4 ms·
Thorium reactors may be useful on earth. But the hype is misplaced for space probes. Either they need maintenance (extracting fission products from the fuel) or
by the8472 12y ago
Thorium reactors may be useful on earth. But the hype is misplaced for space probes. Either they need maintenance (extracting fission products from the fuel) or closed cycle processing which makes them quite bulky (by space mission standards, not by nuclear reactor standards).
RTGs and stirling engines are fairly lightweight and compact. reactors provide more power per weight, but they have a much higher minimum weight.
And molten salts aren't exactly the most hassle-free technology there is. they are highly corrosive, so you have to compromise on the materials you use and it also strongly limits their lifetimes.
RTGs on the other hand often operate long beyond their intended lifetime, albeit at reduced capacity.
- tomswartz07 12y agoI think the issue with Stirling Engines is the fact that they have moving parts that could wear and break down. Most (all?) RTGs are for all intents and purposes, solid state.
- the8472 12y agoYes, but I was comparing to molten salt reactors. Stirling engines are still much simpler than reactors, even if they are slightly more complicated than RTGs. AIUI they already have research models that are capable of running for decades without maintenance.
- treetoppin 12y agoI worked for about a year and a half on the ASRG project, specifically doing reliability work for the Stirling engines. They had a bit of a ways to go to prove out the system (its a tricky problem trying to "prove" that your device will last 17 years), but they had made a whole lot of progress. The biggest problem for the project though was that the ASRG wasnt being designed for any one mission, so its performance requirements were a bit of a moving target.
- iwwr 12y ago>I think the issue with Stirling Engines is the fact that they have moving parts that could wear and break down. In NASA's ASRG design there is a stirling generator with only has one moving part: a free piston moving inside a coil, cushioned by the working gas. Wear and tear should be minimal, even for a multi-decade mission. https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/rps/docs/ASRGfacts2_10rev3_21.pdf https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/rps/docs/ASRGfacts2_10rev3_21.p... (page 2)