3 ms·
I think the problem is they are assuming that the Dyson spheres are relatively close to the star and hence the black body temperature is relatively high. If the
by danieltillett 12y ago
I think the problem is they are assuming that the Dyson spheres are relatively close to the star and hence the black body temperature is relatively high. If the spheres are far out or arranged in shells then their black body temperature could be only slightly above the background radiation temperature. You will not be able to detect a galaxy filled with such spheres like that optically, only by gravity.
Edit. I just wanted to add that any civilisation capable of building Dyson spheres would not waste any energy that can be captured. The emissions of any energy at any temperature more than slightly above the background radiation level would be inefficient.
- gus_massa 12y agoSince you essentially can't store energy for long times [1], you still have to dissipate it as heat after use. For example, you can use energy in computer calculation. Other use is transport operations (like car and naval ships) they move but the energy is transformed into air or water movement and later into heat. Another use is steel blending, you change the shape of the metal, that makes the metal slightly hot. ... Anything you do, you get a lot of heat to dispose. Also, to dispose that heat fast enough, the dissipater has to be hot or big, because the black body radiation is the faster you can emit. A big dissipater require a lot of material, a hot dissipater waste energy, it's a tradeoff. [1] You can store energy for a looong time making coal and burying it, the plants we have done that unintentionally . An alternative is to make a lot of aluminum and try to avoid the oxidation. But they don't look like a sensible use of energy for a civilization.
- ridgeguy 12y agoRough estimates give me fairly low surface temperatures for Dyson spheres having the average diameter of Pluto's orbit (~ 5.85e9 km) or the Kuiper Belt (~6e10 km). The Sun radiates ~ 10e26 Watts, or ~ 1.21e8 W/m^2 at a temperature of ~ 5800°K. Given that radiated power is proportional to (area)*T^4 and making simplifying assumptions about emissivity, etc., I get that a Dyson sphere around our Sun at Pluto's orbit would have a temperature of about 76°K, and a Dyson with a diameter of the Kuiper Belt would have a surface temperature of about 24°K. So if the radiator is large enough (i.e., if your civilization is sufficiently advanced), you can dump stellar levels of power to space at quite modest temperatures.
- danieltillett 12y agoNice work. You don’t need a solid Dyson sphere of that size, just IR mirrors or Fresnel lenses (these could down to a molecule in thickness) to direct the IR energy into collectors. I would imagine that it would be more efficient to have multiple shells of Dyson spheres with each capturing the waste heat of its immediate inner shell. I read through the original paper and the lowest object temperature they were able to detect was around 150˚K. Any Dyson sphere dumping that amount of energy would be pretty inefficient.