2 ms·
(If you know what the difference is between an amplifier and an attenuator, you should probably skip this comment.) The point that the article tries to establi
by dsr_ 12y ago
(If you know what the difference is between an amplifier and an attenuator, you should probably skip this comment.)
The point that the article tries to establish (and, IMHO, fails) is that there are two things going on:
S: The signal that comes in.
V: The perceived volume that reaches your ear after the signal is decoded, amplified, and transduced by speakers.
S influences V, but so does the volume control on your TV or receiver, the efficiency of your speakers, and how far away you are. The fact that S and V are different is what allows your TV station to claim with a straight face that the perception of sound is not under their control. But they're also lying, because...
TV stations take content from many sources (local commercials, network commercials, local programming, network programming) and while they probably pass the network stuff straight through, they still have to adjust the level of everything else so that it is not too distractingly different from what the network feed. Local advertisers will complain vociferously if Billy Bob Auto's 35 seconds of dancing cheerleaders clustered up around old Billy Bob himself is a smidge quieter than Jesse Ventura's minigun chopping down trees in the edited-for-TV rerun of Predator that just went to commercial break.
So they run all the sources through compressors, expanders and limiters to get a more or less equalized top output volume. The sources have all been produced with this expectation, so we have the exact same loudness war that has been mentioned on HN recently, only on TV instead of on CD and FM and MP3.
In the end, you get problems at every commercial break where the program has lots of dynamics and ends on a quiet bit. The "normal" Billy Bob Auto ad wouldn't sound so loud if it had happened right after the car chase.