7 ms·
The hacked Sony emails show how Silicon Valley dealmaking really works
- empressplay 12y agoIt ain't what you know, it's who you know.
- mickgardner 12y agoThis is very normal and how most business works.
- michaelochurch 12y agoMost business people don't claim to be uber-smart and visionary. They just try to do their jobs like everyone else. Do you think the CEO of McDonalds expects anyone to believe that he's some prodigy who's "transforming the world of hamburgers"? Silicon Valley created its own pedestal of "meritocracy" so when we find out that it's no more meritocratic than any other business-- and, in fact, often less so-- the black eye is deserved.
- pdkl95 12y agoIt may be normal and a common practice, but none of that implies that such practices should be seen as "normal" or used at all. Ethics cannot be derived from argumentum ad antiquitatem or argumentum ad populum.
- paulhauggis 12y agoIt's just human nature and I seriously doubt it will ever change. Business is usually built on a relationship of trust, so of course if you know someone you will get better treatment than if you are a stranger. A good example is a new startup giving an executive a free account to try to get their interest. According to you, it's unethical, but it actually helps small companies compete.
- afarrell 12y agoThe problem is that "normal" has two meanings: 1) common 2) according to social norms Neither of which are actually the same as ethics. I'll make a slightly stronger argument though. You should do business with those you trust. There is no rigorous rational way to determine someone's trustworthiness, so you must get to know them and see how they respond to situations and ultimately rely on your intuition for making decisions.
- rhizome 12y agoI thought it was all about meritocracy now.
- verbin217 12y agoWhen conducting business merit is determined by efficacy which is almost certainly enhanced by familiarity.
- afarrell 12y agoCan we all just agree that while individual technology choices may be decided according to some figure of merit, business is a messy multi-biased thing and move on?
- wglb 12y agoOr a little more precisely, who knows you.
- mml 12y agoA parochial old boys (and girls) club? You don't say?!
- michaelochurch 12y agoApparently Evan Spiegel and Dick Costolo have some kind of Ancient Greek thing going on. Nothing else could explain his being so enamored of such a mediocre mind.
- forrestthewoods 12y agoI see nothing shocking or even interesting here. Yes, people who know each other communicate with one another?
- michaelochurch 12y agoI find Dick Costolo's gushing about Evan Spiegel indicative of some kind of creepy mancrush. I'm not joking. This is obviously going on if you read the way the man is using words. While those things are rarely consummated and both men in them identify as heterosexual (and probably many of them have never had sex with another man) they are incredibly common in the Valley: weird mancrush relationships between two men who are, nonetheless, aggressively heterosexual (and yet share intimate details of their sexual exploits, allowing them to live vicariously through the other). It's one of the reason why there's such a strong age discrimination culture. By the time you're 30, you pretty much have to make it on merit because 75 percent of the relationships that establish first funding are no longer available (not that a decent person would want to be in that sort of thing because, ick). This type of relationship needs a name, because it's actually (to my knowledge) never seen in the gay community, and it's usually focused on the older, established man supporting the younger man's career with the express purpose of living vicariously through a young sociopath (who can presumably tear apart young women with the career support and money he's given, giving the older benefactor some vicarious "bull glow"). It's aggressively heterosexual (since extremes of high-frequency sexuality are the point of it; that's why the midlife crisis benefactor supports the career of the young sociopath) but deeply homoerotic... thus paradoxical and, however you take it, really disturbing and creepy. For an example of this, see Michael Scott and Ryan Howard in The Office. It was written in to that show as a joke, but Sand Hill Road runs on that kind of shit.
- BinaryIdiot 12y ago...what? Why does...why...ugh, I don't even know what your post is about. You want to label people with man crushes? I don't get it.
- NhanH 12y agoIn general, I like your posts and opinions: clearly you have experience and is honest with your jaded view -- something that the dreamy younger blood like me very much appreciate. On the other hand, the increased frequency in personal attack to the various characters in SV, and unsubstantiated at that, is getting quite unreasonable. It's firmly what we would call "gratuitous negativity". I hope you would get back to your better writings: constructive advices. It's always easy to trash something, offering the solution is the hard (and fun) part!.
- presty 12y ago> In one thread last April, Lynton asks Costolo for a favor: Can he help get his wife’s news website’s Twitter handle, @LASchoolReport, verified? Costolo replies the same day: “I will have this looked at today and get it taken care of. Stay tuned!” > > Twitter’s policy for verifying accounts has frustrated many, so this isn’t an outrageous request. But it appears even a line directly to the top doesn’t always work. LA School Report, which covers the Los Angeles education universe in impressive detail, remains unverified. rah!
- researcher88 12y agoEvan Spiegel is clearly smart but it's weird to hail him as some visionary when someone else came up with the concept and someone else coded the app. When an app takes off like that, is it even possible to fail running the company? You get funding, all types of input from experts and all you need to do is guide the rocket you are attached to.
- sparkzilla 12y agoI don't know anything about Spiegel, but have you ever tried to guide a rocket you are attached to? I can't imagine it's all that easy.
- droidist2 12y agoIt's kind of like riding a cat and trying to tell him where to go. He either ends up stopping to clean his bollocks or he brings you into the litter box.
- sparkzilla 12y agoThat's a big cat.
- researcher88 12y agoAs a metaphor, it will get you to outerspace but you may miss your target. You don't actually need to guide it, there's so much thrust/traction that you'd have to be super talented and purposely trying to sabotage it for it to fail. That being said, Snapchat has made some incredibly good decisions, new products and so forth.
- nailer 12y agoDo you have a link for that? Wikipedia has Spiegel listed as a developer (but that's unreferenced too).
- godzillabrennus 12y agoSee Digg for a case study on how bad execution post launch during iterative stages can crush a business.
- oelmekki 12y agoI have mixed feelings about this article. In one hand, this is a good thing that journalists are investigating leaks. This is a lot of data, and regular citizen can not take the time for analyzing it all. That's quite what we expect from a journalist doing a proper job. On the other hand, not just any data does yield newsworthy information. I know it's sad to have spent that many time without finding anything of interest, but after reading this article, I have a strange feeling of voyeurism without having learn anything that would be deemed "of public interest".