- sanderjd 12y agoHa, totally didn't do that. I guess I'm self-selecting my bubble by preferring to read comments on the sites I frequent while ignoring actual article comments. Thanks for the pointer. Edit: I went and read the comments on the article, and I'd say that they're about evenly divided. Lots of people saying similar stuff to what you see hear, but also those saying that you can't do this "in today's world".
- natch 12y agoThese discussions often hover around how safe our current world is, and how any dangers are just perceived dangers, where the perception is way out of proportion to the reality. The claim is people have wild perceptions influenced by dramatic media coverage, and the world is just as safe as, or safer than, it ever was. But, I'm not so sure. I think the reality has changed too. Since the days when we used to walk five miles to the toy store, everyone has better access to technology, transportation, and information, than they did, and this is a double edged sword that enables both good and bad people to have more capabilities. Also not just perception is the fact that Reagan defunded mental health treatment, leading to the massive homeless situation we have (I'm not saying homeless people or mentally ill people are necessarily dangerous, but as with any unknown variable, their presence does make it harder to determine when a place is safe or not). Still, in this particular case it seems like the police went way over a line of reasonableness... maybe not in picking the kids up, but in what happened next.
- sanderjd 12y agoI'm pretty curious about this line of thinking, because I share it to some degree. But it also seems to me that the statistics suggest the world is safer. It seems that we feel less safe despite living in a safer world.
- ericd 12y agoI think this is largely from the persistent messaging from the news, etc. that we're not safe. Even if you completely dismiss it rationally, it's hard to keep it from seeping into your less rational thinking.
- natch 12y agoI think both sides are right. On the one hand, we actually are safer. But on the other hand, our tolerance to risk is way down. And one of the main reasons we are safer is because we behave more safely. By doing things like keeping children close to adults who can supervise them.
- 12y ago
- Crito 12y agoRecently a playground near my apartment got torn down. I was talking to my mother on the phone recently, and mentioned how tragic it was that playgrounds were being torn down across the nation in the name of "safety" (http://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/19/science/19tierney.html http://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/19/science/19tierney.html). To my great surprise, she disagreed. She thought it was a good thing. This is a woman that took me to countless playgrounds when I was a kid, and let me roam free in hundreds of acres of forest whenever I wanted. Somehow, after successfully raising me "free-range", she had a change of heart. I couldn't tease anything out of her besides "it's dangerous, kids could get hurt". I don't have a root-cause for her about-face. I suspect either the influence of media or that something happens when adults who have raised children become elderly. Maybe without kids at home, parents start dwelling on the past and fixate on everything that could have gone wrong.
- fencepost 12y agoOne way to get her to think about it: next time it comes up, say "Huh, I didn't realize you were such a terrible parent. Were you trying to get me killed by taking me to all those parks?"
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]